All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3D Civil rights: the triumph of 'Jim Crow', the Court and segregation, 1883 to c1900
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Key topic 2 explains how many Reconstruction gains were rolled back. This lesson covers the Supreme Court rulings of 1883 to 1899, which the Topic Guide asks you to distinguish, and how segregation spread across the South.
The Supreme Court opens the way
- Civil Rights Cases (1883): the Court overturned key elements of the Civil Rights Act of 1875 (Britannica), declaring it partly unconstitutional by an 8 to 1 majority (Pearson June 2025 mark scheme), which opened the way to segregation (Topic Guide).
- Louisville, New Orleans and Texas Railway v Mississippi (1890) upheld a Mississippi law requiring segregation on trains within the state (Britannica).
- Plessy v Ferguson (1896) upheld Louisiana's Separate Car Act of July 1890 and embraced 'separate but equal', enabling legal segregation (Britannica; Pearson January 2025 mark scheme).
1898 and 1899: votes and schools
- Williams v Mississippi (1898), 170 U.S. 213: a unanimous Court, in an opinion by Justice Joseph McKenna, upheld Mississippi's 1890 voting rules, a poll tax and a test of whether an applicant could understand or interpret the state constitution, because they did not discriminate by race on their face, even though officials could use them to do so (Encyclopedia.com). It left in place the changes that disenfranchised large numbers of black voters (Pearson January 2025 mark scheme). The Topic Guide calls this case 'Mississippi versus Wilkinson'; the case name is Williams v Mississippi.
- Cumming v Board of Education (1899): the Court ruled 9 to 0 that a Georgia county board violated no constitutional rights when it closed Ware High School, which served black students, and turned it into elementary schools (Britannica).
Segregation spreads
- Florida changed rail travel in 1887 (Topic Guide); Mississippi introduced segregated rail travel in 1888, followed by Louisiana in 1890 (Pearson specimen mark scheme); from 1887 to 1892 nine states passed laws requiring separation on public conveyances (Britannica).
- States, not the Supreme Court, initiated segregation and the Jim Crow laws; the Court made them legally possible (Pearson specimen mark scheme). Pressure groups pushed for segregation, which extended to other social areas and other states (Topic Guide).
- Intimidation was concentrated in the South: 82% of US lynchings in the 1890s were in the southern states (Pearson specimen mark scheme).
Worked example
Pearson's June 2025 report criticised answers that lumped Supreme Court decisions together. Distinguish what each ruling did.
- 1883: struck down key parts of the Civil Rights Act of 1875 (8 to 1).
- 1896, Plessy: upheld segregated railway cars under 'separate but equal'.
- 1898, Williams: let Mississippi's poll tax and understanding test stand because they were neutral on their face.
- 1899, Cumming: let a county close a black high school.
Answer: Each ruling removed a different protection: federal civil rights law (1883), equal treatment in public facilities (1896), the vote (1898) and education (1899). Naming the differences is what lifts an essay above lumping them together.
Check yourself
- In which year was Plessy v Ferguson decided?
Show answer
1896. 1896.
- What did the Supreme Court do in the Civil Rights Cases of 1883?
- Struck down key parts of the Civil Rights Act of 1875
- Upheld the Civil Rights Act of 1875 in full
- Ended segregation in schools
- Gave black women the vote
Show answer
Struck down key parts of the Civil Rights Act of 1875. The 8 to 1 ruling opened the way to segregation.
- In which year was Williams v Mississippi decided?
Show answer
1898. 1898, 170 U.S. 213.
- Why did the Court uphold Mississippi's voting rules in Williams v Mississippi?
- They applied only to white voters
- They did not discriminate by race on their face
- Congress had approved them
- Mississippi had already abolished them
Show answer
They did not discriminate by race on their face. Encyclopedia.com: the rules were neutral on their face, though officials could use them to discriminate.
- From 1887 to 1892, how many states passed laws requiring separation on public conveyances, according to Britannica?
Show answer
9 states. Nine states, including Louisiana.
- Pearson's specimen mark scheme says what percentage of US lynchings in the 1890s took place in the southern states?
Show answer
82 %. 82%.
- What did the Court allow in Cumming v Board of Education (1899)?
- Integrated schools in Georgia
- Black citizens to sit on juries
- Segregated railway cars
- A county board to close a high school serving black students
Show answer
A county board to close a high school serving black students. Britannica: 9 to 0, no constitutional rights violated.
- How did Supreme Court rulings help Jim Crow spread after 1883?
Show answer
By striking down parts of the 1875 Civil Rights Act and upholding 'separate but equal' in Plessy, the Court made segregation laws legal.. The Court removed federal protection and accepted 'separate but equal'.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3D: Civil Rights and Race Relations in the USA, 1865 to 2009 (Issue 1, January 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Jim Crow law
- Encyclopedia.com: Williams v. Mississippi, 170 U.S. 213 (1898)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Cumming v. Board of Education of Richmond County
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D examiners' report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.