All subjects · English Literature · WET01 Post-2000 Poetry and Prose

Section A: writing the comparative poetry essay

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET01 Post-2000 Poetry and Prose

Section A always asks you to compare the named poem with one other prescribed poem. AO4 (connections) is worth a large share of the marks, so how you choose the second poem and how you connect the two decides the level. This lesson turns Pearson's examiner advice into a plan.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Past questions

SeriesNamed poemFocus of the question
Sample paperHistory (Burnside)the sense of danger
Sample paperEffects (Jenkins)changing relationships
January 2023The Deliverer (Doshi)use of time
January 2023History (Burnside)the natural world
June 2023From the Journal of a Disappointed Man (Motion)work
June 2023A Minor Role (Fanthorpe)characters commenting on their own lives
January 2024Effects (Jenkins)the presentation of objects
January 2024Giuseppe (Ford)undesirable behaviour
June 2024Please Hold (O'Driscoll)frustration
June 2024Eat Me (Agbabi)harsh experience
January 2025The Lammas Hireling (Duhig)unwanted memories
January 2025An Easy Passage (Copus)boundaries
June 2025Material (Barber)parents and parenting
June 2025Ode on a Grayson Perry Urn (Turnbull)youth

Section A questions, from Pearson's sample paper, mark schemes and examiner reports

Choosing the second poem

Pearson's reports say the same thing every series: choose the poem that best fits the question, not the poem you know best. In June 2023, students who wrote about masculinity in Chainsaw Versus the Pampas Grass when the question was about work scored poorly; in January 2023, the same happened with History and the natural world. Before choosing, write the focus word of the question (for example 'boundaries') and test two or three candidates:

Examples that worked: Effects with Material on parenting (June 2025), To My Nine-Year-Old Self with An Easy Passage on boundaries (January 2025), Giuseppe or The Map Woman with The Lammas Hireling on unwanted memories (January 2025).

Structuring an integrated answer

Pearson's top-level descriptors ask for an integrated, connective approach. A reliable structure:

1. Introduction: name both poems and poets, define the focus, give a one-sentence comparative argument.

2. Three or four comparative paragraphs, each on one aspect of the focus (an idea, then the methods both poets use for it). Move between the poems inside each paragraph with connectives such as 'whereas', 'similarly', 'by contrast'.

3. Keep the named poem at the centre: reports from 2023 to 2025 warn against letting the chosen poem dominate.

4. Cover form and structure in the argument, not tacked on at the end.

5. Conclusion: an evaluative judgement on the most important similarity or difference.

AO3 (context) is not assessed in Section A. The June 2024 report notes that some students drifted into context that gained no credit.

Writing the analysis

Worked example

Question: compare how poets present boundaries in An Easy Passage and one other poem. Sketch an opening and one paragraph plan.

  1. Second poem: To My Nine-Year-Old Self, which also looks at the line between childhood and adulthood (the most successful pairing in January 2025).
  2. Introduction: both poems place a girl at the edge of growing up; Copus watches from outside, Dunmore speaks across time to a younger self.
  3. Paragraph: physical boundaries. Copus's girl balanced halfway up on a windowsill, the house and street as markers; Dunmore's adult who cannot step back into the child's world. Form: Copus's single unbroken stanza against Dunmore's shifting pronouns that pull the selves apart.

Answer: Each paragraph compares both poems on one aspect of 'boundaries', with form and language, and keeps An Easy Passage at the centre.

Key idea: Choose the second poem for the question, not for comfort. Integrate the poems in every paragraph, keep the named poem central, include form and structure, and leave context out of Section A.

Check yourself

  1. What do Pearson's reports say is the best basis for choosing the second poem?
    • How well it serves the focus of the question
    • How well you know it
    • Whether it is by a famous poet
    • Whether it is the longest poem
    Show answer

    How well it serves the focus of the question. Reports in 2023, 2024 and 2025 all warn against choosing a favourite poem that does not fit the task.

  2. A student writes three paragraphs on the chosen poem and one on the named poem. What is the problem?
    • Nothing: the second poem is free choice
    • The essay should have no paragraphs
    • The chosen poem dominates, which reports say is not advisable
    • The named poem should not be discussed
    Show answer

    The chosen poem dominates, which reports say is not advisable. June 2025 and other reports say candidates should not discuss the chosen poem in more depth than the named poem.

  3. Is context (AO3) assessed in Section A?
    • No: Section A assesses AO1, AO2 and AO4
    • Yes: it is the main objective
    • Only for poems written before 2005
    • Only in the introduction
    Show answer

    No: Section A assesses AO1, AO2 and AO4. AO3 is assessed only in Section B. The June 2024 report notes contextual drift in poetry answers.

  4. Which paragraph opening best shows an integrated comparison?
    • An Easy Passage is about a girl climbing through a window.
    • In the second poem the poet uses enjambment.
    • I will now discuss the other poem.
    • Whereas Copus watches the girl from outside, Dunmore speaks directly to her younger self, so the boundary becomes one of time rather than space.
    Show answer

    Whereas Copus watches the girl from outside, Dunmore speaks directly to her younger self, so the boundary becomes one of time rather than space.. Integrated comparison moves between the poems within the sentence, around one idea.

  5. The June 2023 report criticised some answers for treating poetic voices as
    • too formal
    • real people with stories, rather than literary constructs
    • dramatic monologues
    • examples of free verse
    Show answer

    real people with stories, rather than literary constructs. Answers that retell the 'story' of the speakers become narrative and descriptive.

  6. Which of these breaks the Section A rubric?
    • Comparing the named poem with one prescribed poem
    • Using the poem titles as labels
    • Writing about form and language
    • Comparing the named poem with two other poems
    Show answer

    Comparing the named poem with two other poems. The June 2024 report lists rubric errors: writing about one poem only, using a poem not on the list, or comparing the named poem with more than one other.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.