All subjects · English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition
Theories of change in the examiner reports
Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN02 Language in Transition
The specification names no theorists, but Pearson's examiner reports list the theories candidates use and warn about partial or misattributed ones. This lesson pulls them together so you use each accurately.
The theory map
| Theory or concept | Core idea | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Kachru's circles | Inner, outer, expanding circles of English | Placing the variety globally |
| Schneider's dynamic model | Five phases from foundation to differentiation | How a postcolonial variety develops |
| Giles: accommodation | Convergence and divergence | Speaker identity and audience in the transcript |
| Overt and covert prestige | Standard versus in-group value | Attitudes, identity |
| Aitchison, Progress or Decay? | Change is neither progress nor decay | Evaluating attitudes |
| Zipf: least effort | Economy balanced against clarity | Elision, clipping, simplification |
| Substrate, superstrate, relexification | Where contact-variety features come from | Explaining creole features |
| Phillipson: linguistic imperialism | English spread as a tool of power | Critical view of global English |
Theories named in Pearson's WEN02 principal examiner reports, January 2024 to June 2025.
Aitchison's images: not theories
Pearson's June 2025 report warns that the 'damp spoon' and 'crumbling castle' images belong to a point about prescriptivism, not to theories in their own right. In her 1996 Reith lecture Aitchison described three common worries, and rejected them:
- damp spoon syndrome: change seen as sloppiness or laziness (a newspaper writer compared her distaste to seeing a damp spoon in the sugar bowl). Aitchison: fast informal speech is not intrinsically worse, just different.
- crumbling castle view: language as a monument decaying from a perfect past. Aitchison: there was no peak year of perfection.
- infectious disease assumption: changes caught like germs. Aitchison: people adopt changes to fit in.
The related 'golden age' idea, that language was once perfect, appears in the January 2025 report's list.
Using theory well
Pearson's reports reward theory used 'relevantly and accurately' with genuine understanding, and criticise partial understanding and misattribution. Rules:
- one theory applied to the data beats five name-dropped
- state what the theory predicts, then test it against the evidence
- evaluate: what does it miss?
Worked example
A candidate writes: 'The speaker drops her verbs, which is Aitchison's damp spoon theory.' Improve it.
- The feature should be named neutrally: third-person -s is absent.
- The damp spoon is an image for a prescriptive attitude, not a theory explaining the feature.
- Better: 'Some listeners might see the absent -s as sloppiness, the attitude Aitchison called damp spoon syndrome; but the pattern is systematic, so it is better explained by substrate influence or simplification.'
Answer: Describe the feature descriptively, present the damp spoon as an attitude Aitchison rejects, and explain the feature with a relevant linguistic account.
Check yourself
- The 'damp spoon syndrome' is the belief that language change is caused by
- contact with other languages
- technology
- colonial education
- laziness and sloppiness
Show answer
laziness and sloppiness. Aitchison: the view that sloppiness drives change.
- The 'crumbling castle' view treats English as
- a germ spreading between speakers
- a monument decaying from a perfect past
- a tool of imperialism
- a set of concentric circles
Show answer
a monument decaying from a perfect past. A monument to be preserved.
- Pearson's June 2025 report says the damp spoon and crumbling castle images are
- parts of Kachru's model
- phases of Schneider's model
- types of semantic change
- points about prescriptivism, not theories in their own right
Show answer
points about prescriptivism, not theories in their own right. The report warns of misattribution.
- What did Aitchison conclude about these worries?
- Language is not sick; we should understand it rather than control it
- English is decaying and needs protection
- Only RP should be taught
- Change must be stopped by law
Show answer
Language is not sick; we should understand it rather than control it. She rejects all three images.
- Which use of theory would Pearson's examiners reward most?
- Listing six theorists in the introduction
- Quoting a theory without linking to the data
- Applying one relevant theory to evidence and evaluating it
- Attributing an idea to the most famous name
Show answer
Applying one relevant theory to evidence and evaluating it. Reports reward relevant, accurate application.
- Why would a descriptive linguist reject the 'golden age' or 'crumbling castle' view of English?
Show answer
Because there was never a perfect peak of English; all languages constantly change, and change is neither progress nor decay.. Aitchison: there was no peak year of perfection.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Subsidiary/Advanced Level in English Language specification (Issue 4, February 2026)
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, June 2025
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, January 2025
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, June 2024
- Pearson principal examiner report, WEN02 Language in Transition, January 2024
- 1996 BBC Reith Lecture 1, A web of worries (extract in a UK sixth form college reading pack)
- Cambridge University Press: The Language Web, The Power and Problem of Words, The 1996 BBC Reith Lectures, chapter 1 A web of worries
- Times Higher Education: Madam, how dare you distort, desecrate and defile the English language
- SciELO, Revista Brasileira de Linguistica Aplicada: article on Kachru's three concentric circles and its critics
- Schneider, E. W. (2003) The dynamics of New Englishes: from identity construction to dialect birth, Language 79(2) (copy hosted by the University of Groningen)
- Giles, Coupland and Coupland: Accommodation theory: communication, context, and consequence (opening chapter of Contexts of Accommodation, Cambridge University Press; copy hosted by the University of Pittsburgh)
- UPCommons: Least effort and the origins of scaling in human language (research article)
- Wikipedia: Linguistic Imperialism (book)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.