All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
1B.2 Nicholas II's recovery and the Dumas, 1905 to 14
Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
Nicholas survived 1905 by combining concessions with force. The specification asks about the nature of Tsarist government from 1906 to 14 and the extent of his recovery.
Force
The Moscow Uprising of December 1905 was crushed, showing that force would be used. Pearson's January 2025 mark scheme links survival to repression: the Okhrana, police and army broke up opposition cells.
The Dumas
Dates in this lesson are New Style (the Western calendar), as Britannica gives them.
- First Duma (1906): the Kadets won most votes and the Trudoviki came second; it demanded land redistribution, equal civic rights and an amnesty. It was dissolved on 22 July 1906.
- Second Duma: met on 5 March 1907 (New Style) with extreme left parties holding 118 of 520 seats; dissolved on 16 June 1907 (New Style).
- June 1907: a new electoral law, issued by decree, sharply restricted the franchise and cut non-Russian representation.
- Third (1907) and Fourth (1912) Dumas: Kadets, socialists and non-Russians together held only about a quarter of the seats.
Change or continuity?
Change: freedoms of speech, assembly and association were granted; no law could take effect without Duma approval; the Duma widened participation.
Continuity: the Tsar kept control through the Fundamental Laws, dissolved hostile Dumas and rewrote the electoral law. Pearson's sample paper asks whether the system remained essentially the same in 1903 to 14.
Worked example
In the Second Duma, extreme left parties held 118 of 520 seats. What percentage is that, to 1 decimal place?
- 118 / 520 = 0.2269...
- x 100 = 22.7%
Answer: 22.7%
Check yourself
- In the Second Duma, extreme left parties held 118 of 520 seats. What percentage is that? Give 1 decimal place.
Show answer
22.7 %. 118 / 520 x 100 = 22.7%.
- Which party won the most votes in the First Duma of 1906?
- The Bolsheviks
- The Kadets
- The Octobrists
- The Socialist Revolutionaries
Show answer
The Kadets. Britannica: the Kadets won the most votes and the Trudoviki came second; the Social Democrats largely boycotted.
- In which year did a new electoral law sharply restrict the franchise for the Duma?
Show answer
1907. Issued by decree in June 1907 when the Second Duma was dissolved.
- What happened to the Moscow Uprising of December 1905?
- It was crushed by force
- It forced Nicholas to abdicate
- It created the First Duma
- It led to peace with Japan
Show answer
It was crushed by force. Its crushing showed force would be used.
- Which point best supports the view that Tsarist government stayed essentially the same after 1905?
- Freedom of assembly was granted
- An elected Duma was created
- The Tsar dissolved hostile Dumas and changed the electoral law by decree
- No law could take effect without Duma approval
Show answer
The Tsar dissolved hostile Dumas and changed the electoral law by decree. The other three are changes; dissolving Dumas shows continuity of autocratic power.
- Explain why Tsarist rule recovered after 1905.
Show answer
The October Manifesto and the Duma built support for gradual change, while the army and Okhrana crushed revolutionaries, such as the Moscow Uprising.. Pearson's mark schemes weigh concessions (the October Manifesto, freedoms, the Duma) against repression (the Okhrana, the army, Stolypin).
Sources
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Russian Empire: Revolution of 1905 and the First and Second Dumas
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1B, January 2023 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1B, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson: IAL History sample assessment materials (WHI01 sample paper and mark scheme)
- Pearson: WHI01 Topic Guide, Option 1B Russia in Revolution, 1881 to 1917 (Issue 1, January 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.