All subjects · English Language · WEN04 Investigating Language

Child language: theories of acquisition

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN04 Investigating Language

Pearson's reports name the same theorists in every Child Language question: Skinner, Chomsky, Piaget and Vygotsky, plus case studies of children with very limited input. Learn what each claims and what evidence supports or challenges it. (Topic lesson: study the lessons for the one topic area your centre entered you for.)

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The four theories

TheoryClaimTypical evidence
Behaviourist (Skinner)Skinner (1957) proposed that language is learned through reinforcementPraise of early words; regional vocabulary is clearly learned
Nativist (Chomsky)Children have an innate language acquisition device (LAD) with built-in knowledge of human languages, described by universal grammar; Chomsky's 1959 review attacked Skinner's accountOverregularisation and the wug test show rules no one taught
Cognitive (Piaget)Language is tied to cognitive stages: sensorimotor (birth to about 2), then preoperational (2 to 7), when children begin to use language as symbolic thinking developsWords appear as the concepts behind them develop
Social interactionist (Vygotsky; Bruner)Language grows through social interaction; children learn within a zone of proximal development, with guided support called scaffolding (a term from Bruner, Wood and Ross, not Vygotsky)Caregivers expand, recast and prompt

OpenStax Psychology 2e (Skinner, Chomsky); Cowie, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (LAD, universal grammar); Baylor open textbook 10.1 and 10.3 (Piaget, Vygotsky, scaffolding).

Limited input: Genie and the hearing sons of deaf parents

Genie (Britannica) was admitted to hospital in Los Angeles in November 1970, aged 13, after extreme isolation. She learned many words and produced two-word phrases ('want milk') and, by late 1971, occasionally three, but despite instruction she never grasped grammar. Her case tested Lenneberg's critical period hypothesis (grammar is very hard to acquire after puberty).

Pearson's June 2024 and June 2025 reports credit answers citing Bard and Sachs (1977) and their case of 'Jim'. The fuller published study (Sachs, Bard and Johnson, 1981) followed two hearing boys of deaf parents with very restricted spoken input at home. The older boy, first seen at 3;9, had heard language from television and briefly at nursery school, yet his speech was below age level and structurally unusual. After adult intervention his speech improved, and by 4;2 the unusual patterns had gone. This suggests that interaction, not just exposure (such as television), drives acquisition.

Evaluating

No single theory explains everything. Pearson's June 2025 report praised answers that argued for a holistic view: exposure, caregiver interaction and consistent practice all matter. Use evidence to weigh theories: overregularisation challenges pure imitation; the Jim case challenges exposure without interaction; Genie supports an innate window for grammar.

Worked example

Statement: 'Children only need to hear language to acquire it.' Use two case studies.

  1. Against: the older boy in Sachs, Bard and Johnson heard television but his speech was delayed and unusual until adult intervention.
  2. Genie: very limited input before 13 and grammar never acquired: timing and interaction matter.
  3. Partly for: nativists argue the LAD needs only exposure to trigger it.
  4. Judgement: hearing language is necessary but not sufficient; interaction is needed.

Answer: Exposure is necessary but not sufficient: the case studies show the role of interaction and timing.

Key idea: Skinner: reinforcement. Chomsky: LAD, universal grammar. Piaget: cognitive stages. Vygotsky: ZPD; Bruner, Wood and Ross: scaffolding. Genie: critical period. Bard and Sachs (Sachs, Bard and Johnson 1981): TV exposure without interaction was not enough. Evaluate holistically.

Check yourself

  1. Which theory says language is learned through reinforcement?
    • Nativism (Chomsky)
    • Cognitive theory (Piaget)
    • Behaviourism (Skinner)
    • Critical period hypothesis
    Show answer

    Behaviourism (Skinner). Skinner (1957): language is learned through reinforcement.

  2. The language acquisition device is part of
    • Chomsky's nativist theory
    • Skinner's behaviourism
    • Piaget's stages
    • Berko's wug test
    Show answer

    Chomsky's nativist theory. Cowie: the LAD embodies built-in knowledge about human languages.

  3. Vygotsky's zone of proximal development is best described as
    • the part of the brain for language
    • the age when babbling starts
    • the range of skills a child can manage with guidance but not yet alone
    • a type of overextension
    Show answer

    the range of skills a child can manage with guidance but not yet alone. Learning happens within this range, with guided support (scaffolding).

  4. Genie was discovered at age
    • 3
    • 13
    • 6
    • 1
    Show answer

    13. Britannica: admitted to Children's Hospital Los Angeles on 4 November 1970, aged 13.

  5. What does the case of the older son of deaf parents (Sachs, Bard and Johnson, 1981) suggest?
    • Television is the best way to learn language
    • Language is purely innate and needs no input
    • Deaf parents cannot raise hearing children
    • Exposure to television alone did not give typical language; interaction helped
    Show answer

    Exposure to television alone did not give typical language; interaction helped. His unusual patterns had gone by 4;2, after intervention.

  6. Piaget's stage from birth to about 2 years is the
    • preoperational stage
    • sensorimotor stage
    • formal operational stage
    • telegraphic stage
    Show answer

    sensorimotor stage. Baylor open textbook: the sensorimotor substages run from birth to about 24 months.

  7. Explain why overregularisations such as 'goed' challenge a purely behaviourist explanation.
    Show answer

    Because adults do not say 'goed', so the child cannot have imitated it; it shows the child applying a rule.. Imitation cannot explain forms that adults never produce.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.