All subjects · Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Superpower futures: contested spheres, developing nations and restructuring
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE03 Contested Planet
Which spheres of influence are contested, how are relationships with developing nations changing, and can existing superpowers afford their power? (spec 3.7.3, enquiry question: what spheres of influence are contested by superpowers and what are the implications of this?)
Key idea 1: contested economic and geographical spheres
- Disputed physical resources: the South China Sea (China's island-building and claims overlapping those of Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and others, over fisheries, oil, gas and shipping lanes); the Arctic (melting ice opening sea routes and access to oil, gas and minerals; claims to the seabed under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, UNCLOS, and its Exclusive Economic Zones). The January 2024 mark scheme credited UNCLOS, EEZs, the Arctic, China in the South China Sea, and Russia in Georgia, Crimea and Ukraine.
- Perceived spheres of influence: Russia regards neighbouring former Soviet states as its sphere; the USA has long regarded the Americas as its own; NATO expansion eastwards is a source of tension.
- Intellectual property: counterfeiting and copying of designs, software, medicines and brands undermines intellectual property rights, causing trade disputes and making TNCs wary of investing or sharing technology in some countries.
Key idea 2: changing relationships with developing nations
- China and Africa: China lends for and builds infrastructure (railways, ports, roads, power plants), buys oil, minerals and timber, and sells manufactured goods. Opportunities: infrastructure, jobs, trade and investment without the governance conditions attached by Western lenders. Challenges: debt sustainability, use of imported Chinese labour, competition for local manufacturers, environmental impacts and concerns about resource exploitation.
- The Middle East: cultural, political and economic tensions (religious and ethnic divisions, authoritarian governments, the Israel and Palestine conflict, rivalry between Saudi Arabia and Iran, conflict in Syria and Yemen) challenge both superpowers and emerging powers. The region's vital oil and gas and chokepoints such as the Strait of Hormuz make it geopolitically crucial, so outside powers are drawn in, which makes tensions harder to resolve.
Key idea 3: economic restructuring and the cost of power
- The USA and the EU face debt, unemployment in older industries, economic restructuring (deindustrialisation as manufacturing moved to Asia, the shift to services and technology) and social costs (inequality, ageing populations, health and pension spending). These problems can weaken their ability and willingness to act abroad.
- Military spending: some powers question whether maintaining naval, nuclear and air power, intelligence services and space exploration gives economic benefits. In 2025 US military spending fell 7.5% in real terms while Germany's rose 24% (SIPRI, April 2026). Arguments for spending: security, deterrence, technology spin-offs, jobs. Arguments against: high opportunity cost (money not spent on health, education or infrastructure).
- The January 2025 examiners' report said strong essays structured arguments around economic, military and geopolitical power, focused on the present and future rather than past world orders, and ended with a real conclusion.
Worked example
Assess whether China's growing involvement in Africa is mainly an opportunity or a challenge for African countries.
- Opportunity: new railways, ports and power plants fill infrastructure gaps; trade and investment boost growth; fewer governance conditions than some Western lenders.
- Challenge: rising debt; imported labour limits local jobs; cheap imports compete with local manufacturers; environmental damage from resource extraction.
- Judgement: it depends on the country's governance and bargaining power; where governments negotiate local jobs, skills transfer and sustainable debt, opportunities outweigh challenges.
Answer: A balanced judgement: opportunities are real, but outcomes depend on governance and debt management.
Check yourself
- In 2025 Germany spent $114 billion, the UK $89.0 billion and France $68.0 billion on the military (SIPRI). What was their combined spending in US$ billion?
Show answer
271.0 US$ bn. 114 + 89.0 + 68.0 = 271.0.
- What percentage of US military spending ($954 billion) was the combined spending of Germany, the UK and France ($271.0 billion)? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
28.4 %. 271.0 / 954 x 100 = 28.4%.
- Why is the South China Sea contested?
- Overlapping claims to islands, fisheries, oil and gas, and vital shipping lanes
- It is the only source of rare earths
- It is a landlocked lake
- It is controlled by NATO
Show answer
Overlapping claims to islands, fisheries, oil and gas, and vital shipping lanes. Resources plus strategic sea lanes.
- An Exclusive Economic Zone gives a coastal state
- control of all international shipping worldwide
- the right to ban other countries' aircraft
- ownership of the high seas
- rights to the resources of the sea and seabed out to 200 nautical miles
Show answer
rights to the resources of the sea and seabed out to 200 nautical miles. Defined under UNCLOS.
- Counterfeiting strains relations between superpowers mainly because it
- increases carbon emissions only
- undermines intellectual property rights and TNC profits
- reduces tourism
- lowers sea levels
Show answer
undermines intellectual property rights and TNC profits. IP theft deters investment and causes trade disputes.
- Which is an example of economic restructuring in the USA and EU?
- Growth of colonial empires
- The building of new coal mines in every city
- A shift from services back to farming
- Deindustrialisation as manufacturing moved to Asia
Show answer
Deindustrialisation as manufacturing moved to Asia. The shift from manufacturing to services and technology.
- Explain why tensions in the Middle East are a challenge for superpowers.
Show answer
The Middle East holds vital oil and gas reserves and chokepoints such as the Strait of Hormuz, so superpowers cannot ignore it, but religious, ethnic and political divisions and rival regional powers make conflicts hard to resolve.. Energy importance plus complex divisions.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025), Unit 3 Contested Planet
- SIPRI fact sheet (April 2026): Trends in world military expenditure, 2025
- Pearson WGE03/01 mark scheme, January 2024
- Pearson WGE03/01 examiners' report, January 2025 series (file dated 6 March 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.