All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
1C.1 Versailles, the constitution and the survival of Weimar, 1919 to 23
Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
The starter lesson on 1918 to 23 covers the putsches and hyperinflation. This lesson weighs two other sources of instability, the Treaty of Versailles and the Weimar Constitution, and asks why democracy survived.
The Treaty of Versailles
- Territory: about 20% of coal production and 15% of agricultural resources lost; all colonies became League of Nations mandates; Alsace-Lorraine went to France; land lost to Poland left many Germans outside Germany.
- Reparations: set in 1921 at 6,600 million pounds.
- Military: army cut to 100,000 men; no submarines; no air force; the Rhineland demilitarised.
- Article 231: war guilt placed on Germany.
Politicians who accepted it were labelled the 'November criminals'.
The constitution as a threat
- Proportional representation produced frequent coalition changes: eight different governments in 1919 to 23.
- The relationship between central government and the Lander (states) caused instability.
- Existing elites in the civil service and industry did not accept the Republic.
- Article 48 let the president rule by decree (see the starter lesson).
Other threats and survival
Threats from the left (Spartacists) and right (Kapp and Munich putsches), reparations and hyperinflation, and a wave of political assassinations. Pearson's guide asks why democracy survived and how close it came to collapse. Evidence from the starter lesson: the Kapp Putsch was defeated by a general strike, the Munich Putsch failed, and Stresemann's government introduced the Rentenmark in November 1923.
Worked example
Why did Article 231 damage the Republic as well as Germany?
- It placed war guilt on Germany, damaging its moral and international standing.
- The politicians who accepted the treaty were then blamed as the 'November criminals'.
- So the Republic itself was linked with national humiliation.
Answer: It tied democracy to humiliation and gave its enemies a weapon.
Check yourself
- What was the maximum size of the German army under the Treaty of Versailles?
Show answer
100000 men. The army was reduced to 100,000 men.
- About what percentage of Germany's coal production was lost through territorial changes?
Show answer
20 %. About 20% of coal production.
- In 1921 reparations were set at how many million pounds?
Show answer
6600 million pounds. Reparations were set at 6,600 million pounds.
- What did Article 231 of the Treaty of Versailles do?
- Placed war guilt on Germany
- Gave the president emergency powers
- Created the League of Nations mandates
- Set the size of the navy
Show answer
Placed war guilt on Germany. Article 231 placed war guilt on Germany, damaging its moral and international standing.
- According to Pearson's January 2024 mark scheme, how many different governments did Germany have in 1919 to 23?
Show answer
8 governments. Proportional representation produced eight governments.
- Why is proportional representation linked to instability in Weimar Germany?
- It produced many parties and frequent coalition changes
- It gave the Kaiser a veto
- It banned left-wing parties
- It let only men over 30 vote
Show answer
It produced many parties and frequent coalition changes. PR gave seats to many parties, so coalitions changed often.
- Apart from territory, give one way the Treaty of Versailles damaged the Weimar Republic.
Show answer
Reparations damaged economic recovery, and politicians who signed it were blamed as the November criminals.. Pearson cites reparations, military limits, Article 231 and the Rhineland, plus the 'November criminals' myth.
Sources
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1C, January 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1C, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson: WHI01 Topic Guide, Option 1C Germany, 1918 to 45 (Issue 1, January 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.