All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Hamlet: context and critical reception
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
AO3 and AO5 on Hamlet draw on a rich history: the sources of the story, the Elizabethan world of succession anxiety and melancholy, the three early texts, and four centuries of criticism and performance. Use only the facts and views you can attribute.
Sources and texts
- Saxo Grammaticus wrote the story of Amleth in his twelfth-century *Historia Danica* (printed 1514): a brother's murder of the king, the queen's remarriage to the killer, feigned madness, a voyage to England and a forged death warrant (RSC).
- Belleforest, *Histoires Tragiques* (1570), retold it in French and added the queen's adultery with her brother-in-law.
- A lost earlier Hamlet play, generally attributed to Thomas Kyd, had a ghost calling for revenge.
- Montaigne's Essays and Bright's Treatise of Melancholy may lie behind Hamlet's questioning and hesitation; Nashe described drunkenness at the Danish court (RSC).
- Texts: the First Quarto (1603) is a shorter, unauthorised text; the Second Quarto (1604) was based on Shakespeare's papers; the First Folio (1623) took its text from the Second Quarto (Britannica).
Elizabethan and Jacobean contexts
- Succession: the play was written as Elizabeth I's reign ended without an heir; the January 2025 mark scheme lists Elizabethan succession anxieties and court spies as relevant to Claudius.
- Religion: the Ghost seems to come from purgatory, a Catholic idea rejected by the Protestant Church of England, which makes its truth uncertain.
- Melancholy and humours: the June 2025 mark scheme points to Bright's *Treatise* and Elizabethan humoral theory, compared with modern understanding of mental illness.
- Revenge: private revenge was condemned by Church and state, yet revenge tragedy was hugely popular.
- The Renaissance man: the ideal of the courtier, soldier and scholar, which Ophelia mourns ('O, what a noble mind is here o'erthrown').
Criticism and performance
From the ISE critical survey:
- Romantic critics read Hamlet as a sensitive thinker: Goethe saw a young man overwhelmed; Coleridge said 'I have a smack of Hamlet in myself'; Hazlitt, 'It is we who are Hamlet'.
- A. C. Bradley (1904) presented Hamlet as a sensitive idealist; Ernest Jones, following Freud, read his delay as Oedipal desire for his mother.
- Historical critics: E. E. Stoll (delay as convention); Lily B. Campbell (melancholy as Elizabethan humour).
- Political: Jan Kott called it 'a drama of political crime'; New Historicists and Cultural Materialists read it in terms of power.
- Feminist: critics such as Juliet Dusinberre and Lisa Jardine examined patriarchal control over Ophelia and Gertrude.
From the RSC stage history: Garrick 'completely overcome by tears of grief'; Kemble 'like a man in armour' (Hazlitt); Olivier's 1937 Old Vic and 1948 film used the Oedipal reading (the film cut Fortinbras); Branagh's 1996 full-text Edwardian film; Ben Whishaw at 23 in Trevor Nunn's 2004 Old Vic production.
Worked example
Use two contrasting critical views in a paragraph on Hamlet's delay.
- View 1: Ernest Jones, following Freud, read the delay as an unconscious Oedipal problem: Hamlet cannot kill the man who has done what he secretly desired (ISE survey).
- Evidence that supports it: Hamlet's obsession with his mother's sexuality in the closet scene; Olivier's 1948 film staged this reading (RSC).
- View 2: E. E. Stoll read the delay as a convention of revenge tragedy, without need of psychology (ISE survey).
- Evidence for it: the play needs four acts of complication; Hamlet gives reasons (proof, the prayer scene).
- Judgement: the play invites psychological reading because it gives Hamlet so many reasons, none of which fully convinces even him.
Answer: Set a psychological reading against a historical one, test each against specific scenes, and conclude on what the play's own uncertainty suggests.
Check yourself
- Which writer first recorded the Amleth story in the twelfth century?
- Saxo Grammaticus
- Belleforest
- Thomas Kyd
- Montaigne
Show answer
Saxo Grammaticus. Historia Danica, printed 1514 (RSC).
- To whom is the lost earlier Hamlet play generally attributed?
- Christopher Marlowe
- Ben Jonson
- Thomas Kyd
- John Webster
Show answer
Thomas Kyd. Kyd wrote The Spanish Tragedy (RSC).
- Which statement about the early texts of Hamlet is supported by Britannica?
- The 1604 Second Quarto was based on Shakespeare's own papers
- The First Folio was printed in 1603
- There is only one early text
- The First Quarto is the longest version
Show answer
The 1604 Second Quarto was based on Shakespeare's own papers. Q1 1603 unauthorised; Q2 1604 from his papers; F 1623 from Q2.
- Why might an Elizabethan Protestant audience distrust the Ghost?
- Ghosts were never shown on stage
- It speaks in prose
- It appears in daylight
- It speaks of purgatory, a Catholic doctrine the Church of England rejected
Show answer
It speaks of purgatory, a Catholic doctrine the Church of England rejected. Purgatory makes the Ghost's origin uncertain; Hamlet fears it 'may be the devil'.
- How did Jan Kott describe Hamlet?
- 'a heap of jewels unstrung'
- 'a drama of political crime'
- 'the very darkest of all comedies'
- 'almost one continued moral'
Show answer
'a drama of political crime'. Kott (1964) read it politically (ISE survey).
- What reading did Olivier's 1948 film follow, according to the RSC?
- A feminist reading of Ophelia
- A Marxist reading with Fortinbras as hero
- A comic reading
- The Oedipal reading, and it cut Fortinbras
Show answer
The Oedipal reading, and it cut Fortinbras. Freud's Oedipal complex shaped Olivier's Hamlet.
- Explain how the context of succession can illuminate Claudius in Hamlet.
Show answer
The play was written as Elizabeth I's reign was ending without an heir, so a usurper who murders his way to the throne and a foreign prince who inherits it would have touched real fears about who would rule and how power is seized.. Succession anxiety, usurpation, fear of disorder.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: Hamlet, dates and sources
- Britannica: Hamlet (play), print article
- Internet Shakespeare Editions (University of Victoria): Hamlet, critical survey
- Royal Shakespeare Company: Hamlet, stage history
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.