All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3C Germany: defeat, revolution and the Weimar Constitution, 1917 to 19
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Key topic 2 runs from 1917 to 1924. This lesson covers the strains of 1917, the collapse of the military dictatorship, the revolutions of 1918 and the Weimar Constitution of 1919.
Collapse, 1917 to 18
- In 1917 a mounting death toll at the front and shortages at home broke the consensus for war: Erzberger's Peace Resolution, strikes, and the Independent Socialists, forerunners of the Communists, who posed a threat of revolution (Topic Guide).
- Hindenburg and Ludendorff ran a military dictatorship whose authority rested on victory; it collapsed when military success deserted them in 1918 as the British, French and Americans inflicted defeat (Topic Guide).
Revolution, 1918 to 19
- Revolution from above in autumn 1918 under Prince Max of Baden, then revolution from below in November and December 1918 (Topic Guide).
- Wilhelm II abdicated on 9 November 1918, and the same day Philipp Scheidemann proclaimed a republic from the Reichstag balcony; the Kaiser left for Holland. German officials then met the Allied generals at Rethondes to sign the armistice (Britannica; Topic Guide).
- SPD leaders Ebert and Scheidemann sought a peaceful move to parliamentary democracy; Rosa Luxemburg wanted a radical social revolution. Ebert used the Freikorps against the Spartacist Rising (1919) and made the Groener pact with the army (Topic Guide; Pearson January 2025 mark scheme).
The Weimar Constitution, 1919
- The National Assembly was elected on 19 January 1919, the first German election in which women could vote; it elected Ebert President on 11 February, and the constitution was promulgated on 11 August 1919. The Treaty of Versailles was signed on 28 June 1919 (Britannica).
- A directly elected President with wide powers under Article 48; the President appointed the Chancellor; a purely proportional voting system; a Reichsrat representing the Länder, which could veto legislation, with Prussia dominant (Pearson specimen mark scheme).
- Analyse strengths (democratic rights for men and women, a federal balance) and weaknesses (Article 48, many small parties) (Topic Guide).
Worked example
Plan a judgement: was the Weimar Constitution more a strength or a weakness for the new republic?
- Strengths: a democratic franchise including women from January 1919; a Chancellor depending on the Reichstag; the Länder represented in the Reichsrat.
- Weaknesses: Article 48 gave a directly elected President wide emergency powers; pure proportional representation encouraged many small parties and unstable coalitions.
- Criterion: which features most affected the republic's survival in a crisis?
Answer: A judgement might argue that the constitution was democratic in principle but its emergency powers and electoral system were dangerous in crisis, which is why the FRG's Basic Law changed exactly these features.
Check yourself
- What did Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution allow?
- The Kaiser to return
- The Länder to leave the Republic
- The President to use emergency powers
- The army to choose the Chancellor
Show answer
The President to use emergency powers. Article 48 gave the President wide emergency powers.
- Who led the 'revolution from above' in autumn 1918?
- Prince Max of Baden
- Friedrich Ebert
- Rosa Luxemburg
- Wolfgang Kapp
Show answer
Prince Max of Baden. Prince Max's government began reform from above.
- In which year did Wilhelm II abdicate?
Show answer
1918. 9 November 1918.
- Which voting system did the Weimar Constitution use?
- First past the post
- Pure proportional representation
- A modified proportional system
- Indirect election by the Länder
Show answer
Pure proportional representation. The FRG later used a modified system instead.
- What was new about the National Assembly election of 19 January 1919?
- Only the SPD could stand
- The Kaiser chose the candidates
- It was held in Holland
- Women could vote for the first time in a German election
Show answer
Women could vote for the first time in a German election. Britannica: the first German election in which women could vote.
- Who wanted a radical social revolution in 1918 to 19?
- Friedrich Ebert
- Rosa Luxemburg
- Prince Max of Baden
- Philipp Scheidemann
Show answer
Rosa Luxemburg. Ebert and Scheidemann wanted a peaceful parliamentary democracy.
- In which year was the Treaty of Versailles signed?
Show answer
1919. 28 June 1919.
- Why did the military dictatorship of Hindenburg and Ludendorff collapse in 1918?
Show answer
Its authority rested on victory, so when the 1918 offensives failed against the British, French and Americans it lost support.. Its authority depended on winning, and it lost.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3C: Germany, 1870 to 1990, united, divided and reunited (Issue 1, January 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Weimar Republic
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1C mark scheme, January 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.