All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3A USA: a more perfect union, the Constitutional Convention, 1786 to 87
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Key topic 2 runs from 1786 to 1791. This lesson explains why the Articles of Confederation were replaced and how the Constitutional Convention of 1787 reached its compromises.
Problems under the Articles
- Economic troubles and a demand for a stronger central government lay behind the Convention, which met ostensibly to amend the Articles of Confederation (Britannica).
- Debts, funding and trade divided the states: Massachusetts and Rhode Island repeatedly disagreed over printing paper money (Pearson June 2023 mark scheme).
- Shays' Rebellion (1786) raised the issues of taxation and debt. Alexander Hamilton saw it as a warning of the 'tyranny of the majority' and the dangers of democracy (Topic Guide).
The Convention, 1787
- Met from 25 May to 17 September 1787 in the Pennsylvania State House, Philadelphia. Of 74 delegates chosen, 55 took part and 39 signed. George Washington presided; James Madison was among the leading delegates (Britannica).
- Virginia Plan (Edmund Randolph): a two-chamber legislature with representation based on population or wealth, the large-state plan.
- New Jersey Plan (William Paterson): equal representation for each state.
- Connecticut (Great) Compromise (Oliver Ellsworth and Roger Sherman), approved 16 July: representation by population in the lower house, equal representation of the states in the upper house, with revenue measures starting in the lower house (Britannica).
Slavery and suspicion of democracy
- Three-fifths compromise: three-fifths of enslaved people were counted for representation, and also for taxes (Britannica). The southern states held about 700,000 enslaved people in 1787 (Pearson specimen mark scheme).
- Importation of slaves could not be forbidden before 1808 (Britannica). The Topic Guide calls these North-South deals 'fudged compromises'.
- In the same year the Northwest Ordinance of 1787 banned slavery in the territory north of the Ohio River (Britannica).
- The Topic Guide also asks you to know the separation of powers and the clauses that reflected suspicion of democracy.
Worked example
What share of the delegates who took part in the Convention signed the Constitution, and what does it suggest?
- 39 / 55 x 100 = 70.9%.
- So nearly three in ten participants did not sign.
Answer: About 71% signed: a clear majority, but the gap shows that the compromises left real disagreement, which carried into the ratification battle.
Check yourself
- In which year did the Constitutional Convention meet in Philadelphia?
Show answer
1787. 25 May to 17 September 1787.
- What did the Connecticut (Great) Compromise decide?
- Equal representation for every state in one chamber
- Representation by population in the lower house and equal state representation in the upper house
- Representation by wealth in a single chamber
- That the President would be chosen by Congress
Show answer
Representation by population in the lower house and equal state representation in the upper house. It balanced the Virginia and New Jersey plans.
- What did the three-fifths compromise do?
- Abolished slavery in three-fifths of the states
- Gave three-fifths of seats to the South
- Required three-fifths of states to ratify
- Counted three-fifths of the enslaved population for representation and taxes
Show answer
Counted three-fifths of the enslaved population for representation and taxes. It settled how enslaved people were counted.
- Of 55 delegates who took part, 39 signed the Constitution. What percentage signed? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Show answer
70.9 %. 39/55 x 100 = 70.9%.
- Which issues did Shays' Rebellion (1786) raise?
- The slave trade
- War with France
- Taxation and debt
- Votes for women
Show answer
Taxation and debt. The Topic Guide links it to taxation and debt.
- Until which year did the Constitution protect the import of slaves from being banned?
- 1808
- 1791
- 1820
- 1863
Show answer
1808. Importation could not be forbidden before 1808.
- Who proposed the Virginia Plan?
- William Paterson
- Roger Sherman
- Edmund Randolph
- Alexander Hamilton
Show answer
Edmund Randolph. Randolph's plan based representation on population or wealth; Paterson proposed the New Jersey Plan.
- Why did the Convention need a compromise between big and small states?
Show answer
Big states like Virginia wanted representation by population while small states like New Jersey wanted equal representation, so a compromise was needed to keep every state in the union.. Representation divided big and small states.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3A: The USA, Independence to Civil War, 1763 to 1865 (Issue 1, January 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Constitutional Convention
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Northwest Ordinances (summary)
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WHI03/1A mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.