All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
2B China: the fall of the Qing, 1900 to 12
Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
In 1900 China was an empire ruled by the Manchu Qing dynasty. By 1912 it was a republic. This lesson explains why late Qing reforms failed to save the dynasty.
Reformers and conservatives
Late Qing politics set reformers, who looked to the imprisoned Guangxu Emperor, against conservatives around the Empress Dowager Cixi. After the Boxer disaster (key topic 2), the court tried reform from above:
- 1905: the traditional civil service examinations were abolished.
- September 1906: the court decided to adopt a constitution; in November the six traditional boards became 11 ministries.
- August 1908: an outline constitution with a nine-year period of preparation.
- Provincial assemblies first met in October 1909, but only about 0.4% of the population could vote (Pearson June 2024 mark scheme).
- New armies were created, but they were loyal to their generals, such as Yuan Shikai, rather than to the Qing.
A weakened court
Cixi and the emperor died within days of each other in late 1908, about three months after the outline constitution. The new emperor, Puyi, was two years old; his regent, Prince Chun, defended the status quo, and the 1910 to 11 cabinet was dominated by imperial relatives and Manchu nobles (Pearson specimen mark scheme).
Revolution
- Sun Yat-sen, in exile, helped found the Tongmenghui (United League) in Japan in 1905; his Three Principles of the People had taken shape by 1903. By about 1906 some 8,000 Chinese students were in Japan.
- May 1911: the court nationalised provincial railways and signed a loan with a four-power banking consortium, enraging provincial elites.
- 10 October 1911: troops occupied Wuchang; the revolt spread. Yuan Shikai switched to the rebels, and the Qing fell in 1912. Sun lost the power struggle that followed to Yuan.
Worked example
Was reluctance to accept political reform the main cause of the 1911 to 12 revolution? (Pearson specimen paper)
- Yes: reforms delayed by nine years; a Manchu-dominated cabinet; Prince Chun's conservatism.
- Other causes: nationalism over foreign railway control; tax rises to pay for reform; Sun's ideas; assemblies that raised expectations; new armies loyal to generals such as Yuan.
Answer: A judgement might argue that reluctance mattered because the half-reforms raised expectations they then failed to meet.
Check yourself
- In which year did the Wuchang rising begin the revolution that ended Qing rule?
Show answer
1911. 10 October 1911.
- In which year were the traditional civil service examinations abolished?
Show answer
1905. Pearson's June 2024 mark scheme dates this reform to 1905.
- How many years of preparation did the Qing outline constitution of 1908 set before a constitution would take effect?
Show answer
9 years. A nine-year period of tutelage.
- Why were the new armies a danger to the Qing?
- They were commanded by foreign officers
- They were disbanded in 1905
- They supported the Boxers
- They were loyal to their generals, such as Yuan Shikai, rather than to the dynasty
Show answer
They were loyal to their generals, such as Yuan Shikai, rather than to the dynasty. Regional armies followed their commanders.
- What provoked anger among provincial elites in May 1911?
- The abolition of the examinations
- The court nationalised provincial railways and took a foreign loan
- The death of Cixi
- The Boxer Protocol
Show answer
The court nationalised provincial railways and took a foreign loan. Nationalising railway companies and borrowing from foreign banks caused outrage.
- What organisation did Sun Yat-sen help to found in Japan in 1905?
- The Chinese Communist Party
- The Guomindang army at Whampoa
- The Boxers
- The Tongmenghui (United League)
Show answer
The Tongmenghui (United League). The United League was founded in 1905.
- Why did the late Qing reforms fail to save the dynasty?
Show answer
They were too slow and limited, with a nine-year delay and few voters, so they raised expectations without satisfying them.. Half-reforms raised hopes but kept power with the court and Manchus.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 2 (WHI02) Option 1B: China, 1900 to 76 (Issue 1, April 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: China, Reformist and revolutionist movements at the end of the dynasty
- Wikipedia: Provincial assemblies (Qing dynasty)
- Pearson WHI02/1B mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1B mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WHI02/1B mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.