All subjects · English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Christina Rossetti: Remember, Echo, May, A Birthday and Somewhere or Other

Edexcel IAL English Literature · WET04 Shakespeare and Pre-1900 Poetry

Rossetti's lyrics sound simple but hold intense feeling under strict control. 'Somewhere or Other' was named in June 2023 (setting) and 'May' in January 2025 (loss); 'Remember' was the suggested second poem for Hardy's 'I Look into My Glass' in June 2022.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Context

From the Poetry Foundation:

Remember, Echo and A Birthday

Remember

Echo

A Birthday

May and Somewhere or Other

May

Somewhere or Other

Worked example

Compare how Rossetti presents love in A Birthday and Somewhere or Other.

  1. A Birthday: love has arrived: 'my love is come to me'; similes of abundance ('a singing bird', 'an apple-tree') and luxurious imperatives.
  2. Somewhere or Other: love not yet found and perhaps unreachable: 'The face not seen, the voice not heard'; barriers such as 'a wall, a hedge, between'.
  3. Method: A Birthday piles similes of fullness; Somewhere or Other uses negatives and uncertainty.
  4. Context: the Poetry Foundation notes A Birthday is unusual in the 1862 volume for celebrating fulfilled love; Rossetti's own renunciations and faith shape the longing in many poems.
  5. AO5: a devotional reading sees the beloved in both as possibly divine.

Answer: A Birthday celebrates love fulfilled through overflowing similes, while Somewhere or Other locates love beyond reach, across walls and hedges, so the pair show the two poles of Rossetti's love poetry: abundance and longing.

Key idea: Rossetti: Pre-Raphaelite family, Anglo-Catholic faith, renounced engagements, Highgate penitentiary, Goblin Market and Other Poems. Remember: sonnet, 'forget and smile'. Echo: dream visits, 'speaking silence'. A Birthday: similes of fullness, love as birthday. May: loss and the 'lost' line. Somewhere or Other: unmet love, 'a wall, a hedge, between'.

Check yourself

  1. What does the sestet of Remember conclude?
    • The beloved must never forget
    • The speaker will return
    • Death is to be feared
    • It is better the beloved should forget and smile than remember and be sad
    Show answer

    It is better the beloved should forget and smile than remember and be sad. Selfless turn.

  2. Which phrase from Echo is an oxymoron?
    • 'my heart is like a singing bird'
    • 'the speaking silence of a dream'
    • 'the silent land'
    • 'Somewhere or other'
    Show answer

    'the speaking silence of a dream'. Speaking and silence.

  3. Why is the speaker's heart like a singing bird in A Birthday?
    • Because it is her actual birthday party
    • Because she is a bird
    • Because spring has come
    • Because her love has come to her: 'the birthday of my life'
    Show answer

    Because her love has come to her: 'the birthday of my life'. Love as rebirth.

  4. What does the January 2025 mark scheme say about the form of May?
    • It is a truncated Petrarchan sonnet with a 'lost' final line
    • It is a ballad
    • It is blank verse
    • It is a villanelle
    Show answer

    It is a truncated Petrarchan sonnet with a 'lost' final line. Form mirrors loss.

  5. According to the Poetry Foundation, what is unusual about A Birthday in the 1862 volume?
    • It is in prose
    • It is about war
    • It celebrates love fulfilled rather than lost
    • It was written by Dante Gabriel
    Show answer

    It celebrates love fulfilled rather than lost. Fulfilled love.

  6. Which liminal image does the June 2023 mark scheme pick out in Somewhere or Other?
    • 'a wall, a hedge, between'
    • 'the black bat, night'
    • 'a great ring of pure and endless light'
    • 'the bald street'
    Show answer

    'a wall, a hedge, between'. Barriers.

  7. How does the structure of Remember support its meaning?
    Show answer

    As a Petrarchan sonnet its octave pleads to be remembered, but the volta in the sestet turns to selflessness, saying it is better to forget and smile than remember and be sad.. Octave plea, volta, selfless sestet.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.