All subjects · English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)

Section B technique: the commentary under exam conditions

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN03 Crafting Language (Writing)

This lesson puts the commentary together: structure, timing, and a model opening and paragraph, checked against the level descriptors.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

A structure that works

1. Introduction: genre, audience, purpose, context and persona in one or two sentences, with your overall approach to the sources.

2. Body: organise systematically, either by framework (discourse and structure; lexis and semantics; grammar and syntax; graphology or phonology) or by decision (persona; opening; use of each source; ending). Each paragraph: feature, example, effect, context, evaluation, with a source comparison where relevant.

3. Conclusion: an evaluative judgement on how far the text meets its audience and purpose, and what the reshaping achieved.

The June 2023 report praised commentaries that were well organised and systematic.

Model introduction

Checklist against the descriptors

Descriptor strandAsk yourself
AO1 methods and terminologyHave I named features precisely at several language levels, with short quotations?
AO2 concepts and issuesHave I discussed register, genre, mode, persona and the reshaping, not just single devices?
AO3 context and meaningIs every feature linked to audience, purpose or context, with inferences about its effect?
AO4 connectionsHave I compared my language with the sources' language and weighed the changes?
EvaluationHave I judged success and explained alternatives, not just listed features?
TimeHave I left enough time to finish? Rushed commentaries list points with little evaluation.

Built from the WEN03 Section B level descriptors and report advice.

Worked example

Improve this commentary sentence to Level 4 or 5 standard: 'I used a lot of facts from Text A to inform the readers.'

  1. Select one fact and quote how you used it.
  2. Compare with the source's form (a date-by-date timeline).
  3. Explain the effect for the audience and the reason in context.
  4. Evaluate the trade-off.

Answer: 'Rather than reproducing Text A's date-by-date timeline, I compressed ten thousand years of domestication into a single complex sentence with a fronted time adverbial ("Long before farms or fences,"), giving readers just enough history to see guide dogs as part of an ancient partnership; this sacrifices detail but keeps the article focused on its persuasive purpose.'

Key idea: Introduction with genre, audience, purpose, context, persona; systematic body by framework or decision; evaluative conclusion. Every paragraph: term, quotation, effect, context, evaluation, source comparison. Finish within time.

Check yourself

  1. What should a commentary introduction contain?
    • A summary of each source
    • Genre, audience, purpose, context and persona, with the overall approach
    • A list of theorists
    • The full Section A text again
    Show answer

    Genre, audience, purpose, context and persona, with the overall approach. Set up the decisions you will analyse.

  2. Which organisation of the body is systematic?
    • Random points as they occur
    • One long paragraph
    • Bullet points with no explanation
    • Paragraphs by framework or by decision
    Show answer

    Paragraphs by framework or by decision. June 2023: well organised and systematic.

  3. What should the conclusion of a commentary do?
    • Introduce a new source
    • Give an evaluative judgement on how far the text meets its audience and purpose
    • Repeat the question
    • List spelling corrections
    Show answer

    Give an evaluative judgement on how far the text meets its audience and purpose. Evaluation is rewarded at Levels 4 and 5.

  4. The reports say rushed commentaries tend to
    • score Level 5
    • contain too many examples
    • list points with little analysis or evaluation
    • be too long
    Show answer

    list points with little analysis or evaluation. Time management matters.

  5. Which checklist question targets AO3?
    • Is every feature linked to audience, purpose or context, with inferences about its effect?
    • Have I named enough theorists?
    • Is my handwriting neat?
    • Have I copied the grid?
    Show answer

    Is every feature linked to audience, purpose or context, with inferences about its effect?. AO3 = context and construction of meaning.

  6. Section B is 30 of the paper's 50 marks. What percentage of the paper is that?
    Show answer

    60 %. 30 / 50 x 100 = 60%.

  7. How would you upgrade the comment 'I used informal language for teenagers' to a higher level?
    Show answer

    Quote a specific informal feature, name it with a term, explain its effect on teenage readers in this context, and evaluate it, for example against the more formal source.. Feature, term, example, effect, context, evaluation.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.