All subjects · English Language · WEN01 Language: Context and Identity
Attitudes to language
Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN01 Language: Context and Identity
Spec 1.3 says students explore 'attitudes to language' as well as how an individual's language choices are affected by context. In WEN01 texts, attitudes show up in two ways: what writers say about language (their own or other people's), and the choices they make because they expect readers to judge them. Unit 2 covers the prescriptive and descriptive debate in more depth. Theories in this lesson are optional supporting knowledge: Pearson IAL mark schemes and WEN01 examiner reports name no theorists, and marks reward analysis of the data (the AO4 descriptors ask you to apply 'theories, concepts and methods to data'). The researchers named here come from Pearson's UK AS English Language (8EN0) examiner reports and published research: use one only when it helps explain a quotation.
What attitudes look like
- Prescriptive attitudes treat one form as correct and others as errors ('We was is wrong').
- Descriptive attitudes record how people actually use language without judging it ('Many speakers here say we was in casual speech'). Linguists, and examiners, expect descriptive terms: say nonstandard, not 'incorrect' or 'lazy'.
- Attitudes to accents: in a 2019 survey of 821 UK adults, Sharma and colleagues found 'Queen's English' and RP labels rated highest for prestige and Birmingham, Essex, Liverpool and Cockney among the lowest, a 'remarkably stable, long-standing hierarchy' compared with similar studies from 1969 and 2004.
- Attitudes attach to whole varieties too: to youth slang, to online writing, and to national varieties of English.
Attitudes inside texts
- Metalanguage: writers sometimes talk about language directly ('I was told my accent would hold me back'). These comments are evidence of attitudes and of how the writer positions themselves.
- Anticipating judgement: a writer may choose Standard English and formal lexis so that readers take them seriously (overt prestige), or proudly keep a dialect form (covert prestige).
- Representing other people's language: a writer who quotes a relative's dialect with affection presents it as valuable; scare quotes or labels such as 'broken English' present it as inferior.
- Challenging attitudes: writers may reclaim a stigmatised accent or variety as part of their identity.
Writing about attitudes
- Identify whose attitude it is: the writer's, a quoted person's, or one the writer expects the reader to hold.
- Link it to identity: what does the attitude say about how the writer wants to be seen?
- Keep your own register descriptive: never call a variety in the data 'wrong'.
Worked example
An illustrative blog by a teacher from Liverpool: 'At my first interview I was told to "tone down the Scouse". I didn't. Twelve years later, my students trust me partly because I sound like their parents.' Analyse the attitudes to language and their effect on identity.
- The reported advice 'tone down the Scouse' shows a negative, prescriptive attitude to a regional accent from someone with power over her career.
- The short simple sentence 'I didn't.' rejects that attitude decisively.
- 'my students trust me partly because I sound like their parents' reframes the accent as an asset: shared accent builds solidarity (covert prestige).
- The time phrase 'Twelve years later' gives her experience as evidence against the original attitude.
Answer: She constructs a confident identity that has outlasted prejudice: the blog challenges a negative attitude to her accent and presents it as a source of trust with her community.
Check yourself
- Which statement is descriptive rather than prescriptive?
- 'We was' is wrong and should be corrected
- People who say 'we was' are being lazy
- Only Standard English is proper English
- Many speakers in this area say 'we was' in casual speech
Show answer
Many speakers in this area say 'we was' in casual speech. It records usage without judging it.
- In the 2019 UK accent survey reported by Sharma and colleagues, which accent label was rated highest for prestige?
- Birmingham
- Queen's English
- Liverpool
- Essex
Show answer
Queen's English. Queen's English and RP were at the top; Birmingham, Essex and Liverpool were near the bottom.
- What did that study conclude about British accent attitudes since 1969?
- All accents are now rated equally
- Regional accents now outrank RP
- Accent attitudes have disappeared among adults
- The hierarchy of accent prestige has stayed remarkably stable
Show answer
The hierarchy of accent prestige has stayed remarkably stable. It found a 'remarkably stable, long-standing hierarchy of accent status'.
- A writer says: 'I used to apologise for my accent. Now I don't.' This is best described as
- metalanguage showing a changed attitude to her own language
- a face-threatening act towards the reader
- synthetic personalisation
- an agentless passive
Show answer
metalanguage showing a changed attitude to her own language. She talks about language itself, revealing an attitude.
- Which term should you use when analysing a form such as 'we was' in a source text?
- incorrect
- bad grammar
- nonstandard
- lazy
Show answer
nonstandard. Descriptive linguistics uses neutral terms.
- Explain why a writer with a stigmatised regional accent might mention it in a public blog.
Show answer
To challenge negative attitudes and stereotypes about the accent and show pride in it as part of their identity.. Mentioning the accent confronts the attitude and reclaims the accent as identity.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in English Language specification (issue 4, February 2026)
- Sharma and colleagues (2022), 50 years of British accent bias: stability and lifespan change in attitudes to accents, English World-Wide 43(2) (Queen Mary University of London repository)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.