All subjects · Information Technology · WIT14 3 hour practical exam on database solutions
User experience: how design affects the user
Edexcel IAL Information Technology · WIT14 3 hour practical exam on database solutions
Specification 17.3 links user characteristics to design choices and design choices to the experience users get. You must build solutions that give a suitable experience and evaluate them.
Characteristics that shape the design
The spec lists five aspects of design that depend on who the users are:
- Type of interface: forms, menus and dashboards (guided) versus direct table or query access (flexible but risky).
- Appearance: layout, alignment, colour, font size, grouping of related fields, a consistent style across screens.
- Complexity: how many options appear at once. Novices need fewer choices per screen; experts tolerate more.
- Language: plain, consistent wording that suits the users; avoid internal field names such as CustID on screen.
- Compatibility: the solution must run on the users' devices and software version, and exported files must open in the software the recipient uses.
How design affects the experience
| Aspect of experience | Good design | Poor design |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of use | Clear labels, logical tab order, one task per screen | Unlabelled boxes, random order |
| Efficiency | Defaults, drop-downs, auto-generated IDs, buttons for frequent jobs | Retyping the same data, many clicks |
| Help | Instructions on the form, help text in the status bar or tooltips | No guidance; users guess |
| Compatibility | Works in the version the users have; exports to formats they can open | Features that fail on the users' system |
| Stability | Errors are trapped and explained; users cannot break the design | Crashes or cryptic system messages |
| Accuracy of data | Validation, input masks, lookups, confirmation before saving | Free typing everywhere |
Building and evaluating for experience
When you build a form or menu in the exam, the mark scheme rewards features that improve the experience, for example a meaningful title, instructions, clear labels, required fields marked with an asterisk, fields that cannot be edited being disabled, a clearly labelled save button with a confirmation message. Pearson's examiner reports note that default wizard forms earn few marks.
To evaluate the experience, judge each aspect (ease of use, efficiency, help, compatibility, stability, accuracy) with evidence from your solution, then suggest a specific improvement for any weakness.
Worked example
Evaluate this design: a booking form opens with all 14 fields of three tables on one screen, field captions are the raw field names, and an Access system error appears if Days is 0.
- Complexity: too many fields at once for occasional users; split into a customer section and a hire section, or show only fields needed for a booking.
- Language: raw names such as CustomerID confuse users; use captions such as 'Customer'.
- Stability and help: the system error is unhelpful; add a validation rule with text such as 'Days must be 1 or more'.
Answer: Each criticism names the aspect of experience, the evidence and a specific fix.
Check yourself
- A user enters a negative quantity and sees a cryptic system error, then the form closes. Which aspect of user experience is poorest?
- Compatibility, because the software version is wrong
- Appearance, because the colours clash
- Efficiency, because there are too many clicks
- Stability, because errors are not trapped and explained
Show answer
Stability, because errors are not trapped and explained. Untrapped errors and crashes are a stability problem; a validation rule with a clear message fixes it.
- Which feature mainly improves efficiency?
- The title is in a larger font
- The date field defaults to today
- The form has a company logo
- Field labels are left aligned
Show answer
The date field defaults to today. Defaults remove a typing step every time a record is entered.
- A report is exported in a format the client's office software cannot open. Which aspect has been ignored?
- Complexity
- Language
- Stability
- Compatibility
Show answer
Compatibility. Outputs must be usable on the recipients' systems.
- Which form label is best for users at a hotel reception?
- Guest's arrival date
- dtArr
- fld_ArrDt
- ARRIVAL_DATE_FK
Show answer
Guest's arrival date. Plain language that matches the users' own words is easiest to understand.
- Which is an example of help built into a form?
- A validation rule with no error message
- A hidden field holding the record ID
- Status bar text explaining what to enter when a field is selected
- A primary key on the table
Show answer
Status bar text explaining what to enter when a field is selected. Help text guides users as they work.
- A data entry form lets users type any value for 'Membership type', which must be Gold, Silver or Bronze. Explain the effect on user experience and suggest an improvement.
Show answer
Users can make spelling mistakes, so data is inaccurate and searches miss records; a drop-down list of the three types would prevent this and be quicker.. Free typing harms data accuracy (and searching); a list, option group or list validation rule fixes it.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Information Technology specification (Issue 2, February 2021): Unit 4, Topics 17 to 19
- Pearson: WIT14/01 examiner report, June 2024
- Pearson: WIT14/01 examiner report, June 2025
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.