All subjects · History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
3D Civil rights: linking the themes, 1865 to 2009
Edexcel IAL History · WHI03 Thematic Study with Source Evaluation
Section B essays on 3D trace race relations across key topics up to a century apart. This lesson gathers the evidence by theme and shows how Pearson's questions link the key topics.
The five themes across the key topics
| Theme | Evidence across the key topics |
|---|---|
| 1 Congress, presidency and Supreme Court | Johnson and the amendments; the 1883, 1896 and 1898 rulings; FDR's caution and EO 8802; Brown, Warren and LBJ's laws; Obama's election |
| 2 Campaigners | Radical Republicans and black officeholders; Booker T. Washington, Du Bois; NAACP and Randolph; King, SCLC, SNCC, CORE, black power; voters and politicians after 2000 |
| 3 Resisting forces | KKK and White League; Jim Crow states; southern Democrats blocking anti-lynching bills; Faubus, Connor, white backlash; continuing policing tensions |
| 4 Economic and educational opportunity | Sharecropping and schools; vocational education and unequal schools; WPA and war work; Brown and the 1964 Act; black middle class and persistent poverty |
| 5 Settlement and housing | Freedom of movement; over 90% still in the old Confederacy by 1900; wartime migration north and west; ghettos and the Fair Housing Act; return South and suburbanisation |
Built from Pearson's 3D Topic Guide.
Essays Pearson has set
- How far were the gains of 1865 to 77 lost in 1883 to 1900? (specimen)
- Was the Supreme Court highly significant in limiting rights in 1883 to 1900 and extending them in 1954 to 68? (specimen)
- Was the Montgomery bus boycott the most important influence on the movement in 1954 to 2009? (June 2021)
- Were the problems of 1883 to 1900 seriously addressed under Roosevelt? (June 2022)
- Did Andrew Johnson only damage, and Roosevelt only increase, black opportunities? (June 2023)
- Was Lyndon Johnson much more successful than Roosevelt? (January 2024)
- Were changing patterns of settlement and housing the biggest influence on black lives in 1933 to 2009? (January 2025)
- Did the status of black Americans change little in 1933 to 45 and 2000 to 09? (June 2025)
Making links
Compare like with like: the Court's 1883 and 1896 rulings with Brown in 1954; Roosevelt's caution with Johnson's laws; the 1890s exclusion of voters with the Voting Rights Act. Distinguish between rulings rather than lumping them together, and decide which criterion (legal rights, daily life, numbers affected) matters most.
Worked example
Plan: was Lyndon Johnson (1963 to 68) much more successful than Franklin Roosevelt (1933 to 45) in addressing the problems of black Americans? (January 2024)
- For Johnson: the Civil Rights Act 1964 ended legal segregation; the Voting Rights Act 1965 outlawed literacy tests, while Roosevelt did nothing on voter suppression; the Fair Housing Act 1968; Thurgood Marshall's appointment; Roosevelt failed on lynching and Jim Crow.
- For Roosevelt: the WPA employed 1 million black Americans by 1939; the FEPC (1941); the 1936 shift of black voters to the Democrats; Bethune's 'black cabinet'. Against Johnson: 239 outbreaks of racial violence in 1964 to 68.
Answer: A judgement might argue Johnson was far more successful on legal rights, while Roosevelt's economic help mattered more to daily life in the 1930s.
Check yourself
- Which theme does wartime migration to the North and West best illustrate?
- The role of the Supreme Court
- The forces resisting civil rights
- Pressure groups and individuals
- The changing pattern of settlement and housing
Show answer
The changing pattern of settlement and housing. Migration is theme 5.
- Which theme do southern Democrats filibustering anti-lynching bills illustrate?
- Changing economic opportunity
- The forces resisting enhanced civil rights
- Settlement and housing
- Pressure groups campaigning for rights
Show answer
The forces resisting enhanced civil rights. Blocking reform is resistance: theme 3.
- Which point modifies the claim that the Supreme Court was the most significant obstacle in 1883 to 1900?
- Plessy v Ferguson upheld 'separate but equal'
- The 1883 rulings struck down the Civil Rights Act of 1875
- Williams v Mississippi upheld voting restrictions
- The Court enabled segregation, but southern states made the Jim Crow laws
Show answer
The Court enabled segregation, but southern states made the Jim Crow laws. Pearson's mark schemes stress that states, not the Court, instigated segregation.
- Pearson's June 2025 report criticised answers that
- lumped different Supreme Court decisions together
- used dates from the right period
- linked key topics
- reached a sustained judgement
Show answer
lumped different Supreme Court decisions together. Distinguish the rulings.
- Which evidence supports the view that the status of black Americans changed little in 2000 to 09?
- Obama's election in 2008
- Growth of a black middle class
- Persistently high black poverty and riots after police shootings
- Black suburbanisation
Show answer
Persistently high black poverty and riots after police shootings. Continuity evidence from Pearson's June 2025 mark scheme.
- Give one way the gains of 1865 to 77 were lost by 1900.
Show answer
Black voters were removed by poll taxes and literacy tests, and segregation was made legal after Plessy v Ferguson.. Voting rights and equal treatment were stripped away.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 3 (WHI03) Option 3D: Civil Rights and Race Relations in the USA, 1865 to 2009 (Issue 1, January 2018)
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2021
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2022
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, January 2024
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D examiners' report, June 2025
- Pearson WHI03/1D examiners' report, January 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.