All subjects · English Literature · WET02 Drama
Othello: context and critical reception
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET02 Drama
Few plays have a richer critical history than *Othello*. Use context and criticism to illuminate race, gender and Iago, never as a list.
Contexts that illuminate the play
- Date and source: 1603 to 1604; from Cinthio's Italian tale (Britannica).
- Venice: a wealthy trading republic that employed foreign generals; the RSC's 2015 design used water to reflect Venice's lagoon and Cyprus's strategic island position.
- The Ottoman threat: Cyprus as a frontier between Christian Venice and the Turks.
- Race in early modern England: 'Moor' could mean North African or Black African; early modern attitudes mixed fascination and prejudice.
- Gender and marriage: obedience to fathers and husbands; female chastity as male honour.
- Machiavelli: Iago as a 'Machiavellian' schemer, the stage stereotype of a cunning, amoral manipulator.
Critical history (from the Internet Shakespeare Editions survey)
- Thomas Rymer (1693) attacked the play as implausible and objected to a Black general.
- Samuel Johnson (1765) praised its 'proofs of Shakespeare's skill in human nature'.
- Coleridge: Iago's 'motive-hunting of motiveless malignity'.
- A. C. Bradley (1904): 'the most painfully exciting and the most terrible' of the tragedies.
- F. R. Leavis, 'Diabolic Intellect and the Noble Hero' (1937): Othello as an egoist whose 'self-pride' becomes 'ferocious stupidity'.
- William Empson (1951): the shifting meanings of 'honest'.
- Bernard Spivack (1958): Iago as a descendant of the morality-play Vice.
- Race-focused criticism: G. K. Hunter, 'Othello and Colour Prejudice' (1967), among others.
- Feminist criticism: Karen Newman (1987) linked gender and race; Ruth Vanita (1994) wrote that Desdemona 'is killed not only by Othello and Iago'.
Productions
- The RSC's 2015 production (directed by Iqbal Khan) cast Hugh Quarshie as Othello and Lucian Msamati as Iago, the first Black actor to play Iago at the RSC; the RSC notes that in this production Iago's hatred 'couldn't easily be attributed to racism', coming instead from 'a much deeper psychology'. Michael Billington (Guardian) said it made audiences see the tragedy 'from a totally fresh perspective'.
- Casting choices change how race and power are read: a Black Iago shifts the focus from racism to envy and class.
Worked example
Use Leavis and Bradley to build AO5 on Othello's nobility.
- Bradley admires the tragedy's terror and sees Othello as noble, deceived by Iago.
- Leavis argues the opposite: Othello's 'self-pride' makes him easy to deceive.
- Test against the text: his eloquent Act 1 speech supports nobility; his speed in believing Iago in 3.3 supports Leavis.
- His final speech can be read either way: noble self-judgement or self-dramatising.
Answer: Setting Bradley's noble hero against Leavis's egoist, and testing both against Act 1, 3.3 and the final speech, creates a sustained debate rather than a single verdict.
Check yourself
- What was the title of F. R. Leavis's 1937 essay on Othello?
- Diabolic Intellect and the Noble Hero
- Honest in Othello
- Othello and Colour Prejudice
- Shakespearean Tragedy
Show answer
Diabolic Intellect and the Noble Hero. He read Othello as an egoist.
- How did A. C. Bradley describe Othello among the tragedies?
- The least successful
- A comedy in disguise
- The most painfully exciting and the most terrible
- The most political
Show answer
The most painfully exciting and the most terrible. Shakespearean Tragedy (1904).
- What did Thomas Rymer (1693) do?
- Attacked the play as implausible and objected to a Black general
- Praised Desdemona as a paragon
- Directed the first production
- Translated Cinthio
Show answer
Attacked the play as implausible and objected to a Black general. An early hostile critic.
- How did Bernard Spivack read Iago?
- As a romantic hero
- As a victim of racism
- As Othello's brother
- As a version of the morality-play Vice
Show answer
As a version of the morality-play Vice. A medieval dramatic ancestor.
- What was significant about Lucian Msamati's Iago in 2015?
- He also played Othello
- He was the first Black actor to play Iago at the RSC
- He played Iago as a woman
- He performed in Italian
Show answer
He was the first Black actor to play Iago at the RSC. Iqbal Khan's RSC production.
- What did Ruth Vanita (1994) argue about Desdemona?
- That she is guilty
- That she never loved Othello
- That she survives
- That she is killed not only by Othello and Iago
Show answer
That she is killed not only by Othello and Iago. A feminist reading of wider responsibility.
- Explain how casting a Black actor as Iago can change an audience's interpretation of the play.
Show answer
It makes it harder to read Iago's hatred simply as racism, so the audience focuses on envy, class or deeper psychology as his motive.. Shifts focus from racism to other motives.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide, issue 3 (unit content, set texts and assessment for Unit 2: Drama)
- Britannica: Othello
- Internet Shakespeare Editions (University of Victoria): Othello, a critical survey (Jessica Slights)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: Othello, Iqbal Khan 2015 production
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.