All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Measure for Measure: context and critical reception
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Measure for Measure was written for the first years of James I's reign, adapted from Italian and English sources, and has been called a 'problem play' and a 'dark comedy'. Its endings and its Isabella have been reinterpreted constantly in performance.
Sources and date
From the RSC:
- First published in the First Folio (1623), 'recognised in the First Folio onwards as a comedy'.
- First recorded performance: James I's Christmas celebrations, 26 December 1604; usually dated 1604 or late 1603.
- Cinthio's Hecatommithi (1565): the tale of Epitia, who sleeps with her abuser only to find he has already executed her brother; a tragedy. Shakespeare used the same collection for *Othello*.
- George Whetstone's Promos and Cassandra (1578): a drama based on Cinthio that adds comic elements including the Mistress Overdone subplot.
- Shakespeare's changes: the bed trick, which keeps Isabella chaste, and Mariana becoming Angelo's wife.
Britannica also names Cinthio's tragedy *Epitia* among the sources.
Contexts
- James I: a new king who had written on kingship; the January 2024 mark scheme cites James's ideas on virtuous rulers and his edict on demolishing suburban buildings; the June 2025 mark scheme notes a contested reading of the play as instruction in just rule.
- Religion: Isabella's convent of Saint Clare (the June 2025 mark scheme mentions the strict 'Isabella Rule' of the London convent of Saint Clare); friars and confession in a Protestant country; Puritan demands for strict moral laws.
- Marriage law: Claudio and Juliet's private contract without public ceremony; the June 2025 and January 2025 mark schemes list courtship and marriage contexts; Angelo's broken contract with Mariana.
- The city: suburbs, brothels and the plague; the June 2024 mark scheme mentions London's plague and James I's succession.
- Genre: the 'problem play' or tragicomedy; the June 2024 mark scheme quotes MacDonald calling it 'the very darkest of all (the) comedies'.
Reception and performance
- Problem play: the RSC notes its dark themes and tone mean it is 'often classified as one of Shakespeare's problem plays'.
- Isabella's silence: Britannica says whether she accepts the Duke is 'a matter of theatrical choice'; productions have had her accept, hesitate, refuse or walk away.
- RSC productions: Judi Dench as Isabella (1962); Barry Kyle (1978), Adrian Noble (1983), Sean Holmes (2003), Roxana Silbert (2011), Gregory Doran (2019); the RSC timeline traces how interpretations have reflected the politics of their time.
- Mark scheme interpretations: Hytner (1988) and McBurney (2006) productions (June 2024); gender readings of Isabella; Marxist readings of unequal power; psychoanalytic readings of the Duke's motives (June 2023, January 2023).
Worked example
Use the play's sources as AO3 evidence in an essay on Isabella.
- Fact: in Cinthio, Epitia sleeps with her abuser; in Whetstone's version too the heroine yields (the RSC says Shakespeare's main change is the bed trick, which keeps Isabella chaste).
- Interpretation: Shakespeare deliberately makes his heroine a novice who refuses, raising the moral stakes.
- Effect: the substitution of Mariana preserves Isabella's chastity but uses another woman's body, which complicates admiration for the solution.
- Link: this change also makes the comic ending possible.
Answer: By changing his sources so that Isabella refuses and Mariana substitutes, Shakespeare sharpens the conflict between chastity and compassion and turns a tragic tale into a troubling comedy.
Check yourself
- When is the first recorded performance of Measure for Measure, according to the RSC?
- 1590, at the Globe
- 1623, when the Folio was printed
- 26 December 1604, at James I's Christmas celebrations
- 1642, before the theatres closed
Show answer
26 December 1604, at James I's Christmas celebrations. A court performance in the new reign.
- Which source added comic elements such as the Mistress Overdone subplot?
- George Whetstone's Promos and Cassandra (1578)
- Cinthio's Hecatommithi
- Holinshed's Chronicles
- Saxo's Historia Danica
Show answer
George Whetstone's Promos and Cassandra (1578). Whetstone dramatised Cinthio's tale.
- What major change did Shakespeare make to his sources, according to the RSC?
- He made the brother die
- He set the play in London
- He added the bed trick, which keeps Isabella chaste
- He removed the Duke
Show answer
He added the bed trick, which keeps Isabella chaste. The heroine yields in the sources.
- Which other play did Shakespeare base on Cinthio's Hecatommithi?
- Hamlet
- Othello
- King Lear
- The Taming of the Shrew
Show answer
Othello. The RSC notes the shared source.
- How does the June 2024 mark scheme quote MacDonald describing the play?
- 'a drama of political crime'
- 'a heap of jewels unstrung'
- 'almost one continued moral'
- 'the very darkest of all (the) comedies'
Show answer
'the very darkest of all (the) comedies'. A genre reading.
- Which actor played Isabella in the RSC's 1962 production, according to its timeline?
- Ellen Terry
- Judi Dench
- Sarah Siddons
- Kathryn Hunter
Show answer
Judi Dench. Pictured on the RSC timeline page.
- Explain how the context of James I's new reign can illuminate the Duke.
Show answer
James was a new king interested in how to rule well, so a duke who tests his deputy, moves among his people in disguise and ends by dispensing justice and mercy can be read as a study of good or flawed kingship.. New king, ideas of rule, the Duke as ruler.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: Measure for Measure, dates and sources
- Britannica: Measure for Measure, print article
- Royal Shakespeare Company: Measure for Measure, production timeline
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2023
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.