All subjects · History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations

Planning and writing a WHI01 essay

Edexcel IAL History · WHI01 Depth Study and Interpretations

This lesson turns the skill into a routine you can repeat in the exam: plan quickly, argue throughout, and finish with a judgement that follows from what you have written.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

A ten-minute plan

1. Decode the view: claim, weighting word, dates.

2. List 3 or 4 points that support it, each with precise evidence (names, dates, figures).

3. List 3 or 4 points that counter or modify it.

4. Decide your judgement and the criteria you will use to reach it.

Write the plan as a two-column table: support / counter.

The shape of the essay

Making each paragraph analytical

Point, evidence, explanation, link. The link sentence is where marks are won: *This suggests the Parlement was a serious challenge, but its resistance mattered mainly because the crown was already bankrupt, so finance was the deeper problem.* A paragraph that only tells the story earns AO1 credit but little AO3 credit.

Worked example

Plan this sample question (Pearson SAMs, 1A): 'The taxation system was the most significant cause of discontent in France in the years 1774 to 89.'

  1. Support (from the January 2018 mark scheme on a similar question): the system was complex and damaged the economy; collection was inefficient, with regional inequalities and corruption; the unfair taille led peasants to defraud and cut production; indirect taxes hit the rural and urban poor.
  2. Counter: the costly War of American Independence; failed reforms by Turgot, Necker and Calonne; bad harvests in the 1780s raising prices; backward agriculture and population growth; Enlightenment ideas; resentment of the court.
  3. Criteria: which problem affected most people, and which made the others worse?
  4. Possible judgement: the tax system mattered because it blocked any solution to the debt, but bad harvests and the cost of war turned discontent into crisis.

Answer: A two-column plan with precise evidence and a judgement stated in the introduction and justified in the conclusion.

Key idea: Plan: decode, support, counter, criteria. Write: answer in the introduction, analytical paragraphs that link back to the view, conclusion that applies criteria to the weighting word.

Check yourself

  1. What should a WHI01 introduction do?
    • Give a clear answer to the view and say how it will be judged
    • Tell the story of the period in order
    • List every historian who wrote about it
    • Leave the judgement as a surprise for the end
    Show answer

    Give a clear answer to the view and say how it will be judged. Answering straight away keeps the essay focused on the view.

  2. Which sentence is most analytical?
    • In 1778 France joined the war against Britain.
    • There were many causes of discontent.
    • This shows the war mattered, but mainly because it deepened the debt that the tax system could not cover.
    • The war was in America.
    Show answer

    This shows the war mattered, but mainly because it deepened the debt that the tax system could not cover.. It links evidence to the view and weighs one factor against another.

  3. How long should planning take for each WHI01 essay?
    • About 10 minutes
    • About 30 minutes
    • No time at all
    • About 1 minute
    Show answer

    About 10 minutes. With 60 minutes per essay, about 10 minutes planning leaves 50 for writing.

  4. What is a 'countering or modifying' point?
    • A repeat of the stated view in different words
    • A point about a different period
    • A historian's name
    • Evidence for another factor or a limit to the stated view
    Show answer

    Evidence for another factor or a limit to the stated view. Mark schemes list points that counter or modify the view alongside points that support it.

  5. A conclusion introduces a brand new factor that the essay never discussed. Why is this weak?
    • Conclusions must be one sentence
    • The judgement no longer follows from the argument
    • New factors are banned by Pearson
    • It makes the essay too short
    Show answer

    The judgement no longer follows from the argument. A supported judgement must come from the evidence and criteria already argued.

  6. What should the last sentence of each main paragraph do?
    Show answer

    Link the point back to the stated view, saying how far it supports or challenges it.. The link sentence turns description into analysis by judging the point against the view.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.