All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
4C The Cold War controversy: weighing the interpretations
Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
Who or what caused the Cold War? Pearson's topic guide frames the issues without naming schools of historians. This lesson lines up the views Pearson has set, with the extract authors its examiners have named.
Issues in the topic guide
- A continuation of traditional great-power rivalry, now between superpowers?
- Soviet or American expansion, or defence?
- Inflexible leaders, or suspicion and misperception?
- Ideology, economics, hegemony, security, personality or misunderstanding as the main cause?
- Long and short-term, contingent and conditional causes, the role of individuals and chance.
Views Pearson has set
| Series | View to assess | Contrasting extract |
|---|---|---|
| Specimen | The Cold War developed from US national security needs | Stalin's ideological commitment to expansion |
| June 2023 | The US atomic monopoly greatly threatened Soviet power | The USSR was not panicked by the bomb |
| January 2024 | Stalin was to blame for the breakdown of the wartime alliance | Truman was less willing to compromise |
| June 2024 | The US decision to exploit its economic power | Soviet Marxist-Leninist ideology |
| January 2025 | A post-war propaganda war (R B Levering) | Truman deliberately began the Cold War (A J P Taylor) |
| June 2025 | Stalin's rejection of Marshall Aid (Kershaw) | The Berlin Blockade (Young) |
Summarised from Pearson WHI04/1C mark schemes; authors' names are from Pearson's January and June 2025 examiners' reports.
Building a judgement
Pick a criterion: which side's actions turned suspicion into division, or which factor made the others matter? For example: ideology explains mutual suspicion, but the security fears of a devastated USSR and the economic aims of a dominant USA explain particular decisions such as the Marshall Plan and the Stalinisation of Eastern Europe. Pearson says you need the viewpoints, not the historiography.
Worked example
January 2025: 'The Cold War began as a result of a propaganda war after the Second World War.' Levering (Extract 1) supports; Taylor (Extract 2) argues Truman began it deliberately. Outline a judgement.
- Levering: each side blamed the other; many Americans came to see Stalin as a threat like Hitler; each claimed only it could secure the world's future.
- Taylor: Truman was anti-Soviet from the start and meant the bomb to frighten the USSR; he miscalculated, raising tension.
- Own knowledge: negative US press and the Iron Curtain speech (1946); Truman's harder line from Potsdam; the bomb used in August 1945.
Answer: One judgement: propaganda deepened and spread hostility, but it reflected real decisions about Eastern Europe, Germany and the bomb, so it was a symptom as much as a cause.
Check yourself
- In January 2025, what view did A J P Taylor's extract take?
- The Cold War was caused by propaganda on each side
- Stalin's ideology made conflict inevitable
- The Berlin Blockade divided Europe
- Truman deliberately began the Cold War to push the USSR out of international politics
Show answer
Truman deliberately began the Cold War to push the USSR out of international politics. Pearson's January 2025 report.
- Which historian's extract (January 2025) argued that propaganda worsened US-Soviet relations?
- A J P Taylor
- R B Levering
- Kershaw
- Young
Show answer
R B Levering. Levering, Extract 1.
- In June 2025, which development did Young's extract present as dividing Europe?
- Marshall Aid
- The atomic bomb
- The Korean War
- The Berlin Blockade
Show answer
The Berlin Blockade. Extract 2 argued the blockade caused the full division by autumn 1949.
- Which issue does Pearson's topic guide raise about the Cold War's causes?
- Whether actions reflected expansion or defence
- Whether the extracts are reliable sources
- Whether Napoleon caused it
- Whether the League caused it
Show answer
Whether actions reflected expansion or defence. Expansion or defence is one of the guide's issues.
- Which evidence supports the view that the USA exploited its economic power (June 2024)?
- The Warsaw Pact of 1955
- Stalin's Moscow speech
- The Marshall Plan aimed to stop communism and promote capitalism
- The Cominform
Show answer
The Marshall Plan aimed to stop communism and promote capitalism. June 2024 mark scheme summary of Extract 1.
- Why might Soviet actions in Eastern Europe after 1945 be seen as defensive rather than expansionist?
Show answer
Because the USSR had been devastated by the war and wanted friendly governments as a buffer to protect its security against future invasion.. A devastated USSR wanted a buffer for security.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 4 (WHI04) Option 1C: The World Divided, Superpower Relations, 1943 to 90 (Issue 1, May 2018)
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, June 2024
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, January 2025
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, June 2023
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, January 2024
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, June 2025
- Pearson WHI04/1C examiners' report, January 2025
- Pearson WHI04/1C examiners' report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.