All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations

4B The 1914 controversy: weighing the interpretations

Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations

Pearson has set many different views on why the war broke out. This lesson lines them up, including the extract authors Pearson's examiners have named, so you can judge any view against the others.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Views Pearson has set

SeriesView to assessContrasting extract
SpecimenGermany's decisions in 1914 were primarily responsibleEvery great power acted to protect core national interests
June 2019The crises of 1905 to 13 created the conditions for general warThe events at Sarajevo, not underlying forces, explain 1914
June 2022Austria-Hungary and Germany were determined to go to warMobilisation plans drove events despite attempts at peace
June 2023Serbia was most responsibleDeliberate German policy
January 2024German political and military aggressionShared responsibility; Sarajevo triggered tensions in the alliances
June 2024Leaders were 'rushed into action by the nature of war plans' (W K Storey)Decisions were overtaken by events (J F V Keiger)
January 2025The speeding up of the arms race, 1911 to 14Operational war planning, not the build-up, was responsible
June 2025War became unstoppable only after Russian mobilisation (D E Lee)Austria-Hungary was determined to use war and, with its German allies, would not accept a negotiated solution (J Joll)

Summarised from Pearson WHI04/1B mark schemes; authors' names are from Pearson's June 2024 and June 2025 examiners' reports.

Themes the topic guide lists

Alliances; militarism and the arms race; nationalism and imperialism; German aggression; the desire for security; the Sarajevo assassination; chance. Also: whether the war was one of aggression or defence; stabilising the German Reich (using war against socialist opponents, sometimes called social imperialism); war guilt; a 'chapter of accidents'; popular support; and whether war was inevitable.

Building a judgement

Distinguish long-term conditions (alliances, arms, crises) from short-term decisions (the blank cheque, the ultimatum, mobilisation). A useful criterion: which factor turned a Balkan quarrel into a war between all the great powers? Pearson's topic guide says you need the viewpoints and the reasons behind them, not the historiography.

Worked example

June 2025: 'Only after Russia's general mobilisation on 30 July 1914 did war become unstoppable.' Lee (Extract 1) agrees; Joll (Extract 2) disagrees. Outline a judgement.

  1. Lee: mobilisation activated the alliances and turned an Austro-Russian quarrel into general war; the Schlieffen Plan meant France had to be attacked before Russia was ready.
  2. Joll: the Austrians were determined to use war to get what they wanted and, with their German allies, had no intention of agreeing a negotiated solution (Pearson's June 2025 report). Own knowledge: Austria-Hungary was already at war with Serbia (28 July); the blank cheque had encouraged it.
  3. Criterion: after which decision did every power believe it could no longer step back?

Answer: One judgement: mobilisation was the point of no return for a general war, but Austro-German decisions earlier in July made a war with Serbia certain and made Russian mobilisation likely.

Key idea: Interpretations: German responsibility, Austro-German determination, Serbia, war plans (Storey) against events (Keiger), Russian mobilisation (Lee) against Austro-German intent (Joll), the arms race, the earlier crises. Separate long-term conditions from short-term decisions.

Check yourself

  1. What view did W K Storey's extract take in the June 2024 paper?
    • Serbia was mainly to blame
    • Leaders were pushed into action by war plans with complicated mobilisation timetables
    • The arms race made war certain from 1911
    • Britain caused the war
    Show answer

    Leaders were pushed into action by war plans with complicated mobilisation timetables. Pearson's June 2024 report.

  2. What view did J Joll's extract take in the June 2025 paper?
    • Russian mobilisation was the turning point
    • The alliances were too weak to matter
    • France caused the war
    • Russian mobilisation was unlikely to be decisive: Austria-Hungary was determined to use war to get what it wanted
    Show answer

    Russian mobilisation was unlikely to be decisive: Austria-Hungary was determined to use war to get what it wanted. Pearson's June 2025 report summarises Joll's view this way.

  3. Whose extract in June 2025 argued that Russia's mobilisation turned an Austro-Russian quarrel into a general war?
    • J Joll
    • D E Lee
    • W K Storey
    • J F V Keiger
    Show answer

    D E Lee. Lee's Extract 1.

  4. What did Pearson's specimen mark scheme mean by German 'social imperialism'?
    • Building schools in colonies
    • Giving workers the vote
    • Using an aggressive foreign policy to resist change at home
    • Sharing colonies with Britain
    Show answer

    Using an aggressive foreign policy to resist change at home. The elite used foreign policy to resist social and political change within the Reich.

  5. In January 2025, Extract 2 argued that the main arms rivalries did not cause the war. Why?
    • The war was triggered by Austria-Hungary and Russia, who were not in an arms race with each other
    • Britain had stopped building ships in 1905
    • Germany had no army
    • Russia had already disarmed
    Show answer

    The war was triggered by Austria-Hungary and Russia, who were not in an arms race with each other. The mark scheme summary of Extract 2.

  6. What is the difference between long-term conditions and short-term decisions in explaining 1914? Give an example of each.
    Show answer

    Long-term conditions, such as the alliance system or the arms race, made war possible; short-term decisions, such as the blank cheque or Russian mobilisation, actually started it.. Conditions made war possible; decisions made it happen.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.