All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Donne: Song, Woman's Constancy and The Apparition

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

These poems show the cynical, mocking side of Donne's love poetry. The June 2024 question on Song asked about mood and tone; the June 2025 question on Woman's Constancy asked about relationships. Read them against the tender poems: the contrast is useful for second-poem choices.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Song ('Go and catch a falling star')

Woman's Constancy

The Apparition

Worked example

Compare the endings of Song and Woman's Constancy.

  1. Song: even a true woman would be 'False, ere I come, to two, or three': the cynicism tightens.
  2. Woman's Constancy: 'For by tomorrow, I may think so too': the speaker admits his own inconstancy.
  3. Effect: Song blames women absolutely; Woman's Constancy turns the satire back on the man, so its misogyny is undercut.
  4. Method: both use a final twist, a common Donne strategy, but the second is self-ironic.

Answer: Both poems end with a twist, but where Song seals its misogyny with a final jibe, Woman's Constancy ironically turns the charge of fickleness on the speaker himself.

Key idea: Song: impossible tasks, 'Nowhere / Lives a woman true, and fair', jaunty form against bitter message. Woman's Constancy: imagined excuses, mock-legal argument, 'by tomorrow, I may think so too'. The Apparition: Petrarchan 'murderess' literalised into a ghostly revenge.

Check yourself

  1. What is the effect of the impossible tasks at the start of Song?
    • They suggest that finding a faithful, beautiful woman is equally impossible
    • They describe a real journey
    • They praise women's virtue
    • They are instructions for a scientific experiment
    Show answer

    They suggest that finding a faithful, beautiful woman is equally impossible. The list prepares the punchline.

  2. How does Woman's Constancy end?
    • The woman promises to be faithful forever
    • The speaker dies
    • The speaker admits that by tomorrow he may think the same
    • They marry
    Show answer

    The speaker admits that by tomorrow he may think the same. 'For by tomorrow, I may think so too.'

  3. What does the speaker threaten in The Apparition?
    • To return as a ghost and find the woman with another lover
    • To marry her sister
    • To kill her new lover
    • To publish her letters
    Show answer

    To return as a ghost and find the woman with another lover. A revenge haunting.

  4. Which convention does The Apparition literalise?
    • The carpe diem argument
    • The dawn parting
    • The pastoral invitation
    • The Petrarchan cruel mistress who 'kills' her lover with scorn
    Show answer

    The Petrarchan cruel mistress who 'kills' her lover with scorn. 'O murd'ress'.

  5. Which critic does the June 2025 mark scheme quote as saying that in Donne 'neither sensual passion, nor gay and cynical wit, nor scorn and anger, is the dominant note'?
    • Johnson
    • Grierson
    • Eliot
    • Bradley
    Show answer

    Grierson. Grierson edited the anthology Eliot reviewed.

  6. What contrast creates the tone of Song?
    • Long blank verse against comic content
    • Religious language against love
    • Rhyming couplets against free verse
    • Jaunty, song-like rhythm against a bitter message
    Show answer

    Jaunty, song-like rhythm against a bitter message. Music and cynicism clash.

  7. Is Song simply misogynist? Give a balanced answer.
    Show answer

    Its message that no woman is true and fair is misogynist, but the exaggerated impossible tasks and jaunty tone suggest a performance of cynicism, so it may mock the speaker's bitterness as much as women.. Misogynist message, but exaggeration and tone suggest performance.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.