All subjects · English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)

Reviews

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)

A review is 'a critical evaluation of a text, event, object, or phenomenon', and 'a commentary, not merely a summary' (University of North Carolina Writing Center). Books, art, architecture, exhibitions, performances, restaurants and much else are reviewed, and many published reviews add a rating such as stars.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Structure

Language of evaluation

FeatureInvented exampleEffect
Evaluative adjectives and adverbs'a generous, slightly chaotic menu'Judgement with nuance
Hedging and concession'The service, though friendly, is slow at weekends.'Balance builds trust (ethos)
Comparison'Better than its glossier neighbour'Positions the subject for readers who know the area
Second-person advice'Go early; order the lemon cake.'Direct relationship with the reader
Humour and wit'The scones could be used to build a sea wall.'Entertainment; reviewer persona
Field-specific lexis'a crumb that is open and tender'Expertise suited to an informed audience

Examples invented for this site.

Illustrative review

Worked example

Analyse three evaluative choices in the illustrative review for a commentary, assuming the audience is readers of a local listings magazine.

  1. Rating and title orientate readers instantly, matching the scanning habits of a listings audience.
  2. Expanded noun phrase with postmodifying adjectives ('heaped and peppery') plus a superlative ('the best I have eaten') gives sensory evidence for praise.
  3. Personification and humour ('as though it has walked here') soften criticism; the closing imperatives and the concessive final clause give balanced, practical advice.

Answer: Evaluation supported by sensory detail, criticism softened by humour, and second-person advice that suits local readers deciding where to eat.

Key idea: Review = evaluation (plus optional rating). Orientation, selective description, judgement against criteria, verdict. Evaluative modifiers, hedging and concession, comparison, second-person advice, humour, field lexis.

Check yourself

  1. A review is mainly
    • a neutral list of facts
    • a speech to persuade voters
    • an evaluation of a work, product, service or event
    • a record of a journey
    Show answer

    an evaluation of a work, product, service or event. UNC Writing Center: a review is a critical evaluation, not merely a summary.

  2. What does a rating in a review show?
    • The relative merit of the thing reviewed
    • The number of words in the review
    • The reviewer's age
    • The price of the magazine
    Show answer

    The relative merit of the thing reviewed. A star or number rating sums up the reviewer's overall judgement.

  3. 'The service, though friendly, is slow at weekends' uses
    • tripling
    • an imperative
    • concession
    • reported speech
    Show answer

    concession. 'Though friendly' concedes a positive before the criticism.

  4. Which sentence gives second-person advice?
    • The café opened in 2019.
    • Go early and order the lemon cake.
    • Chairs were wobbly.
    • The owner is called Sam.
    Show answer

    Go early and order the lemon cake.. An imperative addressed to the reader.

  5. Evaluating a café against food, service, setting and value means using
    • a nut graf
    • a standfirst
    • phonemic symbols
    • criteria
    Show answer

    criteria. Criteria give structure to judgement.

  6. Why might a reviewer include some criticism even of a place they enjoyed?
    Show answer

    Balance makes the judgement seem fair and trustworthy, so readers believe the praise.. UNC Writing Center: aim for a balanced argument; harsh judgements are hard to prove and can make a review seem unfair.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.