All subjects · English Literature · WET03 Poetry and Prose
Science and Society: connecting the three novels
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET03 Poetry and Prose
Science and Society is by far the most popular theme: over two-thirds of candidates in June 2023, and the most popular theme in every report from 2023 to 2025, with responses on all three novels. It joins a Romantic Gothic novel about creating life with two modern visions (1985 and 2005) of societies that control bodies and reproduction.
The three novels at a glance
| Frankenstein | The Handmaid's Tale | Never Let Me Go | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Published | 1818 (revised 1831) | 1985 | 2005 |
| Writer | Mary Shelley | Margaret Atwood | Kazuo Ishiguro |
| Setting | Geneva, Ingolstadt, the Alps, Orkney, the Arctic | Gilead, a theocracy in the former United States (New England) | an alternative late twentieth-century England (Hailsham, the Cottages) |
| Narration | nested: Walton's letters, Victor's story, the creature's story | Offred, first person, present and past; Historical Notes epilogue | Kathy H., first person, retrospective |
| Science | creation of life; ambition | a fertility crisis and state control of reproduction | human clones raised as organ donors |
| Genre | Gothic; often called one of the first science-fiction novels | dystopia | dystopian science fiction |
From Britannica, LitCharts and SparkNotes
Pairing routes
- Frankenstein and The Handmaid's Tale: the June 2025 report praised comparison of Shelley's male narrators with the handmaids' controlled speech and the historical gap from Enlightenment and Romantic Europe to 1980s America.
- Frankenstein and Never Let Me Go: created beings without rights or parents; eloquent protest (the creature) against quiet acceptance (the clones).
- The Handmaid's Tale and Never Let Me Go: two first-person women narrating within systems that use their bodies; the June 2024 report praised comparison of euphemisms such as 'donation', 'completion' and 'Aunts'; the June 2023 report praised discussion of how Atwood and Ishiguro make their narrators admit unreliability.
Big comparative ideas
- Ambition, control and ethics of science (artificial life, the impact of science, extreme ideas).
- Bodies, gender and reproduction (treatment of women, gender).
- Fate and lack of choice (January 2017, June 2025).
- Narration and reliability (sample paper, June 2023).
- Setting and environment (locations, threatening environments, the natural world, setting).
- Loss, loneliness, death and violence (June 2017, January 2023, January 2025, June 2024).
Worked example
Write a comparative topic sentence on the impact of science on society (January 2025) for Frankenstein and Never Let Me Go.
- Common ground: both show scientific creation of human-like beings for whom society takes no responsibility.
- Difference: Shelley's science is one man's private ambition; Ishiguro's is an accepted national system.
- Method: Victor's confessional narrative against Kathy's calm, normalising voice.
Answer: Both novels imagine science creating human life and then refusing it humanity, but Shelley locates the danger in one man's secret ambition, told in Victor's anguished confession, while Ishiguro makes it a normal, accepted system narrated so calmly by one of its products that the reader must supply the horror.
Check yourself
- What do the reports say about the popularity of Science and Society?
- It is the least popular theme
- It has no candidates
- It is the most popular theme
- It is compulsory
Show answer
It is the most popular theme. Over two-thirds of candidates in June 2023.
- Which Science and Society novel is often called one of the first science-fiction novels?
- Frankenstein
- The Handmaid's Tale
- Never Let Me Go
- Mrs Dalloway
Show answer
Frankenstein. Britannica.
- What did the June 2025 report praise in Frankenstein and Handmaid's Tale answers?
- Avoiding context
- Discussing only Victor
- Use of the historical gap from Enlightenment and Romantic Europe to 1980s America
- Comparing film versions
Show answer
Use of the historical gap from Enlightenment and Romantic Europe to 1980s America. Q6, gender.
- Which terms did the June 2024 report praise candidates for comparing as language that obscures violence?
- 'Satis House' and 'Estella'
- 'donation', 'completion' and 'Aunts'
- 'boum' and 'Marabar'
- 'Sweet Home' and '124'
Show answer
'donation', 'completion' and 'Aunts'. Q7, violence.
- Which narrators in this theme are first-person women within systems that use their bodies?
- Walton and Victor
- Marlow and Kurtz
- Pip and Joe
- Offred and Kathy H.
Show answer
Offred and Kathy H.. Atwood and Ishiguro.
- Give one similarity and one difference between the creature in Frankenstein and the clones in Never Let Me Go.
Show answer
Both are created beings denied full humanity by those who made them, but the creature protests and takes revenge whereas the clones largely accept their fate.. Created and denied humanity; protest versus acceptance.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel IAS/IAL in English Literature specification, issue 6 (May 2021), Unit 3: Poetry and Prose (copy hosted by a centre)
- Britannica: Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus
- Britannica: The Handmaid's Tale
- Britannica: Never Let Me Go
- LitCharts: Never Let Me Go plot summary
- Pearson WET03 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET03 examiner report, January 2023
- Pearson WET03 examiner report, June 2023
- Pearson WET03 examiner report, January 2024
- Pearson WET03 examiner report, June 2024
- Pearson WET03 examiner report, January 2025
- Pearson WET03 examiner report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.