All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
EU law: the Court of Justice, the European Commission, supremacy and the position after Brexit
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.12 covers decisions of the European Court of Justice and the role of the European Commission. You also need to evaluate the impact of EU law on the English legal system and understand what changed after the UK left the EU.
The European Commission
The Commission is the EU's executive. It has one Commissioner from each member state, who acts for the Union as a whole, and a President. It proposes and drafts legislation, develops strategy and represents the EU in trade negotiations (Article 17 of the Treaty on European Union). As 'guardian of the treaties' it ensures member states comply: it can start infringement proceedings and refer a state to the Court of Justice (Pearson mark schemes). Pearson's guide gives *Commission v United Kingdom*, over the UK's failure to implement a regulation requiring tachographs in commercial vehicles.
The Court of Justice
The Court of Justice ensures EU law is interpreted and applied uniformly. It hears actions against states that fail to comply, and references from national courts under Article 267: a national court can ask for a ruling on the meaning of EU law, and a court from which there is no further appeal (such as the UK Supreme Court before Brexit) generally had to refer. Its landmark decisions include *Van Gend en Loos* and *Costa v ENEL* (cited in *Miller* for EU law's direct effect and priority) and *Francovich* (1991).
Impact on the English legal system
The European Communities Act 1972 made EU law 'an independent and overriding source of domestic law' (Supreme Court, *Miller*, 2017): section 2(1) gave EU rights effect without further enactment, and section 2(4) made other Acts take effect subject to it. In *Factortame (No 2)* [1991] the House of Lords accepted that EU law could not be impliedly displaced by a later inconsistent Act. Evaluation for the sample paper's 10 mark question: this dispersed parliamentary sovereignty and gave the courts a new role, but Parliament had chosen it in 1972 and could end it, which it did.
After Brexit
In *Miller* (2017) the Supreme Court held that ministers needed an Act of Parliament before giving notice to leave. Under the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, EU-derived law was kept as retained EU law at the end of the transition period (end of 2020). The Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023 (Royal Assent 29 June 2023) revoked listed instruments at the end of 2023, abolished the supremacy of EU law and the general principles of EU law from 1 January 2024, renamed the remaining law 'assimilated law', and made it easier for UK courts to depart from retained EU case law. In an answer, describe EU law as the specification requires, then show you know its supremacy no longer applies in the UK.
Worked example
Analyse the role of the European Commission when a member state breaches EU law. (6 marks)
- Role: guardian of the treaties, ensuring compliance (Article 17 TEU).
- Process: infringement proceedings, then referral to the Court of Justice.
- Example: Commission v UK over tachographs.
Answer: The Commission monitors compliance, can begin infringement proceedings and refer the state to the Court of Justice, as it did against the UK over tachographs.
Check yourself
- Which EU institution proposes legislation and acts as 'guardian of the treaties'?
- The Court of Justice
- The European Commission
- The UK Supreme Court
- The Law Commission
Show answer
The European Commission. Article 17 TEU.
- Under which Article of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU could a national court refer a question of EU law to the Court of Justice?
Show answer
267. Article 267 (formerly Article 234).
- If a member state fails to comply with EU law, the Commission can
- pass an Act of the UK Parliament
- begin infringement proceedings and refer the state to the Court of Justice
- dismiss the state's government
- change the state's constitution directly
Show answer
begin infringement proceedings and refer the state to the Court of Justice. Pearson's sample mark scheme.
- Factortame (No 2) (1991) is cited in Miller for the point that
- directives need no national law
- the Commission can repeal Acts of Parliament
- EU law could not be impliedly displaced by a later inconsistent Act
- Parliament can never legislate on fishing
Show answer
EU law could not be impliedly displaced by a later inconsistent Act. Section 2(4) ECA 1972 gave EU law priority.
- What did the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023 do from 1 January 2024?
- Abolished the principle of the supremacy of EU law in UK law
- Made all EU regulations directly applicable again
- Rejoined the Court of Justice
- Repealed the Human Rights Act 1998
Show answer
Abolished the principle of the supremacy of EU law in UK law. Section 3; remaining retained law became 'assimilated law'.
- In Miller (2017), the Supreme Court held that
- ministers could leave the EU using the prerogative alone
- EU law was never part of UK law
- an Act of Parliament was needed before notice to leave the EU could be given
- the Commission must approve the UK's withdrawal
Show answer
an Act of Parliament was needed before notice to leave the EU could be given. Withdrawal changed domestic law, so Parliament had to authorise it.
- Explain one way EU membership affected parliamentary sovereignty.
Show answer
Under the European Communities Act 1972 EU law took priority over conflicting Acts of Parliament, so courts could disapply UK law, as in Factortame.. EU law had priority over conflicting domestic statutes (ECA 1972 s2(4), Factortame), limiting sovereignty while membership lasted.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
- Pearson: IAL Law sample assessment materials (Paper 1 sample paper and mark scheme)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- UK Supreme Court: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5
- EUR-Lex: Joined Cases C-6/90 and C-9/90 Francovich v Italian Republic, judgment of 19 November 1991
- legislation.gov.uk: Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023
- House of Commons Library: Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.