All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Section A: turning the assertion into a thesis

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Every Section A question opens with an assertion in inverted commas, for example that Claudius is 'little more than a comic-book villain' (January 2025) or that Hamlet's mental disintegration 'resonates fully with modern audiences' (June 2025). The examiner reports say the best answers use the assertion to generate a thesis and keep returning to its terms. This lesson gives a method for doing that in the time you have.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Decode the question

1. Underline the key words of the assertion and ask what each one claims. In 'little more than a comic-book villain', the key words are *little more than* (a limit), *comic-book* (crude, exaggerated, flat) and *villain*.

2. Read the task that follows ('Explore the presentation of Claudius...'). The January 2023 report warned against answering only this second part.

3. Note the reminders: relevant contextual factors (AO3) and different interpretations (AO5).

4. Decide your position: agree, disagree, or agree in part. A qualified position ('Claudius is a villain, but far from a comic-book one') usually gives the richest essay.

Build the plan

Language that keeps you on task

Worked example

Plan an answer to: 'Claudius is little more than a comic-book villain.' Explore the presentation of Claudius in the light of this statement.

  1. Key words: 'little more than' (limits him), 'comic-book' (flat, exaggerated), 'villain'.
  2. Thesis: Claudius commits a villain's crimes, but Shakespeare gives him political skill and a conscience, so he is never a comic-book figure.
  3. Line 1: his first court speech is smooth and diplomatic (1.2), which the January 2025 mark scheme set against the 'comic book villain' idea.
  4. Line 2: the Ghost calls him a serpent and Hamlet a 'smiling, damned villain' (1.5): the play does present him as a villain, so the assertion is partly right.
  5. Line 3: 'O, my offence is rank' and 'My words fly up, my thoughts remain below' (3.3): guilt and failed repentance complicate the label.
  6. Context and AO5: succession anxiety; a reading in the mark scheme that sees Rosencrantz and Guildenstern as 'the king's creatures' shows his network of power.

Answer: A qualified thesis built from the assertion's own words, tested line by line against the play.

Key idea: Underline the assertion's key words, read the task, decide a qualified position, plan three or four lines of argument each with references, method, context and an interpretation, and keep using the assertion's words to the end.

Check yourself

  1. According to the January 2023 report, what should candidates do with a Section A question?
    • Answer only the task in the second sentence
    • Ignore the assertion if they disagree
    • Consider the opening assertion and the task that follows it
    • Write about the whole play in order
    Show answer

    Consider the opening assertion and the task that follows it. Answers should not address only the second part.

  2. Which opening sentence best responds to 'Hamlet's mental disintegration resonates fully with modern audiences'?
    • Hamlet's grief and self-loathing feel strikingly modern, yet Shakespeare frames them through Elizabethan ideas of melancholy, so the resonance is real but not complete
    • Hamlet is a play by Shakespeare written around 1601
    • Hamlet goes mad in the play
    • Modern audiences like Hamlet
    Show answer

    Hamlet's grief and self-loathing feel strikingly modern, yet Shakespeare frames them through Elizabethan ideas of melancholy, so the resonance is real but not complete. It takes a position using the assertion's terms ('resonates fully') and sets up a debate.

  3. What weakness did the June 2024 and June 2025 reports find in some Section A answers?
    • Too many short quotations
    • Too much reference to performance
    • Pre-learned essays adapted only slightly to the question
    • Answers that disagreed with the assertion
    Show answer

    Pre-learned essays adapted only slightly to the question. Responsiveness to the exact wording is rewarded.

  4. Which is a 'line of argument' rather than a scene summary?
    • In Act 3 Scene 3 Claudius tries to pray
    • Shakespeare gives Claudius a conscience, so his villainy becomes tragic rather than cartoonish
    • Claudius marries Gertrude
    • Hamlet sees the Ghost
    Show answer

    Shakespeare gives Claudius a conscience, so his villainy becomes tragic rather than cartoonish. A line of argument is a claim about the play that answers the question.

  5. What did the June 2023 report advise about style?
    • Always use 'I think'
    • Use as many technical terms as possible
    • Write in note form
    • Avoid first-person pronouns
    Show answer

    Avoid first-person pronouns. An analytical, impersonal register is safer.

  6. Explain how to decode the assertion at the start of a Section A question.
    Show answer

    Pick out its key words, work out exactly what each one claims, and decide how far you agree, ready to test each word against the play.. Key words, their claims, your position.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.