All subjects · English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)
Reviews
Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)
A review is 'a critical evaluation of a text, event, object, or phenomenon', and 'a commentary, not merely a summary' (University of North Carolina Writing Center). Books, art, architecture, exhibitions, performances, restaurants and much else are reviewed, and many published reviews add a rating such as stars.
Structure
- Headline or title that often signals the verdict ('A Slow Start, A Sweet Finish').
- Orientation: what, where, who, when, and the reviewer's angle.
- Description selected to support judgements (not a full plot or menu).
- Evaluation against criteria: for a café, food, service, setting, value; for a film, story, performances, look and sound.
- Verdict, often with a rating and a recommendation addressed to a particular reader.
Language of evaluation
| Feature | Invented example | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Evaluative adjectives and adverbs | 'a generous, slightly chaotic menu' | Judgement with nuance |
| Hedging and concession | 'The service, though friendly, is slow at weekends.' | Balance builds trust (ethos) |
| Comparison | 'Better than its glossier neighbour' | Positions the subject for readers who know the area |
| Second-person advice | 'Go early; order the lemon cake.' | Direct relationship with the reader |
| Humour and wit | 'The scones could be used to build a sea wall.' | Entertainment; reviewer persona |
| Field-specific lexis | 'a crumb that is open and tender' | Expertise suited to an informed audience |
Examples invented for this site.
Illustrative review
Worked example
Analyse three evaluative choices in the illustrative review for a commentary, assuming the audience is readers of a local listings magazine.
- Rating and title orientate readers instantly, matching the scanning habits of a listings audience.
- Expanded noun phrase with postmodifying adjectives ('heaped and peppery') plus a superlative ('the best I have eaten') gives sensory evidence for praise.
- Personification and humour ('as though it has walked here') soften criticism; the closing imperatives and the concessive final clause give balanced, practical advice.
Answer: Evaluation supported by sensory detail, criticism softened by humour, and second-person advice that suits local readers deciding where to eat.
Check yourself
- A review is mainly
- a neutral list of facts
- a speech to persuade voters
- an evaluation of a work, product, service or event
- a record of a journey
Show answer
an evaluation of a work, product, service or event. UNC Writing Center: a review is a critical evaluation, not merely a summary.
- What does a rating in a review show?
- The relative merit of the thing reviewed
- The number of words in the review
- The reviewer's age
- The price of the magazine
Show answer
The relative merit of the thing reviewed. A star or number rating sums up the reviewer's overall judgement.
- 'The service, though friendly, is slow at weekends' uses
- tripling
- an imperative
- concession
- reported speech
Show answer
concession. 'Though friendly' concedes a positive before the criticism.
- Which sentence gives second-person advice?
- The café opened in 2019.
- Go early and order the lemon cake.
- Chairs were wobbly.
- The owner is called Sam.
Show answer
Go early and order the lemon cake.. An imperative addressed to the reader.
- Evaluating a café against food, service, setting and value means using
- a nut graf
- a standfirst
- phonemic symbols
- criteria
Show answer
criteria. Criteria give structure to judgement.
- Why might a reviewer include some criticism even of a place they enjoyed?
Show answer
Balance makes the judgement seem fair and trustworthy, so readers believe the praise.. UNC Writing Center: aim for a balanced argument; harsh judgements are hard to prove and can make a review seem unfair.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in English Language specification (Issue 4, February 2026)
- The Writing Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill: Book Reviews
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.