All subjects · History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
2D South Africa: health, AIDS and crime
Edexcel IAL History · WHI02 Breadth Study with Source Evaluation
Key topic 3 also asks about differences in healthcare between communities, attempts to improve healthcare after 1994, the significance of AIDS and crime across all groups.
Health under apartheid
Healthcare was unequal: whites had excellent hospitals and services, while Black South Africans had limited access to good-quality healthcare and health insurance (Pearson June 2016 and June 2025 mark schemes).
Healthcare after 1994
The impact of attempts to improve healthcare in the 1990s is a nominated area. In 1994 the government extended free basic healthcare to pregnant women and children under six, and in 1996 free primary healthcare to all who needed it; 701 clinics were built or upgraded in the following decade. But hospitals stayed overstretched, staffing was poorly managed and drug supplies were erratic (Health-e News, 2004).
AIDS
- By 1999 about 3.6 million people were HIV-positive, with about half a million new cases a year; about half a million people died of AIDS-related illness in 2007, and life expectancy fell (Pearson topic guide). Pearson's specimen mark scheme gives life expectancy falling from 62 to 56 years and adult HIV prevalence rising from 2% to 18% between 1994 and 2014.
- Mandela was preoccupied with dismantling apartheid. Mbeki denied the link between HIV and AIDS and called the focus on AIDS a form of racism; he believed drug companies were exploiting South Africa, and antiretroviral drugs (ARVs) were not distributed. Zuma acknowledged the link and appointed a health minister who focused on mother-to-child transmission.
- Other factors: migrant mine workers far from home, cultural resistance to condoms and some use of traditional medicine instead of ARVs (Pearson June 2016 mark scheme).
Crime
Pearson's specification asks you to consider crime across all groups both under apartheid and after it. After 1994 crime remained high by international standards, and in 2012 police violence at Marikana killed more than 34 striking miners (Britannica). Use crime as evidence of continuing inequality and of the state's struggle to provide security.
Worked example
How far can the spread of AIDS in 1990 to 2014 be explained by the weakness of the government's response? (Pearson June 2016 paper)
- Government: Mandela's other priorities; Mbeki's denial and refusal to distribute ARVs.
- Other factors: poor access to healthcare; migrant labour and mining; cultural attitudes; traditional medicine; Zuma partly reversed the policy.
Answer: A judgement might argue Mbeki's response made a terrible situation much worse, but social and economic factors drove the spread.
Check yourself
- About how many million South Africans were HIV-positive in 1999, according to Pearson's topic guide? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
3.6 million. About 3.6 million.
- Pearson's specimen mark scheme says life expectancy fell from 62 to 56 years in 1994 to 2014. By how many years did it fall?
Show answer
6 years. 62 - 56 = 6 years.
- What did Mbeki's government decide about antiretroviral drugs (ARVs)?
- To make them free for everyone in 1994
- To import them from China
- Not to distribute them to HIV sufferers
- To ban traditional medicine in favour of them
Show answer
Not to distribute them to HIV sufferers. This followed his doubts about drug companies and the science.
- How did Zuma's AIDS policy differ from Mbeki's?
- He denied that AIDS existed
- He acknowledged the link between HIV and AIDS
- He closed all clinics
- He blamed sanctions
Show answer
He acknowledged the link between HIV and AIDS. He also targeted mother-to-child transmission.
- Which factor, other than government policy, helped AIDS spread?
- The Freedom Charter
- The end of the pass laws
- Sports boycotts
- Migrant mine workers living far from home
Show answer
Migrant mine workers living far from home. Pearson's mark scheme names mining and migrant labour.
- Adult HIV prevalence rose from 2% to 18%. How many times higher was it?
Show answer
9. 18 / 2 = 9 times.
- Why did healthcare differ between communities under apartheid?
Show answer
Whites had well-funded hospitals while Black South Africans had little access to good healthcare or insurance because spending was unequal.. Spending and access favoured whites.
- In which year was free primary healthcare extended to all South Africans who needed it?
Show answer
1996. 1996, two years after free care for pregnant women and children under six (1994).
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 2 (WHI02) Option 1D: South Africa, 1948 to 2014 (Issue 1, April 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: South Africa, Postapartheid South Africa
- Pearson WHI02/1D mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI02/1D mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI02/1D mark scheme, June 2016
- Health-e News: A decade of health, some reflections
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.