All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3C Germany: linking the themes, 1870 to 1990
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Section B essays on 3C compare Germany's five key periods through the themes. This lesson gathers the evidence by theme and shows how Pearson's questions link the key topics.
The five themes across the key topics
| Theme | Evidence across the key topics |
|---|---|
| 1 Neighbours | War with France 1870 and War in Sight 1875; defeat 1918, Versailles, Ruhr 1923; 1931 banking crisis, rearmament, Rhineland, Anschluss; Western allies, ECSC, NATO; Gorbachev, Four Powers |
| 2 Economic pressures | Zollverein; war shortages and hyperinflation; Depression; economic miracle; East-West prosperity gap |
| 3 Authority and leadership | Bismarck; Hindenburg, Ludendorff, Ebert; Hitler; Adenauer and Erhard; Honecker and Kohl |
| 4 Protest, dissent and workers | Kulturkampf, Anti-Socialist Law; strikes, Spartacists, Kapp Putsch general strike; KPD, Gestapo; unions co-operating, 1953 rising; Stasi, churches, Leipzig |
| 5 Ideologies and parties | National Liberals, Centre, SPD; SPD, USPD, KPD; Nazis and other parties' complicity; CDU and SPD; SED monopoly |
Built from Pearson's 3C Topic Guide.
Essays Pearson has set
- 'War created the Second Reich and war destroyed it.' (specimen)
- How different was the FRG constitution from Weimar's? (specimen)
- Did Germany in 1917 to 24 largely face different problems from 1870 to 79? (June 2023)
- Was there only limited opposition to the FRG (1949 to 60) and the GDR? (June 2023)
- Was the Weimar Constitution the most important factor in the Nazis achieving power in 1933? (January 2024)
- Was political repression more effective in Nazi Germany than in the GDR? (January 2024)
- Did Communist opposition seriously threaten governments in 1919 to 24 and 1930 to 39? (January 2025)
- How significant were Ebert (1918 to 24) and Adenauer (1949 to 60) in forming democratic states? (January 2025)
Making links
Compare like with like: Ebert's Freikorps with Hitler's Gestapo as answers to the Communist threat; Weimar's Article 48 with the FRG's ceremonial President; the Gestapo with the Stasi (over 100,000 staff). Then choose a criterion (threat to the state, scale, outcome) and say why it matters most.
Worked example
Plan: how different was the constitution of the FRG from that of the Weimar Republic? (specimen)
- Differences: Weimar's directly elected President with Article 48 powers against the FRG's ceremonial President; pure PR against a modified system; Chancellor appointed by the President against elected by the Bundestag; Prussian dominance against balanced Länder.
- Similarities: both republics; both federal with strong Länder; both two-chamber with a states' chamber holding a veto (Reichsrat, Bundesrat); democratic franchise including women; a Chancellor depending on parliament.
Answer: A judgement might argue the framework was similar but the changes targeted exactly the weaknesses that helped destroy Weimar, so the differences mattered more.
Check yourself
- Which theme does the French occupation of the Ruhr in 1923 illustrate?
- Ideologies and political parties
- Authority and leadership
- Relations with and influence of Germany's neighbours
- Protest and workers' organisations
Show answer
Relations with and influence of Germany's neighbours. France is a neighbour: theme 1.
- Which theme does the June 1953 rising in the GDR illustrate?
- Protest, dissent and workers' organisations
- Economic pressures only
- Relations with neighbours only
- Ideologies of the FRG
Show answer
Protest, dissent and workers' organisations. A rising against the state is theme 4.
- Which is a similarity between the Weimar and FRG constitutions?
- A directly elected President with emergency powers
- Pure proportional representation
- A second chamber representing the states with veto powers
- A Chancellor appointed by the President
Show answer
A second chamber representing the states with veto powers. Reichsrat and Bundesrat.
- Which evidence suggests GDR repression was in some ways more extensive than Nazi repression?
- The GDR needed Soviet help to crush the 1953 rising
- The Stasi grew to over 100,000 full-time staff, far larger than the Gestapo
- Protest groups met in the GDR in the 1980s
- Mass protests in 1989 could not be stopped
Show answer
The Stasi grew to over 100,000 full-time staff, far larger than the Gestapo. Pearson's January 2024 mark scheme makes this point.
- Which point weighs against Ebert's significance in forming a democratic state?
- He was the first President of the Republic
- He supported a democratic constitution
- He made the Groener pact to restore stability
- He relied on the Freikorps and did not reform the military leadership
Show answer
He relied on the Freikorps and did not reform the military leadership. Reliance on the Freikorps set a dangerous precedent.
- Use one piece of evidence to support 'War created the Second Reich and war destroyed it'.
Show answer
The Empire was proclaimed at Versailles in 1871 after victory over France, and defeat in 1918 led to the Kaiser's abdication.. Victory in 1870 to 71 created it; defeat and war strain in 1918 destroyed it.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3C: Germany, 1870 to 1990, united, divided and reunited (Issue 1, January 2018)
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, January 2024
- Pearson WHI03/1C examiners' report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.