All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
The Taming of the Shrew: context and critical reception
Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry
Few Shakespeare plays have provoked such changing responses. Its sources lie in folk tales and Italian comedy; its ideas about wives echo official sermons; and its stage history ranges from Garrick's whip to all-female productions.
Sources and texts
From the RSC:
- Mostly dated 1590 to 1591 on grounds of style, structure and language; first printed in the First Folio (1623).
- The Taming of A Shrew (anonymous, 1594) differs from the Folio but has many similarities; many believe it is a 'memorial reconstruction' of Shakespeare's play. In it, Sly stays on stage throughout.
- Folk tales of taming a wayward wife appear across Europe, India and the Americas, with a favoured younger sister, a taming, an obedience test and a wager; some use cunning, some violence, such as the *Merry Jest of a Shrewde and Curste Wyfe, Lapped in Morrelles Skin* (printed 1550).
- Gascoigne's Supposes (1566), from Ariosto's *I Suppositi*, behind the Bianca plot (also Britannica).
- The beggar made king is an old folk tale found in the *Arabian Nights*.
- Kate's final speech echoes a colloquy by Erasmus; Vives's *Office and Duetie of an Husband* and the Homily on Marriage set out the Christian duties of marriage.
Social contexts
- Patriarchy and marriage: wives were legally and religiously subject to husbands; the Homily on Marriage (from 1562) was read in churches.
- Arranged marriage and dowry: the January 2023 mark scheme lists arranged marriage and patriarchy; the January 2025 mark scheme lists changing early modern courtship customs.
- Shrews and scolds: women who argued publicly could be punished; the play's title draws on this.
- Clothes and status: the June 2024 report noted answers on sumptuary laws (laws on who could wear what).
- Padua: the June 2025 mark scheme describes 1590s Padua as a prosperous city where people sought fortunes, contrasted with the English Induction and Petruchio's country house.
Reception and criticism
- Fletcher's reply (about 1611), *The Woman's Prize, or The Tamer Tamed*: a widowed Petruchio is tamed by his new wife; in 1633 both plays were performed at court and 'both were liked' (RSC).
- Adaptations: Garrick's *Catharine and Petruchio* (1754, with a whip); the 1929 Pickford and Fairbanks film; *Kiss Me Kate* (1948); Zeffirelli's 1966 film with Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton; Marowitz's 1975 version; Lloyd's all-female Globe production (2003) (RSC).
- Critics (WSU Shakespeare site): Shaw said no man 'with any decency of feeling' could sit through the ending in the company of a woman; Goddard argued the play means 'the precise opposite' of what the multitude would take it to mean; Stanley Wells sees Kate reaching 'a full realization of her potentialities'; Harold Bloom reads her final speech as 'advising women how to rule absolutely, while feigning obedience'.
- Mark scheme interpretations: Hibbard (historicist), Kantor and Morrison (post-feminist) (June 2022); Novy (June 2025); Karen Newman and Catherine Bates were cited in a strong January 2025 answer.
Worked example
Use stage history to support a point about Kate's final speech.
- Fact 1: Garrick's 1754 adaptation introduced the whip as a prop (RSC): a reading that stresses domination.
- Fact 2: Pickford winked at the camera during the speech in 1929: an ironic reading.
- Fact 3: Marowitz's 1975 version had Kate deliver it as a 'brain-washed automaton': a tragic reading.
- Point: the words are fixed but their meaning changes completely with performance, so the speech is one of the play's most open moments.
Answer: Stage history shows the final speech played as triumph, irony or tragedy, which supports the argument that Shakespeare leaves its meaning open to performance.
Check yourself
- What does the RSC say about The Taming of A Shrew (1594)?
- It is Shakespeare's sequel
- It was written by Fletcher
- It has no Induction
- Many believe it is a memorial reconstruction of Shakespeare's play, and in it Sly stays on stage throughout
Show answer
Many believe it is a memorial reconstruction of Shakespeare's play, and in it Sly stays on stage throughout. An imperfectly remembered version.
- What is John Fletcher's The Woman's Prize, or The Tamer Tamed?
- A source for the Bianca plot
- A reply in which a widowed Petruchio is tamed by his new wife
- A Victorian adaptation
- A sermon on marriage
Show answer
A reply in which a widowed Petruchio is tamed by his new wife. About 1611; role reversal.
- Which source lies behind the Bianca plot?
- Holinshed's Chronicles
- Cinthio's Hecatommithi
- Saxo Grammaticus
- Gascoigne's Supposes (1566), translated from Ariosto
Show answer
Gascoigne's Supposes (1566), translated from Ariosto. RSC and Britannica agree.
- What did George Bernard Shaw say about the ending?
- No man 'with any decency of feeling' could sit it out in the company of a woman
- It is Shakespeare's finest scene
- It is a perfect model of marriage
- It should be sung
Show answer
No man 'with any decency of feeling' could sit it out in the company of a woman. Quoted on the WSU site.
- How does Harold Bloom read Kate's final speech?
- As sincere submission
- As a joke about Sly
- As advising women how to rule absolutely while feigning obedience
- As a translation of Erasmus
Show answer
As advising women how to rule absolutely while feigning obedience. An ironic reading.
- What did Garrick introduce in Catharine and Petruchio (1754), according to the RSC?
- The whip as a prop
- An all-female cast
- A happy ending for Sly
- The Induction
Show answer
The whip as a prop. A domineering Petruchio.
- Give two contrasting critical readings of the play's ending.
Show answer
A literal reading sees Kate's speech as sincere submission to patriarchy, which Shaw found offensive, while an ironic reading, like Bloom's, sees her performing obedience to gain power or sharing a game with Petruchio.. Sincere submission against irony and performance.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in English Literature specification (Unit 4: Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry; assessment objectives and weightings), copy hosted by a centre
- Pearson Edexcel IAL English Literature Getting Started guide (Unit 4 overview, set texts, question format and scheme of work)
- Royal Shakespeare Company: The Taming of the Shrew, dates and sources
- Britannica: The Taming of the Shrew, print article
- Royal Shakespeare Company: The Taming of the Shrew, stage history
- Washington State University (M. Delahoyde): The Taming of the Shrew, critical reactions to the ending
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2022 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2023
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 mark scheme, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson WET04 examiner report, June 2024
- Pearson WET04 examiner report, January 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.