All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
1D.1 Why Labour lost the 1970 election
Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations
On 18 June 1970 the Conservatives under Edward Heath won with a majority of 32. Pearson uses the reasons for Labour's defeat as an example of how the same evidence can support different explanations.
The economy
- Labour could not prevent the 1966 sterling crisis and devalued in 1967, fuelling inflation.
- Unemployment reached about 600,000 by 1970.
- The DEA caused confusion and damaged Labour's credibility.
- Heath's campaign attacked Labour's economic failings, such as a 400 million pound trading deficit.
Other factors
- 'In Place of Strife': abandoning legally backed union reform in 1969 alienated moderate voters, while the White Paper itself angered union members.
- Jenkins did not provide a 'give away' budget before the election.
- The 'Powell factor': Enoch Powell's 1968 'rivers of blood' speech on immigration may have won the Conservatives extra working-class votes.
Worked example
Plan an answer to: 'Labour's poor economic record was the main reason for its 1970 defeat.'
- Support: devaluation, unemployment of 600,000, DEA confusion, Heath's attacks on the trade deficit.
- Counter: In Place of Strife, no give-away budget, the Powell factor.
- Judgement: the economy undermined Labour's claim to competence, which the other factors reinforced.
Answer: A judgement that weighs economic failure against union policy and the Powell factor.
Check yourself
- What was the Conservative majority after the general election of June 1970, according to Britannica?
Show answer
32 seats. A majority of 32.
- In which year did Enoch Powell make his 'rivers of blood' speech on immigration?
Show answer
1968. 1968.
- How did 'In Place of Strife' damage Labour in 1970?
- It caused the 1967 devaluation
- It took Britain into the EEC
- Union members saw it as a betrayal, and its abandonment disappointed moderate voters
- It introduced comprehensive schools
Show answer
Union members saw it as a betrayal, and its abandonment disappointed moderate voters. Pearson's mark schemes give both effects.
- What did Chancellor Roy Jenkins NOT do before the 1970 election?
- Turn the deficit into a surplus
- Provide a 'give away' budget
- Raise taxes
- Tighten spending
Show answer
Provide a 'give away' budget. Pearson notes he did not offer a give-away budget, possibly costing Labour support.
- What did Heath's 1970 campaign attack?
- Labour's decision to join the EEC
- Labour's privatisation policy
- Labour's war in the Falklands
- Labour's economic failings, such as the trade deficit
Show answer
Labour's economic failings, such as the trade deficit. Heath targeted the 400 million pound trading deficit.
- What was the 'Powell factor' in the 1970 election?
Show answer
Enoch Powell's 1968 speech on immigration may have won the Conservatives extra working-class votes.. Pearson: the speech won the Conservatives additional (working-class) votes.
Sources
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1D, January 2020
- Pearson mark scheme: WHI01 1D, June 2025 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: United Kingdom: Britain since 1945
- Pearson: WHI01 Topic Guide, Option 1D Britain, 1964 to 90 (Issue 1, January 2018)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.