All subjects · Information Technology · WIT13 2 hour written exam on data, enabling technologies and systems development
Changeover methods: direct, parallel, phased and pilot
Edexcel IAL Information Technology · WIT13 2 hour written exam on data, enabling technologies and systems development
When a new IT system replaces an old one, the organisation must choose how to switch over. Each method balances cost, risk and speed differently (spec 14.2.2).
The four methods
| Method | How it works | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct | The old system stops and the new one starts at a fixed moment | Quick, cheapest, no duplicated work | Highest risk: if the new system fails there is nothing to fall back on; staff must be trained beforehand |
| Parallel | Old and new systems run together for a period; results are compared | Lowest risk; outputs can be checked; old system is a fallback | Most expensive: double the work and staff time; data entered twice; can confuse staff |
| Phased | The new system is introduced one part (module or function) at a time | Problems are limited to one part; staff learn gradually | Slow; old and new parts must work together (interfacing) |
| Pilot | The whole new system is introduced in one branch, department or group first, then rolled out | Problems found on a small scale; pilot users can train others | Slower overall; the pilot site bears the risk; the pilot may not be typical |
Choosing a method
Ask: How critical is the system (can the business survive if it fails)? What is the budget? How much time is there? Are there many sites or separable modules? How compatible are old and new data?
- Safety-critical or financial systems: parallel.
- Chain of shops or branches: pilot.
- Large system with separate modules (payroll, then stock, then ordering): phased.
- Small system, simple, or old system unusable (or a fixed legal deadline): direct.
Always justify the choice with the scenario's details: a one-word answer earns little.
Worked example
Running the old system costs 3000 a week and the new one 2500 a week. Parallel running lasts 6 weeks. What is the extra cost compared with direct changeover?
- During parallel running the old system is still paid for: 3000 a week extra
- Extra cost = 3000 x 6 = 18000
Answer: 18000 extra, the price of having a fallback
Check yourself
- A bank replaces its account-processing system and cannot risk any errors in balances. Which changeover method is most suitable?
- Parallel
- Direct
- Pilot in one branch with no fallback
- Phased over five years
Show answer
Parallel. Outputs can be compared and the old system remains as a fallback.
- A restaurant chain with 40 outlets introduces a new ordering system in one outlet first. Which method is this?
- Phased
- Parallel
- Pilot
- Direct
Show answer
Pilot. One site first, then roll out.
- A company introduces the HR module of a new system in January, payroll in March and expenses in June. Which method is this?
- Phased
- Pilot
- Parallel
- Direct
Show answer
Phased. One part at a time.
- What is the main disadvantage of direct changeover?
- It is the most expensive method
- Staff must enter all data twice
- It takes the longest time
- If the new system fails there is no old system to fall back on
Show answer
If the new system fails there is no old system to fall back on. High risk.
- Parallel running lasts 4 weeks. The old system costs 1800 a week to run. What is the extra cost of the old system during parallel running?
Show answer
7200. 1800 x 4 = 7200.
- Explain one advantage of pilot changeover for an organisation with many branches.
Show answer
Any problems with the new system only affect one branch, so they can be fixed before the system is rolled out to every branch, and pilot staff can then help train others.. Limited scope, so problems fixed before full rollout.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Information Technology specification (first teaching 2018), Issue 2, February 2021
- Pearson Edexcel IAL Information Technology: scheme of work for Unit 3
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.