All subjects · History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
4C How real was detente? Proxy wars and the collapse of detente
Edexcel IAL History · WHI04 International Study with Historical Interpretations
Detente reduced tension, but rivalry never stopped. Pearson has asked whether either superpower was seriously committed to it. This lesson covers the limits of detente and why it collapsed by 1979.
Rivalry continued
- Proxy conflicts: Angola, Mozambique, Ethiopia; US fear of Marxist influence in South and Central America; superpower intervention in Africa and the Middle East (an overview is enough, says the topic guide).
- Arms: SALT I suited each side; the USA refused to negotiate on MIRVs, where it had the lead; China became a nuclear power; the USA tested a neutron bomb.
- Human rights: the USSR ignored the Helsinki commitments in the Eastern bloc; the USA criticised abuses in the USSR and China.
Why it collapsed
- Brezhnev held to the long-term victory of communism and refused to link detente to concessions (specimen mark scheme).
- Soviet hardliners grew more influential; by the late 1970s detente was strained over Iran, Afghanistan, Central America and Cambodia.
- The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan (late 1979) and Congress's refusal to ratify SALT II ended it.
Was anyone committed?
Committed: both wanted to control the risks and costs of the arms race; the Nixon Doctrine needed good relations with Moscow; the USSR wanted trade, technology and grain and feared isolation as China moved towards the USA. Not committed: the rivalry continued wherever it could.
Worked example
Use the evidence to decide whether 'neither superpower was seriously committed to detente in the 1970s'.
- Not committed: proxy wars in Angola and Ethiopia; MIRVs left out of SALT I; Helsinki human rights ignored; Afghanistan and SALT II's failure in 1979.
- Committed: SALT I, Helsinki and summits in 1972, 1973 and 1974; Soviet need for grain and technology; the US need to leave Vietnam.
Answer: A judgement might say each side was committed to managing the nuclear danger and gaining practical benefits, but neither gave up the wider contest, so detente was a truce, not a settlement.
Check yourself
- Which of these was a proxy conflict of the 1970s, according to Pearson's specimen mark scheme?
- Hungary 1956
- Berlin 1948
- Angola
- Korea 1950
Show answer
Angola. Angola, Mozambique and Ethiopia.
- On which weapons did the USA refuse to negotiate in SALT I, according to Pearson?
- MIRVs, where it held an advantage
- Hydrogen bombs
- Cruise missiles in Britain
- Battleships
Show answer
MIRVs, where it held an advantage. Specimen mark scheme.
- What happened to SALT II?
- It was ratified at once
- It was never signed
- It was signed in 1979 but not ratified by the US Congress
- It was replaced by the Test Ban Treaty
Show answer
It was signed in 1979 but not ratified by the US Congress. Specimen and June 2023 mark schemes.
- When did the USSR invade Afghanistan?
- 1968
- Late 1979
- 1956
- 1985
Show answer
Late 1979. Britannica: late 1979; troops stayed until February 1989.
- How did the USSR undermine the Helsinki Accords?
- It refused to sign
- It invaded Finland
- It left the UN
- It disregarded human rights in the Eastern bloc
Show answer
It disregarded human rights in the Eastern bloc. Specimen mark scheme.
- Give one reason why detente collapsed at the end of the 1970s.
Show answer
The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 alarmed the USA, and Congress refused to ratify SALT II.. Afghanistan; SALT II not ratified; proxy wars; human rights.
Sources
- Pearson: International Advanced Level History, Getting Started guide
- Pearson IAL History Topic Guide, Unit 4 (WHI04) Option 1C: The World Divided, Superpower Relations, 1943 to 90 (Issue 1, May 2018)
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Major Cold War events
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, Specimen
- Pearson WHI04/1C mark scheme, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.