All subjects · English Language · WEN04 Investigating Language

Global English: attitudes, standards and preservation

Edexcel IAL English Language · WEN04 Investigating Language

Every recent Global English Section B question has been a debate about attitudes: embrace or conform, preserve or let go. This lesson gives you the concepts to argue either side. (Topic lesson: study the lessons for the one topic area your centre entered you for.)

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Concepts the examiners credit

ConceptUse it to argue
Prescriptivism and descriptivismPrescriptivists judge forms as correct or incorrect against a standard; descriptivists describe how people actually speak. Pearson's reports note candidates referencing prescriptivism for Appalachian, Gullah and Nigerian English.
Accommodation theory (Giles)Speakers converge (adapt their speech to become more like the listener's) or diverge (accentuate differences). Giles and Ogay: convergence is often driven by a desire for approval, divergence by a desire to stress distinctiveness, usually group identity.
Covert and overt prestige (Trudgill)Standard forms carry overt prestige; local forms carry covert prestige that speakers rarely admit but that affects behaviour.
Language changeNamed in the reports: varieties develop through contact, isolation and globalisation.

Concepts named in Pearson's WEN04 reports for Global English (June 2024, January 2025, June 2025).

Building the debate

Arguments for conformity to a standard: wider intelligibility, access to education and jobs, international communication. Arguments for embracing or preserving the variety: identity, heritage, covert prestige, linguistic diversity, and the fact that varieties are rule-governed systems. The June 2025 report praised answers on isolation, attitudes to non-standard varieties, stigma and code-switching: many speakers do not choose one side but switch by context.

Avoid the trap

The June 2025 and January 2025 reports criticised answers that described a variety's history without answering the statement. Every paragraph must take a position on the question. Use your own data: for example, an interview clip where a speaker code-switches, or a news article showing changing attitudes.

Worked example

Statement: 'Speakers of Appalachian English should adopt Standard American English.' Plan two paragraphs.

  1. For: overt prestige and wider job access; prescriptive attitudes create stigma (evidence: media stereotypes you found).
  2. Against: Appalachian English is rule-governed (a-prefixing constraints), carries identity and covert prestige; speakers can code-switch instead of abandoning it.
  3. Judgement: code-switching gives access without losing identity.

Answer: A balanced debate ending in a judgement: code-switching rather than replacement, supported by data and concepts.

Key idea: Prescriptive vs descriptive; accommodation (converge, diverge); overt vs covert prestige; language change; code-switching. Take a position in every paragraph and use your own data.

Check yourself

  1. A prescriptive attitude to a variety
    • describes its forms neutrally
    • measures its vowels acoustically
    • judges its forms against a 'correct' standard
    • records it for preservation
    Show answer

    judges its forms against a 'correct' standard. Prescriptivism sets rules of correctness.

  2. A speaker deliberately uses more local forms to show pride in their community. This is
    • divergence
    • convergence
    • hypercorrection
    • relexification
    Show answer

    divergence. Giles and Ogay: divergence accentuates differences, often to stress group distinctiveness.

  3. Covert prestige is
    • the official prestige of the standard
    • prestige only in writing
    • positive value attached to non-standard forms that speakers rarely admit
    • a type of accent reduction
    Show answer

    positive value attached to non-standard forms that speakers rarely admit. Trudgill (1972).

  4. The June 2025 report credited discussion of code-switching because
    • it ends all variation
    • many speakers use the variety and the standard in different contexts
    • it is a phonological feature
    • it was the subtopic
    Show answer

    many speakers use the variety and the standard in different contexts. Switching by context complicates a simple either-or debate.

  5. Which Section B paragraph opening is weakest?
    • Embracing the variety protects identity, as my interview data suggests.
    • Conforming widens job access, though it risks stigma.
    • Code-switching shows the statement is too simple.
    • Appalachian English began in the 1700s when settlers arrived.
    Show answer

    Appalachian English began in the 1700s when settlers arrived.. History without a position does not answer the statement.

  6. Explain why code-switching can weaken an argument that speakers must choose between a local variety and the standard.
    Show answer

    Because speakers can use the standard in formal contexts and the local variety at home, keeping identity and access.. Code-switching lets speakers keep identity and gain access.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.