All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
1A.4 Brumaire and the Consulate, 1799
Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
In November 1799 the coup of Brumaire overthrew the Directory and made Napoleon Bonaparte First Consul. The specification covers the lead-up, the events and the nature of the government at the end of 1799.
Sieyes and Napoleon
Sieyes wanted a coup to strengthen the executive by peaceful means. Elected to the Directory, he could dissolve it from inside, and he enlisted Napoleon, increasingly seen as a national hero after the Italian campaign and his return from Egypt.
The coup, 9 to 10 November 1799 (18 to 19 Brumaire)
- The Directors placed the Paris garrison of 8,000 regular troops under Napoleon's command, realising too late that they had lost control.
- Lucien Bonaparte falsely persuaded the councils that a Jacobin coup was under way.
- When the Five Hundred objected, Napoleon's troops cleared the legislative hall.
- Many members of the councils had been bribed or warned in advance; property owners wanted a strong leader.
The Consulate
The Constitution of Year VIII gave effective power to the First Consul, Napoleon. A plebiscite approved it with about 3,000,000 votes; Britannica notes roughly half may have been manufactured.
Did it destroy the Revolution's principles?
For: it ended the separation of powers, Napoleon acted as a dictator, and strong government mattered more than principle. Against: the 1799 constitution kept the 'sacred rights' of property, equality and liberty; Napoleon used plebiscites to show popular support; many personnel and policies continued from the Convention and Directory.
Worked example
About 3,000,000 votes approved the Constitution of Year VIII, but roughly half may have been manufactured. About how many genuine votes might there have been?
- 3,000,000 / 2
Answer: About 1,500,000.
Check yourself
- In which year did the coup of Brumaire take place?
Show answer
1799. 18 to 19 Brumaire, year VIII, was 9 to 10 November 1799.
- How many regular troops were in the Paris garrison placed under Napoleon's command?
Show answer
8000 troops. Pearson's mark scheme gives 8,000 regular troops.
- About 3,000,000 votes approved the 1799 constitution, of which roughly half may have been manufactured. How many votes is half?
Show answer
1500000 votes. 3,000,000 / 2 = 1,500,000.
- What did Sieyes want from the coup?
- The return of the Bourbon king
- A Jacobin republic
- Rule by the sans-culottes
- A stronger executive achieved by peaceful means
Show answer
A stronger executive achieved by peaceful means. Pearson: he wanted to strengthen the executive without disturbing the political balance.
- How did Lucien Bonaparte help the coup succeed?
- He commanded the Austrian army
- He falsely persuaded the councils that a Jacobin coup was under way
- He wrote the Declaration of Rights
- He led the Vendee rebels
Show answer
He falsely persuaded the councils that a Jacobin coup was under way. Lucien's false claim of a Jacobin plot helped the conspirators.
- Under the Constitution of Year VIII, who held effective power?
- The Council of Five Hundred
- The five Directors
- The Paris Commune
- The First Consul
Show answer
The First Consul. The constitution gave effective power to the First Consul.
- Give one argument that the Consulate did NOT destroy the principles of the Revolution.
Show answer
It kept rights such as equality, liberty and property, and used plebiscites to claim popular support.. Pearson: the 1799 constitution kept the sacred rights of property, equality and liberty; Napoleon used plebiscites; personnel continued.
Sources
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: History of France: the French Revolution and Napoleon, 1789 to 1815
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: French Revolution timeline
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1A, June 2016
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1A, January 2018
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1A, January 2020
- Pearson: WHI01 Topic Guide, Option 1A France in Revolution, 1774 to 1799 (Issue 1, January 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.