All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet

Bottom-up, top-down and global development goals

Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet

Spec 3.8.3 key ideas 2 and 3: small-scale bottom-up projects versus large-scale top-down projects, and the mixed success of the Millennium Development Goals and the framework set by the Sustainable Development Goals.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Key idea 2: contrasting approaches

Small-scale, bottom-up projects are planned with local people and use intermediate technology (hand pumps, solar lamps, improved cook stoves) or Fairtrade. Fairtrade guarantees a minimum price and pays a Fairtrade Premium for community projects: 1.87 million farmers and workers in more than 1,800 producer organisations, with a premium of EUR 201.6 million in 2024 (Fairtrade International, April 2026). Trade-offs: they are cheap, sustainable and empowering, but small in scale, slow to spread, and Fairtrade covers only some products, with women only 23% of Fairtrade farmers.

Large-scale, top-down projects are planned by governments, IGOs or TNCs: mega-dams, highways, ports, special economic zones. They can kick-start development by providing power, transport and jobs at a national scale, but costs and benefits are distributed unevenly: displaced communities and local environments often lose, while cities, industry and elites gain, and they can create debt. The GERD dam in Ethiopia (5,150 MW, $4 billion) is a current example: power for a country where about 45% lack electricity, but tension with Egypt downstream.

Key idea 3: global development agendas

The Millennium Development Goals (2000 to 2015): eight goals with time-bound targets. Progress was real but uneven (UN, 2015):

Skill (16) and the specification ask you to know one named country's MDG progress in detail; China's poverty reduction drove much of the global fall (World Bank, 2022).

The Sustainable Development Goals (2015 to 2030): 17 goals that apply to all countries, not just developing ones, and add environmental sustainability, inequality, cities, climate and peace. They provide a global framework for national action: governments set their own plans and report progress, but goals are voluntary and funding gaps are large.

Worked example

Extreme poverty fell from 1.9 billion people in 1990 to 836 million in 2015 (UN). Calculate the percentage fall.

  1. Fall = 1,900 million - 836 million = 1,064 million.
  2. Percentage = 1,064 / 1,900 x 100 = 56.0%.

Answer: A fall of about 56.0%, although world population grew over the same period.

Key idea: Bottom-up projects (intermediate technology, Fairtrade: 1.87 million farmers and workers, EUR 201.6 million premium in 2024) are sustainable but small; top-down projects can kick-start growth but spread costs and benefits unevenly. MDGs: extreme poverty fell from 1.9 billion to 836 million, but progress was uneven; the 17 SDGs (2015 to 2030) apply to all countries.

Check yourself

  1. Under-five mortality fell from 90 to 43 deaths per 1,000 live births between 1990 and 2015. What was the percentage fall? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
    Show answer

    52.2 %. (90 - 43) / 90 x 100 = 52.2%.

  2. The MDG target was to cut under-five mortality by two-thirds from 90 per 1,000. What rate would have met the target?
    Show answer

    30 per 1,000. 90 x (1 - 2/3) = 30 per 1,000; the actual 43 missed it.

  3. How do the SDGs differ from the MDGs?
    • The SDGs apply only to developing countries
    • The SDGs apply to all countries and add environmental and inequality goals
    • The SDGs have fewer goals than the MDGs
    • The SDGs ended in 2015
    Show answer

    The SDGs apply to all countries and add environmental and inequality goals. 17 universal goals for 2015 to 2030.

  4. Explain why the benefits of large-scale top-down development projects are often unevenly shared.
    Show answer

    Mega-projects such as dams are planned by governments and benefit cities, industry and elites with power and jobs, while local communities may be displaced from their land and lose livelihoods and the environment is damaged.. Who gains (urban, industry) versus who loses (displaced locals).

  5. In 2024 the Fairtrade Premium was EUR 201.6 million and there were 1.87 million Fairtrade farmers and workers. What is the mean premium per person in euros? Give your answer to the nearest euro.
    Show answer

    108 EUR. 201.6 / 1.87 = 107.8, about EUR 108 per person.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.