All subjects · English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition

Kachru's three circles of English

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition

Kachru's model is the theory Pearson's examiners mention most often for Unit 2. Their reports also warn that it is often only partially understood, so learn it accurately and know its limits.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The model

CircleRole of EnglishExamples
InnerFirst language in the traditional bases of EnglishUK, USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand
OuterInstitutional second language, spread through colonisation; large, diverse speech communities with distinct characteristicsIndia, Nigeria, Singapore, the Philippines
ExpandingForeign language learned for international useChina, Brazil, Chile, the Netherlands

From a SciELO article discussing Kachru's model, formulated in the early to mid 1980s.

Using it in the exam

Pearson's January 2024 report says higher-level answers used Kachru's circle to explain the development of the variety in the data. Do more than label: say what the placement implies. An outer-circle variety such as Nigerian or Singaporean English has its own local norms, sits alongside other languages, and grew out of colonial institutions. The June 2025 report quotes a candidate placing Cameroon English in the outer circle.

Criticisms

The SciELO article summarises critics:

Creoles are hard to place: a Caribbean creole speaker may be a native speaker of an English-lexified language in a country Kachru might put in the outer circle. Evaluating the model like this earns AO2 credit.

Worked example

A Section B source describes young professionals in an outer-circle country who speak English at work, a local language at home and English-based slang online. Evaluate Kachru's model using it.

  1. Placement: outer circle, English as an institutional second language.
  2. Strength: explains the official and educational role inherited from colonialism.
  3. Limitation: one country contains people with very different proficiency and uses; the model is national, not individual (Jenkins, Bruthiaux).
  4. Conclusion: useful for context, too coarse for individual speakers.

Answer: Kachru explains why English has an institutional role there, but the speakers' mixed proficiencies and domains show the circles blurring.

Key idea: Inner (L1: UK, USA), outer (institutional L2 from colonisation: India, Nigeria, Singapore), expanding (foreign language: China, Brazil). Critique: national not individual, ignores proficiency and internal variation, circles blurring.

Check yourself

  1. In Kachru's model, India and Nigeria belong to the
    • inner circle
    • expanding circle
    • acrolect circle
    • outer circle
    Show answer

    outer circle. Outer circle: English as an institutional second language from colonisation.

  2. Which country is in the inner circle?
    • Singapore
    • New Zealand
    • China
    • Brazil
    Show answer

    New Zealand. Inner circle: traditional bases of English as an L1.

  3. In the expanding circle English is mainly
    • the only home language
    • a creole
    • the language of colonial administration
    • a foreign language
    Show answer

    a foreign language. Expanding circle: studied as a foreign language.

  4. One criticism reported in the SciELO article is that Kachru's model
    • cannot show speakers' proficiency
    • ignores the USA
    • was invented in the 19th century
    • applies only to pidgins
    Show answer

    cannot show speakers' proficiency. Jenkins's criticism.

  5. Pearson's January 2024 report says higher-level answers used Kachru's model to
    • list every country in the world
    • replace analysis of the transcript
    • explain the development of the variety
    • prove one variety is better
    Show answer

    explain the development of the variety. The report credits explanation of a variety's development.

  6. Give one limitation of Kachru's circles when analysing a speaker in Section A.
    Show answer

    It classifies whole countries, so it cannot show an individual speaker's proficiency or the variation within one country.. Criticisms from Jenkins, Bruthiaux and others.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.