All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Judges: types, selection, appointment and independence
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Specification point 1.2.20 covers the role, selection and appointment of judges, including the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 and the Constitutional Reform Act 2005. In June 2025 a 6 mark part asked how judges are selected and appointed.
Types of judge
| Judge | Where they sit |
|---|---|
| Justices of the Supreme Court (12) | UK Supreme Court: final appeals |
| Lords and Ladies Justices of Appeal | Court of Appeal |
| High Court judges | High Court divisions; serious criminal cases on circuit |
| Circuit judges | Crown Court and County Court, on one of six circuits |
| Recorders | Part-time, fee-paid judges in the Crown Court and County Court; solicitors, barristers and CILEx Fellows can apply |
| District judges | Most County Court cases |
| District judges (magistrates' courts) | Salaried, legally qualified, sit alone on longer magistrates' cases |
From the Judicial Office visitor's guide (2021) and the Judicial Appointments Commission.
Selection and appointment
Since April 2006 the independent Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) selects judges for courts in England and Wales and some tribunals, by open competition and solely on merit, and only people of good character. It has a statutory duty to encourage diversity. It is chaired by a lay person; judges sit on it but are not a majority. The JAC recommends a candidate to the Lord Chancellor, who has only a very limited power of veto (judiciary.uk).
Eligibility: most roles need 5 years' post-qualification experience, Circuit judge and above 7 years (JAC). Solicitors, barristers and, for some roles such as District judge and Recorder, CILEx Fellows can apply. Supreme Court Justices need two years in high judicial office or fifteen years as a qualifying practitioner and are chosen by a selection commission (CRA 2005, s25 and ss26 to 31).
Before 2006, the Lord Chancellor, a government minister, recommended appointments after his department's own enquiries; critics said it drew judges from a narrow pool, in the image of existing judges.
The two Acts
- Courts and Legal Services Act 1990: widened rights of audience, so solicitors could qualify to appear in the higher courts (Pearson's June 2022 mark scheme lists it under rights of audience).
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005: the Lord Chancellor is no longer a judge or head of the judiciary; the Lord Chief Justice became Head of the Judiciary of England and Wales (s7); ministers must uphold judicial independence and must not seek to influence particular decisions through special access to judges (s3); the Supreme Court replaced the House of Lords Appellate Committee, separating the top court from Parliament (it opened in 2009); and it created the JAC.
Evaluation
For (June 2025 mark scheme): appointees have deep legal knowledge; the JAC is independent and appointments are free from political interference; solicitors and academics can now apply.
Against: the best lawyers may not apply because of pay; barristers still predominate; the judiciary is not representative of society, though schemes such as the Judicial Work Shadowing Scheme and Judicial Outreach Mentoring Scheme try to widen the pool; limited training and practical experience outside law.
Worked example
Explain how judges are selected and appointed. (6 marks: plan)
- Eligibility: 5 or 7 years' experience; solicitors, barristers, some CILEx Fellows.
- JAC: open competition, merit, good character, lay chair, duty to encourage diversity.
- Recommendation to the Lord Chancellor, limited veto; senior appointments by the Crown.
- Analysis: more independent than the pre-2006 system, but diversity is still limited.
Answer: A developed explanation of the JAC process with a judgement on its effectiveness.
Check yourself
- Which body has selected judges in England and Wales since April 2006?
- The Law Society
- The House of Commons
- The Bar Council
- The Judicial Appointments Commission
Show answer
The Judicial Appointments Commission. Created by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005.
- The JAC must select candidates
- according to political party
- solely on merit and of good character
- only from barristers
- by seniority alone
Show answer
solely on merit and of good character. Merit and good character are statutory requirements.
- How many years' post-qualification experience do most judicial roles require, according to the JAC?
Show answer
5 years. Five years; seven for Circuit judge and above.
- Under the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, who is Head of the Judiciary of England and Wales?
- The Lord Chief Justice
- The Lord Chancellor
- The Prime Minister
- The Master of the Rolls
Show answer
The Lord Chief Justice. Section 7 gave the Lord Chief Justice this title.
- Section 3 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005
- abolished the jury
- created the Law Commission
- requires ministers to uphold judicial independence
- set up the European Commission
Show answer
requires ministers to uphold judicial independence. Ministers must not seek to influence decisions through special access.
- What was the main criticism of the system used before 2006?
- A government minister recommended judges drawn from a narrow pool
- Judges were elected by the public
- Judges had no legal qualifications
- The Supreme Court chose all judges
Show answer
A government minister recommended judges drawn from a narrow pool. Judges were chosen in the image of existing judges (judiciary.uk).
- Explain why a lack of diversity in the judiciary might be a problem.
Show answer
If judges come from a narrow background they may not understand the experiences of many people who appear before them, which can reduce public confidence in the courts.. An unrepresentative judiciary may lack understanding and lose public confidence.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Judicial Office: The Judicial System of England and Wales, a visitor's guide (March 2021)
- Courts and Tribunals Judiciary: Judicial appointments
- Judicial Appointments Commission: Check you're eligible
- Courts and Tribunals Judiciary: Appointments and diversity
- legislation.gov.uk: Constitutional Reform Act 2005, Explanatory Notes
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2022 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2025 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson examiners' report: YLA1/01, June 2025
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.