All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
1C.1 The collapse of the Second Reich: revolution from above and below, 1918
Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
In autumn 1918 the German Empire (the Second Reich) collapsed. The specification asks why, and how Germany became a democratic republic. Pearson frames the change as a revolution from above followed by a revolution from below.
Revolution from above
After the failure of the Spring Offensive of 1918, the High Command under Ludendorff accepted that a different form of government was needed.
- The liberal Prince Max was appointed Chancellor.
- The Chancellor and Cabinet became answerable to the Reichstag, making Germany a parliamentary government.
- The Kaiser no longer appointed the government, so his political powers were sharply reduced.
- Ludendorff resigned.
Revolution from below
- Naval mutinies at Wilhelmshaven and other ports spread; workers' and soldiers' councils were set up in Rostock and Bremen.
- In Munich a revolt proclaimed a republic in Bavaria.
- The SPD withdrew from Prince Max's government, ending it, and formed its own government, which led to a republic.
- A popular uprising in November 1918 forced the Kaiser to seek refuge in Holland. He abdicated on 9 November and the armistice followed on 11 November.
Which mattered more?
Pearson's January 2025 question asks whether the revolution from above was more significant than the revolution from below. Above: it created parliamentary government before the Kaiser fell. Below: the November revolution was a more radical stage, ending the monarchy itself.
Worked example
Classify each as 'from above' or 'from below': (a) Prince Max appointed Chancellor; (b) naval mutiny at Wilhelmshaven; (c) Cabinet made answerable to the Reichstag; (d) Bavarian republic proclaimed.
- (a) and (c) came from the elite and the High Command: from above.
- (b) and (d) came from sailors, workers and soldiers: from below.
Answer: (a) above, (b) below, (c) above, (d) below.
Check yourself
- Which liberal was appointed Chancellor as part of the 'revolution from above'?
- Friedrich Ebert
- Gustav Stresemann
- Heinrich Bruning
- Prince Max
Show answer
Prince Max. Prince Max became Chancellor as the High Command accepted reform.
- Which change made Germany a parliamentary government in 1918?
- The Kaiser dissolved the Reichstag
- The Chancellor and Cabinet became answerable to the Reichstag
- The army took over government
- Bavaria declared independence
Show answer
The Chancellor and Cabinet became answerable to the Reichstag. Responsibility to the Reichstag is the core of parliamentary government.
- Where did naval mutinies begin the revolution from below?
- Munich and Berlin cinemas
- The Ruhr coal mines
- Alsace-Lorraine
- Wilhelmshaven and other ports
Show answer
Wilhelmshaven and other ports. Pearson cites naval mutinies at Wilhelmshaven and other ports.
- Where did the Kaiser seek refuge in November 1918?
- Holland
- Austria
- Bavaria
- Britain
Show answer
Holland. A popular uprising forced him to seek refuge in Holland.
- The Kaiser abdicated on 9 November 1918 and the armistice was signed on 11 November. How many days apart?
Show answer
2 days. 11 - 9 = 2 days.
- Why can the revolution from below be seen as more significant than the revolution from above?
Show answer
It was more radical: mutinies and councils forced the Kaiser out and ended the monarchy, creating a republic.. Pearson: the November revolution was a more radical stage that ended the monarchy.
Sources
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1C, January 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson: WHI01 Topic Guide, Option 1C Germany, 1918 to 45 (Issue 1, January 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.