All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Explaining the development gap: theories, trade and governments
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Spec 3.8.1 key ideas 2 and 3: the theories that explain the development gap (modernisation, dependency and core-periphery), the role of trade and terms of trade, and how governments slow or speed up progress.
Key idea 2: explaining the gap
- Modernisation theory (Rostow's model): all countries pass through stages, from traditional society, through preconditions for take-off and take-off (industrialisation fuelled by investment), to the drive to maturity and high mass consumption. Poorer countries simply have not progressed yet; investment, aid and trade will help them. Critics say it is based on Western experience and ignores external constraints.
- Dependency theory: the world economy is organised so that a rich core benefits from a poor periphery. Colonialism, and later unequal trade, debt and TNC control, keep the periphery supplying cheap raw materials and labour, so wealth flows to the core. It explains persistent poverty in former colonies but struggles to explain the rise of the Asian NICs.
- Core-periphery models also work nationally: capital cities and coastal regions (core) attract investment and people from a lagging periphery.
Trade, investment and terms of trade: many developing countries export primary products (crops, minerals) whose prices are low and volatile, and import manufactured goods whose prices rise. When export prices fall relative to import prices, the terms of trade worsen and a country must export more to buy the same imports. Investment flows mostly to countries with markets, skills and stability, bypassing many of the poorest.
Key idea 3: the role of governments
Slow progress in some least developed countries: poor governance (corruption, weak institutions, failure to provide services) and political instability (coups, civil war, collapse of the state) deter investment, destroy infrastructure and divert spending.
- Haiti: HDI 0.554 (rank 166), life expectancy 64.9 years (UNDP 2025); repeated political crises and weak institutions, on top of hazards such as the 2010 earthquake.
- Somalia: HDI 0.404 (rank 192 of 193), life expectancy 58.8 years; decades of conflict and a weak central state.
Rapid progress in some NICs: government policy and investment in infrastructure and education, combined with FDI.
- South Korea: now HDI 0.937 (rank 20) with life expectancy 84.3 years; state-directed industrialisation, export promotion and heavy investment in education.
- China: close to 800 million people lifted out of extreme poverty in 40 years, about three-quarters of the global reduction, through broad-based economic transformation that raised incomes, followed by targeted support for lagging regions and poor households (World Bank, April 2022); HDI now 0.797.
Worked example
A country's export price index fell from 100 to 80 while its import price index rose from 100 to 125. Calculate its terms of trade index (export price index / import price index x 100) and explain the effect. (Illustrative figures.)
- Terms of trade = 80 / 125 x 100 = 64.
- Below 100, so the terms of trade have worsened: each unit of exports now buys only 64% as many imports as before.
- A primary exporter must sell far more crops or minerals to pay for the same machinery and fuel, which is a key argument of dependency theory.
Answer: 64: worsening terms of trade make it harder for primary exporters to develop.
Check yourself
- Dependency theory explains the development gap mainly as a result of
- countries passing through natural stages of growth
- an unequal global system in which a rich core benefits from a poor periphery
- climate differences only
- population growth alone
Show answer
an unequal global system in which a rich core benefits from a poor periphery. Core exploits periphery through trade, debt and TNCs.
- A country's terms of trade worsen when
- it exports more manufactured goods at higher prices
- its currency becomes more valuable and imports fall
- it joins a trade bloc
- its export prices fall relative to its import prices
Show answer
its export prices fall relative to its import prices. It must export more to buy the same imports.
- Explain how government policy helped South Korea develop rapidly.
Show answer
The government invested heavily in education and infrastructure and directed industrialisation towards exports, which attracted investment and created a skilled workforce, so incomes and HDI rose quickly.. Education, industrial or infrastructure policy, and the result.
- In Rostow's modernisation model, the 'take-off' stage is when
- society is based mainly on subsistence farming
- mass consumption of consumer goods is widespread
- industrialisation begins, fuelled by investment
- a country becomes a colony
Show answer
industrialisation begins, fuelled by investment. Take-off follows the preconditions stage.
- Which factor best explains slow development progress in Somalia?
- Decades of conflict and a weak central state
- Too much foreign direct investment
- A highly educated workforce
- Rapid export-led industrialisation
Show answer
Decades of conflict and a weak central state. Instability deters investment and destroys infrastructure.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025), Unit 3 Contested Planet
- UNDP Human Development Report 2025, Statistical Annex: HDI table (2023 data)
- World Bank press release (1 April 2022): Lifting 800 million people out of poverty, lessons from China's experience
- Pearson WGE03/01 mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.