All subjects · English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition

Identity and accommodation in the data

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition

Pearson's reports say Giles's accommodation theory 'featured heavily' in recent answers and links it to identity in the transcript. Use it precisely.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Accommodation theory

Speech accommodation theory, developed by the social psychologist Howard Giles and colleagues, was later widened into communication accommodation theory (Giles, Coupland and Coupland).

Motives include social approval (converging to be liked) and social identity (diverging to signal group distinctiveness). Studies reviewed by Giles and colleagues found speakers often converge towards those with more power: interviewees towards interviewers, salespeople towards customers.

Upward and downward

The 2016 exemplar commentary credits applying downward convergence and covert prestige. Upward convergence moves towards a more prestigious variety (an interviewee using more acrolectal forms); downward convergence moves towards a less prestigious one (a politician adopting local forms to seem ordinary).

Spotting it in a transcript

Look for:

Pearson's January 2024 report linked accommodation theory to the speaker's comments in the transcript; the June 2025 report linked it to phonology.

Worked example

An invented YouTube interviewee: 'when I'm with my friends we talk we own way (.) but here (.) for the video (.) I'm trying to speak more proper you know'. Analyse.

  1. The speaker reports upward convergence towards a standard for a global online audience.
  2. 'we talk we own way' (object form 'we' as possessive) shows the home variety still surfacing.
  3. 'more proper' shows the speaker has absorbed overt-prestige attitudes, while 'our own way' implies covert prestige for the home variety.

Answer: Upward convergence for the audience, with home-variety forms leaking through and a tension between overt and covert prestige.

Key idea: Convergence = becoming more like the listener; divergence = emphasising difference. Upward towards prestige, downward away from it. Motives: approval, identity. Link to the interview context and the speaker's own comments.

Check yourself

  1. An interviewee shifts towards the interviewer's standard accent. This is
    • upward convergence
    • divergence
    • downward convergence
    • relexification
    Show answer

    upward convergence. Moving towards a more prestigious variety.

  2. Welsh speakers broaden their Welsh accents after an English-sounding speaker calls Welsh a dying language. This is
    • convergence
    • decreolisation
    • divergence
    • nativisation
    Show answer

    divergence. Bourhis and Giles (1977), reported by Giles, Coupland and Coupland: accentuating differences to assert identity.

  3. Communication accommodation theory grew out of an earlier theory called
    • speech accommodation theory
    • the language bioprogram
    • the dynamic model
    • the principle of least effort
    Show answer

    speech accommodation theory. Giles and colleagues widened speech accommodation theory into communication accommodation theory.

  4. A politician uses local slang to seem like an ordinary voter. This is
    • upward convergence
    • divergence
    • exonormative stabilisation
    • downward convergence
    Show answer

    downward convergence. Moving towards a less prestigious variety.

  5. One motive for convergence is
    • showing group distinctiveness
    • seeking social approval
    • hiding your identity from friends
    • making speech harder to follow
    Show answer

    seeking social approval. Similarity increases attraction.

  6. Why might a speaker in a transcript diverge from Standard English?
    Show answer

    To emphasise their own identity and group membership, showing pride in their variety and distinctiveness from outsiders.. Divergence signals group distinctiveness and social identity.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.