All subjects · English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition
Attitudes: prescriptivism, descriptivism and prestige
Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition
The specification asks you to critically evaluate attitudes towards language and its users. Section B sources often express attitudes to a variety, and your own writing must model a descriptive stance.
Prescriptivism and descriptivism
Prescriptivism sets rules of 'correct' usage and treats departures as errors (Sheffield's example: the rule against ending a sentence with a preposition). Descriptivism describes how people actually use language without judging it. Pearson's June 2025 report notes candidates are becoming better at adopting a descriptivist approach and criticises prescriptivist tendencies. A deficit model treats a variety as a failed version of the standard; Pearson's reports tell candidates to avoid it.
Overt and covert prestige
Pearson's reports note that Labov's concept of overt and covert prestige features often in answers.
- Overt prestige: standard varieties are widely and consciously recognised as prestigious.
- Covert prestige: non-standard varieties are valued within a community, mainly by their own speakers, as markers of identity and solidarity.
Trudgill's Norwich study (1972) took the term from Labov's New York work (1966), describing the 'hidden values' of non-standard speech that are 'not usually overtly expressed': Norwich men tended to report their own speech as more non-standard than it was. Creoles and new Englishes can carry covert prestige in the same way.
Stigma, preservation and imperialism
Sources often show attitudes in tension: stigma (the 2016 exemplar commentary credits recognising creoles as stigmatised), pride and language preservation (Pearson's June 2024 mark scheme: recording folk tales, speakers' reluctance to share stories with outsiders). Some candidates used Phillipson's Linguistic Imperialism (1992), which argues that Western countries used English as a tool of imperialism; Pearson's June 2025 report quotes it as a Section B example. Weigh it against evidence of speakers making English their own.
Worked example
An invented source quotes a teacher: 'Our children must drop the patois if they want good jobs', and a musician: 'Our creole is who we are.' Analyse the attitudes.
- The teacher's view is prescriptive and links the standard to overt prestige and economic success.
- The musician's view shows covert prestige: the creole signals identity and solidarity.
- Evaluate: both reflect real social pressures; a descriptive linguist would note the creole is systematic and that speakers can command both (code-switching).
Answer: Overt prestige (teacher) versus covert prestige (musician), evaluated descriptively, noting speakers' ability to use both varieties.
Check yourself
- 'People should never split an infinitive' is a
- descriptive observation
- prescriptive attitude
- covert prestige marker
- calque
Show answer
prescriptive attitude. It prescribes a rule.
- Which statement is descriptive?
- Speakers should stop dropping their verbs
- This variety is a lazy form of English
- Proper English always uses 'is'
- Many speakers in this community omit the copula before adjectives
Show answer
Many speakers in this community omit the copula before adjectives. It describes usage without judging.
- Young men keep a local non-standard accent because it signals toughness and belonging. This is
- overt prestige
- covert prestige
- relexification
- exonormative stabilisation
Show answer
covert prestige. Value within the group despite low official status.
- Overt prestige is attached to
- slang used by teenagers
- creoles spoken at home
- standard varieties widely recognised as prestigious
- words borrowed from French
Show answer
standard varieties widely recognised as prestigious. Overt = openly recognised.
- Pearson's reports warn against a 'deficit model'. This means treating a variety as
- a failed version of the standard
- a lingua franca
- a written mode
- an expanding-circle variety
Show answer
a failed version of the standard. Deficit = lacking.
- Phillipson's Linguistic Imperialism argues that
- English spread only because it is easy
- creoles have no grammar
- Western countries used English as a tool of imperialism
- RP should be taught everywhere
Show answer
Western countries used English as a tool of imperialism. Wikipedia summary of the book's argument.
- Explain why a speaker might keep a stigmatised creole even though Standard English has more overt prestige.
Show answer
Because it carries covert prestige: it signals identity, belonging and solidarity with their community.. Covert prestige: value within the community.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in English Language specification (Issue 4, February 2026)
- University of Sheffield, All About Linguistics: Standardisation and RP
- Trudgill, P. (1972) Sex, covert prestige and linguistic change in the urban British English of Norwich, Language in Society 1 (Cambridge University Press)
- Wikipedia: Linguistic Imperialism (book)
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, June 2025
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, January 2025
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, June 2024
- Pearson WEN02 mark scheme, June 2024 (copy hosted by Physics and Maths Tutor)
- Pearson: IAS Unit 2 Language in Transition (WEN02) exemplar scripts with examiner commentary, June 2016 series (Issue 1.1, February 2017)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.