All subjects · English Literature · WET03 Poetry and Prose

Planning and writing the comparative essay

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET03 Poetry and Prose

With about 72 minutes for a 30-mark comparative essay, planning is what separates controlled answers from list-like ones. The January 2025 report said planning was consistently linked to more controlled, discriminating and comparative responses.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Decoding the question

Every Section B question has the same frame: 'Compare the ways in which the writers of your two chosen texts present [focus]. In your answer, you must consider relevant contextual factors.'

A plan in five minutes

1. Define the focus and decide your thesis: a comparative claim about how and why the two writers present it differently or alike.

2. Choose 3 or 4 comparative points, each with: a method in each novel; short evidence; a context for each.

3. Order the points to build an argument (for example from obvious to subtle, or from similarity to difference).

4. Plan an ending that evaluates (whose presentation is more radical, hopeful, ambiguous, and why).

Writing

Worked example

Plan a response to 'Compare the ways in which the writers of your two chosen texts present loneliness' for Frankenstein and Never Let Me Go (a January 2023 focus).

  1. Thesis: both novels create beings made for others' use, but Shelley makes loneliness a cry of protest while Ishiguro makes it a quiet acceptance.
  2. Point 1 (voice): the creature's eloquent embedded narrative of rejection against Kathy's restrained retrospective narration.
  3. Point 2 (setting): sublime, empty landscapes (Alps, Arctic) against enclosed Hailsham and lonely roads of a carer.
  4. Point 3 (relationships): the creature's demand for a companion refused; Kathy's lost friendships with Ruth and Tommy.
  5. Context: Romantic isolation and the Gothic; late twentieth-century debates on cloning and the ethics of genetic engineering.
  6. Conclusion: Shelley's loneliness accuses its creator; Ishiguro's indicts a society by showing how little its victims protest.

Answer: Thesis plus three comparative points (voice, setting, relationships) with context for each and an evaluative conclusion.

Key idea: About 72 minutes. Decode 'the ways in which ... present' plus the focus; define and widen the focus; thesis; 3 or 4 integrated comparative points with methods, evidence and context for both; an evaluative conclusion.

Check yourself

  1. What does 'the ways in which the writers ... present' direct you to analyse?
    • The writers' methods, not just what happens
    • Only the plot
    • Only the characters' feelings
    • Only historical background
    Show answer

    The writers' methods, not just what happens. The phrase points to AO2.

  2. Why should you define a broad focus such as 'love' early on?
    • To fill space
    • Because examiners do not know what love means
    • To open up a range of types and set up a precise argument
    • To avoid comparing the texts
    Show answer

    To open up a range of types and set up a precise argument. The June 2025 mark scheme lists familial, romantic and platonic love.

  3. Which introduction is strongest for a question on power (Women and Society)?
    • Brontë and Morrison show power as possession, but where Heathcliff seizes property through law and marriage, slavery has made Sethe's own children legal property, so her desperate act becomes a terrible assertion of ownership over them
    • Power is when someone controls someone else
    • In this essay I will compare power in two novels
    • Wuthering Heights was published in 1847 and Beloved in 1987
    Show answer

    Brontë and Morrison show power as possession, but where Heathcliff seizes property through law and marriage, slavery has made Sethe's own children legal property, so her desperate act becomes a terrible assertion of ownership over them. Comparative thesis with methods and context.

  4. What should the conclusion do?
    • Repeat the introduction word for word
    • Introduce a third novel
    • List the quotations used
    • Make an evaluative judgement about the comparison
    Show answer

    Make an evaluative judgement about the comparison. Judgement, not summary.

  5. What did the January 2025 report link planning to?
    • Shorter answers with fewer marks
    • More controlled, discriminating and comparative responses
    • Less use of context
    • More plot summary
    Show answer

    More controlled, discriminating and comparative responses. Planning helps control.

  6. In an open-book exam, how should you use quotations?
    • Long passages copied to prove knowledge
    • Not at all
    • Only in the conclusion
    • Short, precise and embedded in your own sentences
    Show answer

    Short, precise and embedded in your own sentences. 'Evidence should be short and embedded within points' (June 2023).

  7. What makes a good thesis for a Section B essay?
    Show answer

    A comparative argument that answers the question about both writers' methods and suggests why their presentations are alike or different.. Comparative, method-focused, explanatory.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.