All subjects · Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Research skills: sources, reliability and referencing
Edexcel IAL Geography · WGE04 Researching Geography
Unit 4 rewards independent research. This lesson covers how to turn a research focus into a research plan, find good sources, judge their reliability and reference them, which together earn marks in the Research and Quality sections of the mark scheme.
From research focus to research plan
The Getting Started Guide suggests deconstructing the focus: highlight key words, match each one to specification bullet points, and note how strong each link is. Then build a portfolio for the option:
- Concepts: definitions, models and theories you can apply (for example Park's model, the hazard management cycle, carrying capacity, the epidemiological transition).
- Case studies: a wide range at different scales (global, national, local) and in contrasting development contexts. The generic mark scheme's top research band asks for a wide range of relevant case studies across scales and locations.
- Evidence: both quantitative (numbers, dated) and qualitative (views, descriptions) data that are accurate and topical.
- Counter-evidence: examples that challenge the likely view, so you can argue both ways.
The January 2025 examiners' report criticised centres whose students submitted near-identical case studies; independent research gives breadth.
Judging sources
Rank sources by how far you can trust them:
- Primary data organisations and peer-reviewed research: UN agencies (FAO, WHO, UNESCO, UNDRR), national statistics offices, geological surveys (USGS), disaster databases (EM-DAT). Usually the most reliable, though still estimates.
- Quality media and NGOs: useful and current, but may simplify or campaign.
- Revision sites and unattributed web pages: check against a primary source before using.
Ask of every source: Who produced it and why (possible bias)? When (is it current)? How were figures collected (survey, census, estimate)? Does it agree with other sources? Example: the Haiti 2010 earthquake death toll was reported by the government as 316,000 (January 2011) but a US government-commissioned draft report estimated no more than 85,000 (Britannica). Quoting a range and explaining why it is uncertain is better evaluation than quoting one number as fact.
| Question to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Who wrote it? | Purpose and possible bias |
| When? | Topicality; data change |
| How was it measured? | Accuracy and comparability |
| Is it corroborated? | Reliability |
Referencing and methodology
The Quality of written communication, methodology and sourcing section (5 marks) rewards a clear methodology that explains why evidence was selected and considers bias, plus accurate referencing of a wide range of sources. In the exam you cannot copy a bibliography, so learn short references for your key sources, for example (WHO, 2024) or (USGS) in the text, and a short methodology paragraph or table near the start: which sources, why chosen, their limitations.
The January 2025 examiners' report said referencing was often completely absent, so the majority of candidates stayed in Level 2 of this section; the June 2025 report said inconsistent referencing restricted many to 2 or 3 marks out of 5. Both reports said very few candidates evaluated source reliability or the limitations of their sources, so doing it well makes a report stand out. The June 2025 report noted the strongest evaluations were set out clearly in methods tables.
Worked example
A student finds two figures for deaths in the 2023 Turkiye-Syria earthquake: 'over 50,000 in Turkiye and 5,900 in Syria' (UN News, February 2024) and a social media post saying 30,000. How should they use these in a report?
- Prefer the UN figure: an international organisation, dated a year after the event, so counts were more complete.
- Note that the social media post is unattributed and probably an early count.
- Reference the source in the text and add a methodology comment that totals rose as bodies were recovered.
Answer: Use the UN figure (at least 55,900 deaths in total), reference it, and comment on why early and later counts differ.
Check yourself
- Which source is likely to be most reliable for the number of malaria deaths in 2023?
- The WHO World malaria report
- An unattributed revision website
- A travel blog
- A social media post
Show answer
The WHO World malaria report. WHO compiles national data with a stated method, though figures are still estimates.
- Estimates of deaths in the 2010 Haiti earthquake range from 85,000 (US-commissioned draft report) to 316,000 (Haitian government). How many times larger is the higher estimate? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
3.7. 316,000 / 85,000 = 3.7.
- A company that sells GM seed publishes a report saying GM crops end hunger. What is the main concern?
- Possible bias, because the company profits from the conclusion
- The report is too old
- Companies cannot collect data
- It is a primary source
Show answer
Possible bias, because the company profits from the conclusion. Ask who produced it and why.
- The generic mark scheme's top research band asks for
- one detailed case study
- as many diagrams as possible
- only statistics
- a wide range of relevant case studies across scales and locations, with accurate quantitative and qualitative evidence
Show answer
a wide range of relevant case studies across scales and locations, with accurate quantitative and qualitative evidence. Level 3 research (11 to 15 marks).
- In the Quality section, what should a methodology show?
- The candidate's name and centre
- Why evidence was selected and an awareness of possible bias
- How long revision took
- A list of equipment
Show answer
Why evidence was selected and an awareness of possible bias. Top level: clear methodology, rationale for evidence selection, considers bias.
- What did the January 2025 examiners' report criticise about some centres' Option 2 answers?
- Too many sources
- Answers that were too short to mark
- Use of maps
- Near-identical case studies in reports from the same centre
Show answer
Near-identical case studies in reports from the same centre. The report said some reports from the same centres were almost identical in their case studies; independent research gives breadth.
- Explain why quoting a range of estimates for a death toll can improve a Unit 4 report.
Show answer
Different organisations count in different ways and at different times, so giving a range and explaining the uncertainty shows evaluation of source reliability rather than treating one figure as fact.. Uncertainty plus evaluation of reliability.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in Geography specification, Issue 3 (2025)
- Pearson IAL Geography Getting Started Guide (Unit 4 section and command words)
- Pearson WGE04 generic mark scheme (Introduction, Research, Analysis, Conclusion and evaluation, Quality of written communication)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: 2010 Haiti earthquake
- UN News (6 February 2024): One year on, for survivors of Turkiye-Syria quakes the suffering is far from over
- Pearson WGE04/01 examiners' report, January 2025 series (published March 2025)
- Pearson WGE04/01 examiners' report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.