All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Energy players, unconventional fossil fuels and the carbon cycle
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Spec 3.5.2 key ideas 2 and 3: the organisations that control energy supply, the costs and benefits of unconventional fossil fuels, and how burning fossil fuels and biofuels affects the carbon cycle.
Key idea 2: energy players and unconventional fossil fuels
Players:
- OPEC (12 member countries, OPEC 2026) coordinates production quotas to influence prices.
- Supermajors and other TNCs (ExxonMobil, Shell, BP and others) explore, produce, refine and trade energy worldwide, and invest in pipelines and shipping.
- State-owned companies (Saudi Aramco and many national oil companies) control most reserves and serve national interests.
- Together they influence which supplies are developed, trade patterns, pathways and prices; consuming governments influence them through taxes, regulation and strategic reserves.
Unconventional fossil fuels:
- Tar (oil) sands, Athabasca, Alberta: oil sands underlie about 142,200 km2 with about 158.9 billion barrels of proven reserves; bitumen production averaged about 3.46 million barrels per day in 2024 up to May (Canada Energy Regulator, November 2024), and oil sands royalties were $16.9 billion in 2022 to 2023 (Government of Alberta). Benefits: jobs (about 138,000 in Alberta's upstream energy sector in 2022), revenue, secure North American supply. Costs: surface mining destroys boreal forest and peat (about 4,800 km2 is surface mineable), toxic tailings ponds, high water use, and higher carbon emissions per barrel because of the energy used to extract bitumen.
- Shale gas and tight oil, USA: fracking pumps water, sand and chemicals at high pressure to crack shale; horizontal drilling made it economic. Benefits: cheaper gas, jobs, energy independence, less coal burning. Costs: water use and contamination fears, methane leaks, small earthquakes, landscape impacts.
- Deep-water oil: technically difficult and risky (oil spills), but it adds supply.
Key idea 3: energy use and the carbon cycle
Burning fossil fuels moves carbon from slow geological stores (coal, oil and gas formed over millions of years) into the atmosphere in decades. Global energy-related emissions rose a further 1.1% in 2025 (Energy Institute). Effects:
- Climate: more CO2 enhances the greenhouse effect and warms the planet.
- Ocean acidification: the oceans absorb CO2, which forms carbonic acid, lowering pH and making it harder for corals and shellfish to build calcium carbonate skeletons.
- Ecosystem health: warming shifts biomes, bleaches corals and stresses forests.
Biofuels (biodiesel from palm or soya oil, bioethanol from sugar cane or maize) are sometimes called carbon neutral because the crop absorbs as much CO2 as is released when the fuel burns. This is questioned because:
- land clearance to grow them (especially draining and burning carbon-rich peat forest) releases huge amounts of carbon;
- fertiliser, machinery, processing and transport all use energy;
- energy crops compete with food crops for land, which can raise food prices.
Indonesia blends palm-oil biodiesel into diesel: the government mandated a 35% blend in 2024, and biodiesel production was projected to reach about 13 billion litres that year (USDA, Indonesia Biofuels Annual). The June 2025 mark scheme expected biofuels to be weighed against nuclear, renewables and electric vehicles, and against land-use change and deforestation.
Worked example
Alberta's oil sands underlie about 142,200 km2, of which about 4,800 km2 is surface mineable (Government of Alberta). What percentage is surface mineable, and what does this mean for extraction?
- 4,800 / 142,200 x 100 = 3.4%.
- Most of the bitumen is too deep to dig out, so it must be extracted underground (in situ), which uses a lot of energy and water.
- Surface mining over the mineable area destroys boreal forest and peat and leaves tailings ponds.
Answer: About 3.4%: most oil sands are extracted in situ, but surface mining has the most visible impacts.
Check yourself
- Alberta's oil sands hold about 158.9 billion barrels of proven reserves. At 3.46 million barrels per day, about how many years would they last? Give your answer to the nearest year.
Show answer
126 years. 158.9 billion / (3.46 million x 365) = 125.8, about 126 years.
- Which is an environmental cost of tar sands extraction in Athabasca?
- Release of radioactive waste
- Destruction of boreal forest and toxic tailings ponds
- Flooding of river valleys for reservoirs
- Coral bleaching in Alberta
Show answer
Destruction of boreal forest and toxic tailings ponds. Surface mining and tailings are key impacts.
- How does fossil fuel use cause ocean acidification?
- Oil spills dissolve calcium carbonate
- Coal ash raises sea levels
- Methane makes sea water alkaline
- Oceans absorb CO2, which forms carbonic acid and lowers pH
Show answer
Oceans absorb CO2, which forms carbonic acid and lowers pH. CO2 + water forms carbonic acid.
- Explain why biofuels may not be carbon neutral.
Show answer
Clearing forest or peatland to grow biofuel crops releases stored carbon, and fertiliser, machinery, processing and transport all use fossil energy, so total lifecycle emissions are greater than the CO2 the crops absorb.. Land-use change plus energy inputs, linked to emissions.
- Fracking releases shale gas by
- surface mining bitumen
- drilling under the Arctic ice
- pumping water, sand and chemicals at high pressure to crack the rock
- heating coal underground
Show answer
pumping water, sand and chemicals at high pressure to crack the rock. Horizontal drilling plus hydraulic fracturing made shale economic.
- OPEC influences world oil prices mainly by
- coordinating production quotas among its member countries
- owning all the world's refineries
- setting fuel taxes in importing countries
- controlling the Strait of Malacca
Show answer
coordinating production quotas among its member countries. Raising or cutting output changes supply.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025), Unit 3 Contested Planet
- OPEC press release (29 April 2026): Annual Statistical Bulletin 2026
- Government of Alberta: Oil sands facts and statistics
- Canada Energy Regulator Market Snapshot (13 November 2024): Existing projects largely responsible for continued production growth from Alberta oil sands
- USDA Foreign Agricultural Service: Indonesia Biofuels Annual (ID2024-0018)
- Energy Institute media release (30 June 2026): Statistical Review of World Energy 2026
- Pearson WGE03/01 mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WGE03/01 examiners' report, January 2025 series (file dated 6 March 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.