All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
King Lear: context and critical reception
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
King Lear grew from a legend retold many times, was written for a new king, survives in two versions, and was performed for 150 years with a happy ending. These facts give you strong AO3 and AO5 material.
Sources
From the RSC:
- Holinshed's Chronicles (1587), based on Geoffrey of Monmouth: King Leir tests his daughters Gonorilla, Regan and Cordeilla; Cordeilla later restores him to the throne.
- The anonymous play King Leir (performed 1594, published 1605): its Britain has a strongly Christian culture, unlike Shakespeare's pagan world.
- Spenser's Faerie Queene (1590): the youngest daughter, now Cordelia, is hanged.
- Sidney's Arcadia (1590): the subplot of a king deposed and blinded by his illegitimate son and rescued from suicide by his legitimate son.
- Harsnett's Declaration of Egregious Popish Impostures (1603): the source of Poor Tom's fiends.
- Montaigne's Essays (Florio's translation, 1603).
- A real case: Sir Brian Annesley, whose youngest daughter Cordell protected him from her sister's attempt to have him declared insane.
- Shakespeare's main additions are Lear's madness and the Fool, and the tragic ending.
Contexts and texts
- King James I: the play was performed before him at Christmas 1606. James wished to unite England and Scotland; a king who divides Britain would have looked dangerous. The June 2025 mark scheme lists James I's succession; the January 2024 mark scheme lists patriarchy and inheritance.
- Primogeniture and illegitimacy: Edmund attacks the 'plague of custom' that disinherits him.
- Pagan setting, Christian audience: the January 2025 mark scheme describes it as a Christian play set in a pagan world.
- Two texts (ISE): the 1608 Quarto ('True Chronicle Historie') has about 285 lines not in the 1623 Folio ('The Tragedie of King Lear'), which has about 102 not in the Quarto. Michael Warren and Gary Taylor (*The Division of the Kingdoms*, 1983) argued the Folio is Shakespeare's deliberate revision; others disagree.
Reception and criticism
- Nahum Tate (1681): Tate called the original 'a heap of jewels unstrung and unpolished'; his version removed the Fool, made Cordelia and Edgar lovers and ended happily. It held the stage until 1838, when Macready restored a (shortened) original text and the Fool (RSC).
- A. C. Bradley (1904): argued that Lear dies not in pain but in ecstasy, and that an actor should attempt to express 'an unbearable joy' as Lear believes Cordelia breathes.
- Mark scheme interpretations: Ignatieff on the heath as 'a place in the mind' (June 2024); McCluskie on misogyny (June 2025); Marxist readings of corrupting power and historicist readings of divine right (June 2022, January 2023).
- Productions: Burbage as the first Lear; Garrick in Tate's version; Gielgud's 1940 Old Vic Lear; Brook's 1962 RSC production with Scofield and his 1971 film; Kozintsev's 1970 film; Kathryn Hunter's 1997 Lear (RSC).
Worked example
How can Nahum Tate's adaptation be used as AO5 in an essay on suffering and justice?
- Fact: Tate's version, with Cordelia surviving to marry Edgar, replaced Shakespeare's on stage from 1681 to 1838 (RSC).
- Interpretation: audiences and critics found the original ending unbearable because it denies poetic justice.
- Use: set this against a modern view that the bleakness is the point: the play refuses to make suffering meaningful.
- Counterweight: Bradley's reading that Lear dies in 'an unbearable joy' finds a kind of redemption in the final moments.
Answer: Tate's happy ending shows how strongly earlier audiences wanted justice; set against Bradley and modern bleak readings, it lets you argue about whether the play's suffering has any meaning.
Check yourself
- Which source provided the Gloucester subplot, according to the RSC?
- Holinshed's Chronicles
- Montaigne's Essays
- Sir Philip Sidney's Arcadia
- Spenser's Faerie Queene
Show answer
Sir Philip Sidney's Arcadia. A king blinded by his illegitimate son.
- What did Shakespeare take from Harsnett's Declaration (1603)?
- The names of the fiends Poor Tom raves about
- The love test
- The French invasion
- The Fool's songs
Show answer
The names of the fiends Poor Tom raves about. Obidicut, Hobbididence, Mahu, Modo, Flibbertigibbet.
- How did Tate describe Shakespeare's original?
- 'the greatest drama of all time'
- 'a drama of political crime'
- 'a heap of jewels unstrung and unpolished'
- 'every inch a king'
Show answer
'a heap of jewels unstrung and unpolished'. Quoted in the RSC stage history.
- For how long did Tate's version replace Shakespeare's on stage, according to the RSC?
- From 1606 to 1623
- From 1681 to 1838
- From 1900 to 1950
- It was never performed
Show answer
From 1681 to 1838. Macready restored the original in 1838.
- Which statement about the two texts is supported by the ISE introduction?
- The two texts are identical
- Only the Folio survives
- The Quarto was printed in 1623
- The Quarto has about 285 lines not in the Folio, and the Folio about 102 not in the Quarto
Show answer
The Quarto has about 285 lines not in the Folio, and the Folio about 102 not in the Quarto. Warren and Taylor argued the Folio is a revision.
- How does the January 2025 mark scheme describe the play's world?
- A comedy set in Italy
- A Christian play set in a pagan world
- A history play about Elizabeth I
- A play set in Shakespeare's London
Show answer
A Christian play set in a pagan world. Characters swear by pagan gods; the audience was Christian.
- Explain why the opening scene might have alarmed an audience at the court of James I.
Show answer
James wanted to unite his kingdoms, so a king who divides Britain and gives away power would look like dangerous political folly that leads to civil war and invasion.. James's wish for union against Lear's division.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: King Lear, dates and sources
- Internet Shakespeare Editions: King Lear, the two versions (Quarto and Folio)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: King Lear, stage history
- A. C. Bradley, Shakespearean Tragedy (1904), King Lear lectures (Shakespeare Navigators edition)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2022 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2023
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.