All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Donne: Song, Woman's Constancy and The Apparition
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
These poems show the cynical, mocking side of Donne's love poetry. The June 2024 question on Song asked about mood and tone; the June 2025 question on Woman's Constancy asked about relationships. Read them against the tender poems: the contrast is useful for second-poem choices.
Song ('Go and catch a falling star')
- Impossible tasks: 'Go and catch a falling star, / Get with child a mandrake root', 'Teach me to hear mermaids singing': a list of imperatives, each as impossible as the last.
- The point: even if you travelled for years you would find 'Nowhere / Lives a woman true, and fair'.
- Twist: if you did find one, 'Yet do not, I would not go, / Though at next door we might meet': by the time he arrived she would be 'False, ere I come, to two, or three'.
- Form: song-like stanzas with short lines and strong rhymes; the jaunty music clashes with the bitter message.
- Readings: the June 2024 mark scheme lists imperatives, fantastic imagery, bitterness at the end and misogynist representation of women; one reading treats the poem as a performance of cynicism, a joke the reader is invited to share or reject.
Woman's Constancy
- Situation: 'Now thou hast loved me one whole day, / Tomorrow when thou leav'st, what wilt thou say?' The speaker imagines the excuses she will give for leaving.
- Mock-legal arguments: lovers' vows made in one state can be broken in another; 'sleep, death's image' dissolves contracts.
- Twist: 'Vain lunatic, against these scapes I could / Dispute, and conquer, if I would, / Which I abstain to do, / For by tomorrow, I may think so too.' He is no more constant than she.
- Mark scheme points (June 2025): diction of 'lovers' contracts' and 'true marriages'; direct questions; the ironic ending; context of marriage consent; Grierson on the balance of passion, wit, scorn and anger.
The Apparition
- A threat: 'When by thy scorn, O murd'ress, I am dead', the speaker will return as a ghost to find her in bed with another man.
- Petrarchan reversal: the cruel mistress who 'kills' her lover is a convention; Donne literalises it into a revenge haunting.
- Images: her new lover will pretend to be asleep; she will lie 'A verier ghost than I', bathed in a cold sweat.
- Ending: he will not say what he will tell her, because he would rather she 'painfully repent' than stay 'innocent' through his threats.
- Tone: bitter, vengeful, darkly comic; useful for questions on mood, women, or revenge.
Worked example
Compare the endings of Song and Woman's Constancy.
- Song: even a true woman would be 'False, ere I come, to two, or three': the cynicism tightens.
- Woman's Constancy: 'For by tomorrow, I may think so too': the speaker admits his own inconstancy.
- Effect: Song blames women absolutely; Woman's Constancy turns the satire back on the man, so its misogyny is undercut.
- Method: both use a final twist, a common Donne strategy, but the second is self-ironic.
Answer: Both poems end with a twist, but where Song seals its misogyny with a final jibe, Woman's Constancy ironically turns the charge of fickleness on the speaker himself.
Check yourself
- What is the effect of the impossible tasks at the start of Song?
- They suggest that finding a faithful, beautiful woman is equally impossible
- They describe a real journey
- They praise women's virtue
- They are instructions for a scientific experiment
Show answer
They suggest that finding a faithful, beautiful woman is equally impossible. The list prepares the punchline.
- How does Woman's Constancy end?
- The woman promises to be faithful forever
- The speaker dies
- The speaker admits that by tomorrow he may think the same
- They marry
Show answer
The speaker admits that by tomorrow he may think the same. 'For by tomorrow, I may think so too.'
- What does the speaker threaten in The Apparition?
- To return as a ghost and find the woman with another lover
- To marry her sister
- To kill her new lover
- To publish her letters
Show answer
To return as a ghost and find the woman with another lover. A revenge haunting.
- Which convention does The Apparition literalise?
- The carpe diem argument
- The dawn parting
- The pastoral invitation
- The Petrarchan cruel mistress who 'kills' her lover with scorn
Show answer
The Petrarchan cruel mistress who 'kills' her lover with scorn. 'O murd'ress'.
- Which critic does the June 2025 mark scheme quote as saying that in Donne 'neither sensual passion, nor gay and cynical wit, nor scorn and anger, is the dominant note'?
- Johnson
- Grierson
- Eliot
- Bradley
Show answer
Grierson. Grierson edited the anthology Eliot reviewed.
- What contrast creates the tone of Song?
- Long blank verse against comic content
- Religious language against love
- Rhyming couplets against free verse
- Jaunty, song-like rhythm against a bitter message
Show answer
Jaunty, song-like rhythm against a bitter message. Music and cynicism clash.
- Is Song simply misogynist? Give a balanced answer.
Show answer
Its message that no woman is true and fair is misogynist, but the exaggerated impossible tasks and jaunty tone suggest a performance of cynicism, so it may mock the speaker's bitterness as much as women.. Misogynist message, but exaggeration and tone suggest performance.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Pearson IAL English Literature Appendix 5: prescribed texts, version 1.4 (May 2021): Unit 4 anthologies and prescribed poems
- Standard Ebooks: John Donne, Poetry (text used to check quotations)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.