All subjects · English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition

Attitudes: prescriptivism, descriptivism and prestige

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition

The specification asks you to critically evaluate attitudes towards language and its users. Section B sources often express attitudes to a variety, and your own writing must model a descriptive stance.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Prescriptivism and descriptivism

Prescriptivism sets rules of 'correct' usage and treats departures as errors (Sheffield's example: the rule against ending a sentence with a preposition). Descriptivism describes how people actually use language without judging it. Pearson's June 2025 report notes candidates are becoming better at adopting a descriptivist approach and criticises prescriptivist tendencies. A deficit model treats a variety as a failed version of the standard; Pearson's reports tell candidates to avoid it.

Overt and covert prestige

Pearson's reports note that Labov's concept of overt and covert prestige features often in answers.

Trudgill's Norwich study (1972) took the term from Labov's New York work (1966), describing the 'hidden values' of non-standard speech that are 'not usually overtly expressed': Norwich men tended to report their own speech as more non-standard than it was. Creoles and new Englishes can carry covert prestige in the same way.

Stigma, preservation and imperialism

Sources often show attitudes in tension: stigma (the 2016 exemplar commentary credits recognising creoles as stigmatised), pride and language preservation (Pearson's June 2024 mark scheme: recording folk tales, speakers' reluctance to share stories with outsiders). Some candidates used Phillipson's Linguistic Imperialism (1992), which argues that Western countries used English as a tool of imperialism; Pearson's June 2025 report quotes it as a Section B example. Weigh it against evidence of speakers making English their own.

Worked example

An invented source quotes a teacher: 'Our children must drop the patois if they want good jobs', and a musician: 'Our creole is who we are.' Analyse the attitudes.

  1. The teacher's view is prescriptive and links the standard to overt prestige and economic success.
  2. The musician's view shows covert prestige: the creole signals identity and solidarity.
  3. Evaluate: both reflect real social pressures; a descriptive linguist would note the creole is systematic and that speakers can command both (code-switching).

Answer: Overt prestige (teacher) versus covert prestige (musician), evaluated descriptively, noting speakers' ability to use both varieties.

Key idea: Prescriptive = rules and 'errors'. Descriptive = how language is used. Avoid the deficit model. Overt prestige (standard) versus covert prestige (non-standard identity). Phillipson: English as a tool of imperialism.

Check yourself

  1. 'People should never split an infinitive' is a
    • descriptive observation
    • prescriptive attitude
    • covert prestige marker
    • calque
    Show answer

    prescriptive attitude. It prescribes a rule.

  2. Which statement is descriptive?
    • Speakers should stop dropping their verbs
    • This variety is a lazy form of English
    • Proper English always uses 'is'
    • Many speakers in this community omit the copula before adjectives
    Show answer

    Many speakers in this community omit the copula before adjectives. It describes usage without judging.

  3. Young men keep a local non-standard accent because it signals toughness and belonging. This is
    • overt prestige
    • covert prestige
    • relexification
    • exonormative stabilisation
    Show answer

    covert prestige. Value within the group despite low official status.

  4. Overt prestige is attached to
    • slang used by teenagers
    • creoles spoken at home
    • standard varieties widely recognised as prestigious
    • words borrowed from French
    Show answer

    standard varieties widely recognised as prestigious. Overt = openly recognised.

  5. Pearson's reports warn against a 'deficit model'. This means treating a variety as
    • a failed version of the standard
    • a lingua franca
    • a written mode
    • an expanding-circle variety
    Show answer

    a failed version of the standard. Deficit = lacking.

  6. Phillipson's Linguistic Imperialism argues that
    • English spread only because it is easy
    • creoles have no grammar
    • Western countries used English as a tool of imperialism
    • RP should be taught everywhere
    Show answer

    Western countries used English as a tool of imperialism. Wikipedia summary of the book's argument.

  7. Explain why a speaker might keep a stigmatised creole even though Standard English has more overt prestige.
    Show answer

    Because it carries covert prestige: it signals identity, belonging and solidarity with their community.. Covert prestige: value within the community.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.