All subjects · English Language · WEN04 Investigating Language

Child language: words, meanings and grammar

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN04 Investigating Language

Children's errors are evidence of how they learn. Overextensions show how they build meanings; overregularisations show that they work out rules rather than just copying. (Topic lesson: study the lessons for the one topic area your centre entered you for.)

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Meaning: over- and underextension

Both change as the child's vocabulary grows (Penn Linguistics notes).

Grammar: overregularisation

Children often use irregular forms correctly at first ('went'), then overapply a regular rule ('goed', 'bringed', 'mouses'), before using the adult form again. This is resistant to correction: in one recorded example a child kept saying 'holded' despite adult recasts. It suggests rule learning, not imitation.

Berko's wug test

ItemTaskChildren correct (about)
wug'There are two ___' (plural /-z/)91%
tassplural needing /-əz/36%
nizplural needing /-əz/28%
rickpast tense /-t/: 'ricked'73%
motpast tense /-əd/: 'motted'33%

Berko (1958): 80 children aged about 4 to 7 (preschool and first grade) used nonsense words with pictures. Because they had never heard the words, consistent answers show they apply rules. They learned the most general patterns first.

Practice transcript

Worked example

Analyse the practice transcript.

  1. 'runned': past-tense -ed overapplied to an irregular verb (overregularisation).
  2. 'sheeps': plural -s overapplied to a zero-plural noun.
  3. Father recasts with the correct forms; the child repeats 'two sheeps', showing resistance to correction.
  4. Supports rule-learning (nativist or cognitive views) more than simple imitation.

Answer: Two overregularisations and resistance to a recast: evidence that the child is applying rules.

Key idea: Overextension (too broad), underextension (too narrow). Overregularisation ('goed') shows rule use and resists correction. Berko's wug test: children pluralise new words, learning general patterns first.

Check yourself

  1. A child calls every man 'daddy'. This is
    • underextension
    • overregularisation
    • telegraphic speech
    • overextension
    Show answer

    overextension. The word is used too broadly.

  2. A child uses 'car' only for the family car. This is
    • overextension
    • underextension
    • babbling
    • a wug error
    Show answer

    underextension. Too narrow.

  3. 'I goed to the park' is evidence that the child
    • is copying adult speech
    • has a hearing problem
    • is in the babbling stage
    • is applying a past-tense rule
    Show answer

    is applying a past-tense rule. Adults do not say 'goed', so it is not imitation.

  4. Why did Berko use nonsense words such as 'wug'?
    • So children could not have heard the forms before, showing rule use
    • To confuse children
    • Because real words were too hard
    • To test spelling
    Show answer

    So children could not have heard the forms before, showing rule use. New words test productive rules.

  5. In a class of 50 children, how many would you expect to say 'wugs' if 91% did in Berko's study? Round to the nearest whole child.
    Show answer

    46 children. 50 x 0.91 = 45.5, about 46.

  6. Children found plurals like 'nizzes' harder than 'wugs' because
    • they learn the most general pattern (/-s/ or /-z/) before rarer forms (/-əz/)
    • 'niz' is a real word
    • they were older
    • the pictures were unclear
    Show answer

    they learn the most general pattern (/-s/ or /-z/) before rarer forms (/-əz/). Berko: rules simpler than adult grammar; general patterns first.

  7. What does the 'holded' example (a child repeating 'holded' despite recasts) suggest about the role of correction?
    Show answer

    It suggests direct correction has little immediate effect, because children are applying their own rules rather than imitating.. Penn notes: overregularisation is resistant to correction.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.