All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
4A Napoleon's downfall: the Spanish ulcer and the Russian campaign
Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
Two land wars drained the Empire: the 'Spanish ulcer' in the Iberian Peninsula (1808 to 14) and the invasion of Russia (1812). Both are central to the debate about where the downfall really began.
The Peninsular War, 1808 to 14
- In 1808 Napoleon enforced the Continental System on Portugal, then turned on his Spanish ally and put his brother Joseph on the Spanish throne (June 2024 mark scheme).
- He misjudged Spanish reaction: a guerrilla war caused heavy casualties and questioned French strength. He left much of the fighting to subordinates and tried to command from a distance.
- Wellington won in Iberia between 1808 and 1813, diverting French troops; Pearson's specimen mark scheme says the campaign tied down 200,000 French troops when they were needed in central Europe, and Wellington's victory at Vitoria (1813) helped persuade others to fight on. Napoleon himself traced his disasters back to Spain.
Russia, 1812
- The Franco-Russian alliance made at Tilsit (1807) was always temporary; Tsar Alexander I stopped enforcing the Continental System after 1810.
- Invading while still at war in Spain caused overstretch. Napoleon overstretched supply lines, underestimated logistics and chose to take Moscow; Russian tactics and geography forced a catastrophic retreat.
- The loss of horses crippled his cavalry: Pearson's January 2025 mark scheme gives 100,000 horses dead in Russia. The defeat broke the myth of his invincibility and Russia carried the war into central Europe.
Weighing the two
Pearson's mark schemes have set both as the 'main' cause. For Spain: it was Napoleon's own blunder, it drained men and prestige for six years, and it opened a southern front. For Russia: it destroyed the Grand Army, led Prussia to switch sides and created the Sixth Coalition. A strong answer links them: the war on two fronts in 1812 was the real overstretch.
Worked example
Pearson's specimen mark scheme says Spain tied down 200,000 French troops; the January 2025 scheme says 100,000 horses died in Russia. Why do these two figures help the 'overstretch' argument?
- 200,000 men in Spain could not fight in central Europe in 1812 to 13.
- Losing 100,000 horses meant Napoleon could not rebuild his cavalry for 1813 to 14, even when he raised new men.
Answer: Together they show that fighting on two fronts drained both manpower and the cavalry that Napoleon's way of war depended on.
Check yourself
- Whom did Napoleon place on the Spanish throne in 1808?
- Marshal Ney
- His brother Joseph
- King Ferdinand
- Talleyrand
Show answer
His brother Joseph. Spanish resentment of Joseph sparked the guerrilla war.
- What was the 'Spanish ulcer'?
- A disease in the Grand Army in Russia
- Spain's naval defeat at Trafalgar
- A British subsidy to Spain
- The long, draining war in the Iberian Peninsula
Show answer
The long, draining war in the Iberian Peninsula. The Peninsular War drained French men and resources from 1808 to 1814.
- Pearson's specimen mark scheme says Wellington's campaign forced Napoleon to commit how many French troops to Spain?
Show answer
200000 troops. 200,000 French troops, needed in central Europe after the retreat from Russia.
- In which year did Napoleon invade Russia?
Show answer
1812. The 1812 campaign ended in a catastrophic retreat.
- Why was the alliance made at Tilsit (1807) unlikely to last, according to Pearson's June 2021 mark scheme?
- The Tsar never intended a permanent alliance and each power wanted to dominate the Near East
- Russia had been defeated by Britain
- Napoleon had married into the Romanov family
- Prussia forced Russia to leave
Show answer
The Tsar never intended a permanent alliance and each power wanted to dominate the Near East. Alexander I saw it as temporary; both wanted influence in the Near East.
- Pearson's January 2025 mark scheme says how many horses died in Russia?
Show answer
100000 horses. 100,000 horses died, depleting Napoleon's cavalry for 1813 to 14.
- Why did fighting in Spain and Russia at the same time weaken Napoleon so badly?
Show answer
It was a war on two fronts: men and resources tied down in Spain could not be used in Russia, so his forces were overstretched.. Two fronts overstretched his men and resources.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 4 (WHI04) Option 1A: The Making of Modern Europe, 1805 to 71
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2021
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, June 2018
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, January 2021
- Pearson WHI04/1A mark scheme, January 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.