All subjects · English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)

The commentary: what it must do

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)

Section B is worth 30 of the 50 marks, more than the writing itself. The reports say candidates 'continue to find Section B more of a challenge than Section A' (January 2025), and many run out of time. Know exactly what it asks before you practise it.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

What the specification requires

The commentary reflects on the writing process in Section A and must cover:

1. Analysis and evaluation of the language choices made

2. The re-shaping of the source texts to meet the genre, audience, purpose and context

3. How contextual factors have influenced language choices

The specimen and June 2019 mark schemes add: show understanding of relevant language concepts and issues, apply appropriate terminology, analyse features specific to the genre, and write in an appropriate register and style. The Section B question is worded in the same way every year (June 2024 and January 2024 reports).

How it is marked

LevelMarksDescriptor (summarised)
00No rewardable material
11 to 6Descriptive: methods largely unassimilated; limited terminology, frequent errors; limited knowledge of concepts and issues; paraphrases; lists contextual factors and features; limited connections between reshaping the sources and own writing
27 to 12General understanding: some clarity, lapses in terminology; summarises basic concepts and issues; applies some understanding to the reshaping; describes construction of meaning with examples; obvious connections
313 to 18Clear relevant application: relevant methods with clear examples; logical structure, clear terminology; clear understanding of concepts and issues applied to the reshaping; explains meaning with relevant links to context and features; relevant connections
419 to 24Discriminating controlled application: controlled analysis with discriminating examples; effective transitions; discriminating selection of a range of concepts and issues; inferences about meaning; discriminating connections
525 to 30Critical and evaluative: critical analysis with sustained examples; sophisticated structure and expression; evaluative selection of a wide range of concepts and issues; critical understanding of the reshaping; evaluates construction of meaning; critical connections

Section B levels from the WEN03 mark schemes (January 2025, June 2025, June 2024), summarised. Grid bullet 1 = AO1, bullets 2 to 4 = AO2, bullet 5 = AO3, bullet 6 = AO4. Best fit: choose the level, then the mark within it.

Voice, length and focus

Worked example

A student plans a commentary. Which of their planned paragraphs should be cut, and why? (a) a summary of what each source said; (b) how the persona of a dog trainer shaped first-person anecdotes; (c) a page on a famous linguist's theory of politeness; (d) how short paragraphs and a standfirst suit readers of a free paper.

  1. Keep (b): persona, context and language choice linked (AO2, AO3).
  2. Keep (d): genre conventions and graphology linked to audience.
  3. Cut (a): source summary is not analysis; describe sources only to explain reshaping.
  4. Cut or shrink (c): theory in place of technical analysis of your own writing is what the June 2025 report warns against.

Answer: The commentary analyses and evaluates your own choices and how you reshaped the sources; summary and detached theory earn little.

Key idea: Section B: analyse and evaluate your choices, show how you reshaped the sources for genre, audience, purpose and context, explain how context influenced language. 30 marks, AO1 to AO4. Technique over theory; first or third person; organised and systematic.

Check yourself

  1. How many of the paper's 50 marks does the commentary carry?
    • 20
    • 25
    • 50
    • 30
    Show answer

    30. Section B is 30 marks.

  2. Which is one of the three things the specification says the commentary must cover?
    • A summary of each source text
    • The re-shaping of the source texts to meet the genre, audience, purpose and context
    • A biography of the source writers
    • A plan of Section A
    Show answer

    The re-shaping of the source texts to meet the genre, audience, purpose and context. Specification, Section B.

  3. Can the commentary be written in the first person ('I chose...')?
    • No; it must be third person
    • No; it must be second person
    • Only in the conclusion
    • Yes; first or third person are each acceptable
    Show answer

    Yes; first or third person are each acceptable. June 2017 report.

  4. What does the June 2025 report say the main focus of the commentary should be?
    • Analysis of technical methods rather than theory
    • Detailed accounts of linguistic theories
    • A summary of the sources
    • Praise for the writing
    Show answer

    Analysis of technical methods rather than theory. Technique over theory.

  5. Which phrase belongs to the Level 4 descriptor for Section B?
    • Lists contextual factors and language features
    • Summarises basic concepts
    • Makes inferences about the construction of meaning
    • Knowledge of methods of language analysis is largely unassimilated
    Show answer

    Makes inferences about the construction of meaning. Level 4 AO3 descriptor.

  6. Grid bullet 6 (AO4) rewards
    • connections between reshaping the source texts and own writing
    • accuracy of spelling in Section A
    • the number of theorists named
    • the length of the commentary
    Show answer

    connections between reshaping the source texts and own writing. AO4 = connections across texts.

  7. A Level 3 commentary earns between 13 and 18 marks. What is the midpoint of that band?
    Show answer

    15.5 marks. (13 + 18) / 2 = 15.5.

  8. Why does a commentary that mainly summarises the source texts score poorly?
    Show answer

    Because summary is description, not analysis or evaluation of your own language choices, which is what the marks reward.. Level 1: 'uses a descriptive approach or paraphrases'. The commentary is about your own writing.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.