All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

The Taming of the Shrew: context and critical reception

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Few Shakespeare plays have provoked such changing responses. Its sources lie in folk tales and Italian comedy; its ideas about wives echo official sermons; and its stage history ranges from Garrick's whip to all-female productions.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Sources and texts

From the RSC:

Social contexts

Reception and criticism

Worked example

Use stage history to support a point about Kate's final speech.

  1. Fact 1: Garrick's 1754 adaptation introduced the whip as a prop (RSC): a reading that stresses domination.
  2. Fact 2: Pickford winked at the camera during the speech in 1929: an ironic reading.
  3. Fact 3: Marowitz's 1975 version had Kate deliver it as a 'brain-washed automaton': a tragic reading.
  4. Point: the words are fixed but their meaning changes completely with performance, so the speech is one of the play's most open moments.

Answer: Stage history shows the final speech played as triumph, irony or tragedy, which supports the argument that Shakespeare leaves its meaning open to performance.

Key idea: Date 1590 to 1591; Folio 1623; A Shrew 1594 (memorial reconstruction?). Sources: folk tales of taming, Gascoigne's Supposes from Ariosto, the beggar-king tale, Erasmus, Vives, the Homily on Marriage. Reception: Fletcher's Tamer Tamed, Garrick, Pickford, Kiss Me Kate, Zeffirelli, Marowitz, Lloyd; Shaw, Goddard, Wells, Bloom.

Check yourself

  1. What does the RSC say about The Taming of A Shrew (1594)?
    • It is Shakespeare's sequel
    • It was written by Fletcher
    • It has no Induction
    • Many believe it is a memorial reconstruction of Shakespeare's play, and in it Sly stays on stage throughout
    Show answer

    Many believe it is a memorial reconstruction of Shakespeare's play, and in it Sly stays on stage throughout. An imperfectly remembered version.

  2. What is John Fletcher's The Woman's Prize, or The Tamer Tamed?
    • A source for the Bianca plot
    • A reply in which a widowed Petruchio is tamed by his new wife
    • A Victorian adaptation
    • A sermon on marriage
    Show answer

    A reply in which a widowed Petruchio is tamed by his new wife. About 1611; role reversal.

  3. Which source lies behind the Bianca plot?
    • Holinshed's Chronicles
    • Cinthio's Hecatommithi
    • Saxo Grammaticus
    • Gascoigne's Supposes (1566), translated from Ariosto
    Show answer

    Gascoigne's Supposes (1566), translated from Ariosto. RSC and Britannica agree.

  4. What did George Bernard Shaw say about the ending?
    • No man 'with any decency of feeling' could sit it out in the company of a woman
    • It is Shakespeare's finest scene
    • It is a perfect model of marriage
    • It should be sung
    Show answer

    No man 'with any decency of feeling' could sit it out in the company of a woman. Quoted on the WSU site.

  5. How does Harold Bloom read Kate's final speech?
    • As sincere submission
    • As a joke about Sly
    • As advising women how to rule absolutely while feigning obedience
    • As a translation of Erasmus
    Show answer

    As advising women how to rule absolutely while feigning obedience. An ironic reading.

  6. What did Garrick introduce in Catharine and Petruchio (1754), according to the RSC?
    • The whip as a prop
    • An all-female cast
    • A happy ending for Sly
    • The Induction
    Show answer

    The whip as a prop. A domineering Petruchio.

  7. Give two contrasting critical readings of the play's ending.
    Show answer

    A literal reading sees Kate's speech as sincere submission to patriarchy, which Shaw found offensive, while an ironic reading, like Bloom's, sees her performing obedience to gain power or sharing a game with Petruchio.. Sincere submission against irony and performance.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.