All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Measure for Measure: plot and structure act by act
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Measure for Measure was written around 1603 to 1604, early in the reign of James I, and its first recorded performance was at court on 26 December 1604 (RSC). It is a comedy in the First Folio, but its threatened execution, sexual blackmail and uneasy ending have made it one of Shakespeare's 'problem plays'.
Acts 1 and 2: the law enforced
Act 1: Vincentio, Duke of Vienna, announces he is leaving and hands his power to Angelo, with old Escalus as his second. Vienna's strict laws against sexual licence have long gone unenforced. Angelo at once arrests Claudio, who has made his betrothed, Juliet, pregnant before their public marriage, and sentences him to death; a proclamation orders the brothels of the suburbs pulled down, to the dismay of Mistress Overdone and her servant Pompey. The Duke secretly stays in Vienna disguised as a friar, saying 'Lord Angelo is precise' and that the test will show 'If power change purpose, what our seemers be'. The witty Lucio fetches Claudio's sister Isabella, a novice about to enter the order of Saint Clare, to plead for him.
Act 2: Escalus urges mercy, but Angelo replies 'We must not make a scarecrow of the law'. Constable Elbow brings Pompey and Froth before them in a comic trial. Isabella pleads with Angelo; Lucio urges her on ('You are too cold'). She argues that authority makes 'man, proud man, / Drest in a little brief authority' play 'such fantastic tricks before high heaven / As make the angels weep'. Alone, Angelo discovers his desire: 'What's this, what's this? Is this her fault or mine?' Next day he offers to spare Claudio if Isabella sleeps with him; when she threatens to expose him he answers 'Who will believe thee, Isabel?' Alone she concludes: 'Then, Isabel, live chaste, and, brother, die: / More than our brother is our chastity.'
Act 3: the prison
The disguised Duke counsels Claudio to 'Be absolute for death'. Isabella tells Claudio of Angelo's offer; he first accepts death, then breaks: 'Ay, but to die, and go we know not where'; 'Sweet sister, let me live.' She turns on him: 'O you beast! / O faithless coward! O dishonest wretch!' The Duke proposes the bed trick: Mariana, whom Angelo abandoned when her dowry was lost at sea, will take Isabella's place at the assignation. Pompey is arrested again; Lucio slanders the absent Duke to the disguised Duke himself; Mistress Overdone is taken to prison. The Duke's rhyming soliloquy ends: 'O, what may man within him hide, / Though angel on the outward side!'
Acts 4 and 5: substitutions and judgement
Act 4: At the 'moated grange' Mariana agrees to the plan, and the bed trick takes place. Angelo breaks his promise and orders Claudio's execution. The Duke tries to substitute the head of the drunken prisoner Barnardine, who refuses to die; instead a pirate, Ragozine, conveniently dies of fever, and his head is sent to Angelo. The Duke tells Isabella that Claudio is dead. Lucio calls the Duke 'the old fantastical duke of dark corners'. Angelo, alone, is tormented by guilt.
Act 5: The Duke returns in state. Isabella publicly accuses Angelo and is disbelieved; Mariana appears veiled; when Lucio pulls the hood from the 'friar', the Duke is revealed. Angelo confesses and asks for death. The Duke orders him to marry Mariana and then be executed: 'An Angelo for Claudio, death for death! / Haste still pays haste, and leisure answers leisure; / Like doth quit like, and measure still for measure.' Mariana begs Isabella to kneel with her, and Isabella pleads for Angelo's life. Claudio is revealed alive; Angelo and Barnardine are pardoned; Lucio must marry Kate Keepdown, the mother of his child ('Marrying a punk, my lord, is pressing to death'). The Duke twice proposes to Isabella; the text gives her no reply. Britannica notes that whether she accepts is 'a matter of theatrical choice'.
Worked example
Explain how the bed trick works structurally and why it matters.
- Problem: Isabella must either sleep with Angelo or let Claudio die; both options are tragic.
- Solution: the Duke substitutes Mariana, Angelo's abandoned betrothed, in the dark.
- Structural effect: the trick turns the plot from tragedy towards comedy, and sets up the public unmasking of Act 5.
- Source: the RSC notes that the bed trick, which keeps Isabella chaste, is Shakespeare's own change to his sources.
- Problem: it relies on deception by a ruler disguised as a friar, which troubles many readers.
Answer: The bed trick is the hinge that turns tragedy into comedy, but because it is engineered through disguise and deceit, it also makes the comic ending feel manipulated rather than earned.
Check yourself
- Why is Claudio sentenced to death?
- He has murdered a nobleman
- He has insulted the Duke
- He has stolen from the church
- He has made his betrothed, Juliet, pregnant before their public marriage
Show answer
He has made his betrothed, Juliet, pregnant before their public marriage. Angelo revives an old law against fornication.
- What does Angelo offer Isabella?
- To marry her
- To spare Claudio if she sleeps with him
- To make her abbess
- To release her from the convent
Show answer
To spare Claudio if she sleeps with him. Sexual blackmail in 2.4.
- Who takes Isabella's place in the bed trick?
- Juliet
- Mistress Overdone
- Kate Keepdown
- Mariana, Angelo's abandoned betrothed
Show answer
Mariana, Angelo's abandoned betrothed. She was abandoned when her dowry was lost at sea.
- Whose head is sent to Angelo instead of Claudio's?
- Ragozine's, a pirate who died of fever
- Barnardine's
- Lucio's
- Pompey's
Show answer
Ragozine's, a pirate who died of fever. Barnardine refuses to die; Ragozine dies conveniently.
- What is Lucio's punishment in Act 5?
- He is executed
- He is banished to Poland
- He must marry Kate Keepdown, the mother of his child
- He becomes a friar
Show answer
He must marry Kate Keepdown, the mother of his child. 'Marrying a punk, my lord, is pressing to death.'
- How does Isabella respond in the text to the Duke's proposals?
- The text gives her no reply, so productions must decide
- She accepts at once
- She refuses and returns to the convent
- She faints
Show answer
The text gives her no reply, so productions must decide. Britannica calls it a matter of theatrical choice.
- Why does the ending of Measure for Measure feel uneasy for many audiences?
Show answer
Because the comic marriages are forced or unwanted, Angelo is pardoned after his crimes, and Isabella gives no answer to the Duke's proposal, so the resolution feels imposed rather than happy.. Forced marriages, easy pardon, silent Isabella.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: Measure for Measure, dates and sources
- Britannica: Measure for Measure, print article
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.