All subjects · English Language · WEN01 Language: Context and Identity
Convergence and divergence: identity and audience
Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN01 Language: Context and Identity
Pearson's UK AS (8EN0) June 2025 report says the majority of candidates linked texts to Giles' accommodation theory, and the June 2023 WEN01 report praised answers where 'issues of convergence and prestige are well handled'. This Unit 1 lesson uses the idea only for identity and audience in written and multimodal texts; Unit 2 applies it to accents in spoken transcripts. Theories in this lesson are optional supporting knowledge: Pearson IAL mark schemes and WEN01 examiner reports name no theorists, and marks reward analysis of the data (the AO4 descriptors ask you to apply 'theories, concepts and methods to data'). The researchers named here come from Pearson's UK AS English Language (8EN0) examiner reports and published research: use one only when it helps explain a quotation.
The core idea
In Giles' accommodation theory (the first study by name was Giles, Taylor and Bourhis, 1973):
- Convergence: a writer or speaker reduces the differences between their language and their audience's, to win the audience's social approval.
- Divergence: they accentuate the differences, to keep a distinct, positively valued social identity.
In Unit 1 the question is always: which audience is the writer moving towards or away from, and what identity does that construct?
Applying it to written texts
Accommodation is not only about accent in conversation. Writers converge with readers too:
- informal lexis, contractions and direct address with a young audience
- formal lexis and data with officials
- shared references with a community
Pearson's June 2023 WEN01 report credited comments on a writer 'sharing his own experiences of poverty and hunger to converge with them', and on converging with the 'broader secondary audience' reached through social media.
The 8EN0 June 2025 report said higher-level answers recognised that small differences in audience can lead writers to converge or diverge, and warned that some candidates misidentified informal lexis when applying accommodation and face theory.
Mixed audiences and evaluating the idea
- A published text often has a primary and a secondary audience, so a writer can converge with one while diverging from the other (the ethnicity lesson covers code-switching as one way of doing this).
- Divergence can be deliberate identity work: a campaigner who keeps a strong regional voice before national politicians asserts that she represents her community, not their world.
- Evaluate: the theory explains motives, but written texts have mixed audiences, so a writer may converge with one group and diverge from another at the same time. Pearson's 8EN0 reports reward candidates who test or challenge a theory against quotations rather than just naming it.
Worked example
An illustrative youth worker writes to the council: 'Dear Councillors, I write on behalf of the young people of Eastfield. As they'd put it, the youth centre closing is "proper long" for them.'
- Formal opening 'Dear Councillors, I write on behalf of' converges with the council's institutional register.
- Quoting 'proper long' keeps the young people's slang, diverging from council language.
- The quotation is framed ('As they'd put it'), so the writer converges with councillors while representing the young people's voice.
Answer: He converges upwards to gain approval from those with power, while selectively preserving the young people's language to mark them as a distinct group he speaks for; the theory explains both moves at once.
Check yourself
- Convergence means
- adjusting your language to become more like your audience
- emphasising differences from your audience
- using only Standard English
- refusing to speak
Show answer
adjusting your language to become more like your audience. Moving towards.
- A speaker deliberately strengthens her regional accent when talking to officials from the capital. This is
- convergence
- over-accommodation
- divergence
- synthetic personalisation
Show answer
divergence. Accentuating difference to assert identity.
- According to accommodation theory, the main motive for convergence is
- a desire for the audience's social approval
- a desire to confuse the listener
- the rules of Standard English
- the field of the text
Show answer
a desire for the audience's social approval. Approval.
- According to accommodation theory, divergence is mainly motivated by
- wanting to be liked by the listener
- forgetting the listener's dialect
- a word limit
- keeping a distinct social identity
Show answer
keeping a distinct social identity. Group identity.
- A charity article for teenagers uses 'you guys', contractions and gaming references. In accommodation terms, the writer is
- diverging from a young audience
- converging with a young audience
- using elaborated code
- showing political power
Show answer
converging with a young audience. Matching the audience's style.
- Which is a fair evaluation point about applying accommodation theory to published texts?
- The theory only applies to written texts
- Convergence never happens in writing
- The theory proves every writer is insincere
- Writers often have mixed audiences, so they may converge with one group while diverging from another
Show answer
Writers often have mixed audiences, so they may converge with one group while diverging from another. Mixed audiences complicate it.
- A rapper keeps his local slang in an interview with a national newspaper. Use accommodation theory to explain why.
Show answer
He diverges from the newspaper's standard style to emphasise his local group identity and authenticity, showing loyalty to his community rather than seeking approval.. Divergence marks group identity and authenticity.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in English Language specification (issue 4, February 2026)
- Fowler, Gasiorek and Giles (2025), Communication accommodation theory in quantitative research, Communication Monographs (Taylor and Francis), Massey University repository copy
- Pearson WEN01/01 examiner report, June 2023
- Pearson AS English Language 8EN0/01 examiner report, June 2023 (same Language and Identity content)
- Pearson AS English Language 8EN0/01 examiner report, June 2024
- Pearson AS English Language 8EN0/01 examiner report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.